Preview Changes: R5 vs Richmond - Saturday April 16, 4.05pm ACST @ Adelaide Oval

[Scorpus]

IN:
McAdam, Cook, Berry

OUT:
Hinge, Rowe, Schoenberg

Hinge dropped and named as an emergency, not injured

 

[kirky]

Milera has been stinking it up in the sanfl.. his field kicking is totally off.. way too many turnovers..

Would rather gove Parnell or Davis a run at it..

Has Milera ever shown his potential?

From what I’ve seen he panics when under pressure (mind you he is no orphan there in our team).

 

[jackster83]

Brown, Crouch, Hinge, Schoenberg out.

Hamill, Berry, Worrell, Cook in.

Jones goes back to the Brown role he played last year.

Sloane to half forward/wing.

Murphy into the middle.

ROB on his last chance. A poor first half against Richmond and I'd sub him out at half time.

 

[kirky]

Why don't you just name the reserves side? Suggest we do 22 changes?

We lost by a kick, they're not going to make six changes.

Plus, you brought in four talls and only dropped one, FFS.

Perhaps the poster in question should stick to making apricot slices.

 

[George Kramer]

Brown, Crouch, Hinge, Schoenberg out.

Hamill, Berry, Worrell, Cook in.

Jones goes back to the Brown role he played last year.

Sloane to half forward/wing.

Murphy into the middle.

ROB on his last chance. A poor first half against Richmond and I'd sub him out at half time.

Schoenberg was good against Port and then we reduced his midfield minutes, we are messing with his head and confidence.
ROB should go.

But if we are serious about rewarding performance, Hamill and Berry have to come in.

 

[texas_ranger]

Crouch and Schoenberg both 60% TOG is surprising to see.

Might not be popular but have a feeling Gollant could make way for Thilthorpe, which could stretch Richmond's defence

 

[Eagleboy2011]

Id like to see Rob have a spell in the 2's. Ive liked him for a while but at the moment he has no weapons. His defensive marking was great but atm he could not take one to save himself. His tap rucking to advantage is non existent.

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

What I'd like to see, and what I expect to see, are two very different things.

I'd like to see ROB dropped, and replaced by Strachan. ROB's start to the season has been way below ordinary, and Strachan was exceptional in the 2 games he played late last year. However, Nicks' loyalty to the senior players means there's almost no chance of this happening.

I'd like to see at least one of Sloane & Crouch dropped, and replaced by Berry (and Hately if both were to go). Sloane & Crouch have both been woeful since returning, regardless of what the newspapers say (their authors not having bothered to watch the game). Sloane is completely cooked, and Crouch just doesn't hurt the opposition enough to make up for his occasional clangers. Once again, not going to happen.

I'd like to see Frampton dropped, forever. That experiment has to finish, and Frampton's career along with it. Whether he's replaced by Murray, McAsey, Borlase or Worrell is of little importance to me. I just want to see Frampton banished for good. I think there's a reasonable chance of this one happening.

What I expect to see is one change, and one change only (don't forget that we lost by under a goal, away from home):
OUT: Hinge (inj)
IN: Cook, with Berry (sub)

I really don't understand why anyone would be calling for Rowe to be dropped. He's actually been pretty good so far this year.

Can’t argue with any of this. I wouldn’t underestimate Nicks commitment to Frampton (having spent time together at Port). What other player has been afforded the opportunity to reinvent themselves like Frampton under Nicks? I think this one has a year or two to run before finally getting a line put through it.

And that’ll be 20-30 games that we should be putting into Worrell.

