Preview Changes Port VS Freo - Rnd 18

[Seppo]

On the chopping block:
Suban, Ibbotson, Kepler, Mundy (inj)
In the mix:
Fyfe, Lower, Neale, Mayne & Dawson (if fit)

 

[Bradesmaen]

Mundy isnt injured.

Mzungu? Horrible player

 

[chinggis77]

Fyfe, Neale, Mayne and Dawson are definite ins. So there will be at least 4 outs.

I would think Roberton, Suban, if injured - Mundy and possibly Zac Clarke.

 

[Kickett Punches Read]

Out:
Suban- really disappointed with this guy, i really rated him, but he has offered us nothing this year
Mzungu: worst on ground. just a horrible footballer
Kepler: doesnt take his opportunities, gets a game on goof factor
Clarke: pretty ordinary today

In:
Mayne
Neale
Fyfe
Dawson

Really really disappointed with the second half, but not surprised.

 

[freocuz]

Fyfe, Neale, Mayne and Dawson are definite ins. So there will be at least 4 outs.

I would think Roberton, Suban, if injured - Mundy and possibly Zac Clarke.

I thought Roberton was pretty good today, one of the few who actually had any urgency when attacking the ball.

 

[Leslie_Chow]

In;
Mayne
Dawson
Fyfe



Out;
Suban- Spud
Mzungu- Spud
Kepler

Broughton and Lower could also come in...too many below average players still in the team

 

[Outshined]

Agree with most here so far. Suban and Mzungu were pretty bad. Suban's lack of progress has been frustrating to say the least.

 

[Scham]

I thought Roberton was pretty good today, one of the few who actually had any urgency when attacking the ball.

Yep, one of our best today.

 

[chinggis77]

In;
Mayne
Dawson
Fyfe



Out;
Suban- Spud
Mzungu- Spud
Kepler

Broughton and Lower could also come in...too many below average players still in the team

Surely Neale with 35 (or 38 possessions if you believe the West), should come in as well. He would be much better than a number of guys in the team.

 

[derPy]

ibbotsons lazy kick which gifted the giants a goal was beyond me

In: Fyfe, Lower, Neale, Mayne, Broughton

Out: Ibbotson, Suban, Kepler, Clarke, Spurr/duffield

 

[rgauci]

OUT: The liabilities
IN: The great white hope

=

OUT: Suban, Ibbotson, Clarke
IN: Mayne, Lower, Fyfe

Tempted to bring in Neale, but not sure who to leave out.

 

[derPy]

ibbotsons lazy kick which gifted the giants a goal was beyond me

In: Fyfe, Lower, Neale, Mayne, Broughton

Out: Ibbotson, Suban, Kepler, Clarke, Spurr/duffield

 

[Andy Brennan]

Mzungu has legs and arms made of noodles. The guy can't stick a tackle and goes to ground every time he gets near a ****ing opponent.

 

[Seppo]

For all those suggesting it, we will not be dropping both Kepler AND Clarke.

Kepler was the worst of the two. Did anyone notice that thing strapped to his leg under the bandage?

 

[332docker]

Can't wait to see mello back in the side. He is better than Son son. Harder at the ball, Better defensive tackling and pressure acts, just as good a kick and probably a better set shot, not sure it will be this week, but the sooner the better...

 

[Scham]

Kepler and Suban both had shockers.

Ibbo had his usual bad moments.

MDB, Barlow and Clarke had off days, so too Balla who was a bit off with his disposals.

It really depends on who's available really as to who goes out but I'd suggest that Suban and Kepler will go regardless.

 

[Andy Brennan]

Lol Suban 10 disposals at 50% eff with 75% time on ground.

Sutcliffe 10 disposals at 70% eff with 31% time on ground.

 

[Bradesmaen]

Lol Suban 10 disposals at 50% eff with 75% time on ground.

Sutcliffe 10 disposals at 70% eff with 31% time on ground.

One was playing midfield, the other was down back.

 

[eastfreo75]

In: Fyfe, Dawson, Neale, Mayne

Out: Ibbotson, Suban, Druffield, Z Clarke,

 

[StingBitten]

Expect a few chops... bye bye Suban and Bradley.

Roberton was fantastic today! Were you watching the same game?

 

[Scham]

Can't wait to see mello back in the side. He is better than Son son. Harder at the ball, Better defensive tackling and pressure acts, just as good a kick and probably a better set shot, not sure it will be this week, but the sooner the better...

I think we can fit both of them in. Especially if Mayne isn't available this week, and particularly with the form of Clarke and Kepler.

 

[E Shed]

Can't wait to see mello back in the side. He is better than Son son. Harder at the ball, Better defensive tackling and pressure acts, just as good a kick and probably a better set shot, not sure it will be this week, but the sooner the better...

I don't dispute your right to this opinion but the idea that Mellington is a better kick than Walters is a strange one. Walters would be about the best kick in our team (IMO) besides maybe Hill either at Goal or setting them up so you pretty much rate him better than that?

 

[Arcassius]

For all those suggesting it, we will not be dropping both Kepler AND Clarke.

Kepler was the worst of the two. Did anyone notice that thing strapped to his leg under the bandage?

Yeah saw it - looked like some weird kind of rectangular block, figured it was his house arrest GPS device

I'd drop kep just for being shitful in front of goal - he's become 2011 Mayne

 

[yakka man]

INS - Fyfe, Lower or Neale.

OUTS - Suban, Clarke.

 

[Spoken4]

INS - Fyfe, Lower or Neale.

OUTS - Suban, Clarke.

Is Lower right? Read in the Sunday Times that he "does not look 100%"

Kepler, aside from the yips in front of goal, played well today.