 

[craig crowing]

Club probably:
Oh the effort was great we were just unlucky. How good is OUR CAPTAIN RORY SLOANE.
Out: Hinge
In: Milera

What the hell is all this bring in Milera as he is struggling in the SANFL after missing 2 years of football and for all the skills never reached any real consistent full games in past.
Where Hamill doing well and found confidence in 2s and showed can compete at AFL level over last 2 years , whilst kicking not always best he can certainly give us that run we need .
Then other posters have a million changes which not realistic but don't have Cook in 22 who one of our most talented kids who came on and was huge in that frantic last qtr.
And still have McHenry in team who is a liability in forward entries and not one idea how to score a goal that's apart from all those stupid frees etc.
Yes Sloane ,Smith and ROB should be dropped but not going to happen.

 

[texanmike]

Can’t argue with any of this. I wouldn’t underestimate Nicks commitment to Frampton (having spent time together at Port). What other player has been afforded the opportunity to reinvent themselves like Frampton under Nicks? I think this one has a year or two to run before finally getting a line put through it.

And that’ll be 20-30 games that we should be putting into Worrell.

Yep that last sentence is so frustrating, we’ve seen enough of a lot of our players at AFL level where you can say nope he ain’t got it and then we are still giving these no hopers games over more talented and well performing players in the 2s. If this is a rebuild then do it right, for starters dropping our injured and worse performed Captain in Adelaide crows history Rory Sloane and bringing in Berry.

 

[Drakescoffeecake]

Out: Frampton, Schoenberg, Jones, Hinge
In: McAsey, Cook, Hately, Berry

 

[LoBu]

Lol at people having Sloane out. He's NEVER getting dropped. Same with Crouch.

Crouch has been dropped multiple times, he is not a lock.

Weirdly he is listed in the best players for both AFL website and the Advertiser, not sure if they actually watched the match though.

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

Crouch has been dropped multiple times, he is not a lock.

Weirdly he is listed in the best players for both AFL website and the Advertiser, not sure if they actually watched the match though.

Is that the same Crouch who couldn’t stay on two legs half the game?

 

[LoBu]

Is that the same Crouch who couldn’t stay on two legs half the game?

That's him, the one who wouldn't kick the ball

 

[Mutineer]

I want to see Strachan for ROB just to see if it improves our center clearances, but it won't happen. Sloane won't be dropped either, as much as it needs to happen

Out: Mrouch, Jones, Frampton, Hinjury
In: Berry, Hately, McAsey, Cook

B: Brown, Butts, Doedee
HB: Smith, McAsey, Sloane
C: Dawson, Laird, Sholl
HF: McHenry, Walker, Rowe
F: Rachele, Himmelberg, Gollant
R: ROB, Keays, Schoenberg
I/C: Berry, Hately, Cook, Murphy

Rotate Keays, Laird, Schoenberg, Berry, Hately, and spurts of Rachele and Murphy through the middle.

No to McAsey coming in, if anyone comes in for Frampton we should go back to Murray. McAsey isn't even playing the key back role in the Snaffle.

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

That's him, the one who wouldn't kick the ball

Hang on, just to be clear. The same Crouch who ignored Laird streaming inside F50 for a clear goal so he could shank a kick to the forward pocket and out of bounds? That Crouch?

 

[Jinglebells32]

Yep, although McAsey was ok this weekend. Not our best KPD, but didn’t drop his chin which is a massive improvement for him.

McAsey played the best game that I've seen him play. My only criticism was that he went to ground just about every time that he took a mark, which held up play.

 

[WetCrow1991]

What the hell is all this bring in Milera as he is struggling in the SANFL after missing 2 years of football and for all the skills never reached any real consistent full games in past.
Where Hamill doing well and found confidence in 2s and showed can compete at AFL level over last 2 years , whilst kicking not always best he can certainly give us that run we need .
Then other posters have a million changes which not realistic but don't have Cook in 22 who one of our most talented kids who came on and was huge in that frantic last qtr.
And still have McHenry in team who is a liability in forward entries and not one idea how to score a goal that's apart from all those stupid frees etc.
Yes Sloane ,Smith and ROB should be dropped but not going to happen.

Thanks Grandpa.

 

[SydCrow]

Surely Berry gets a run. Not sold on Hately but apparently he also played well. McAdam has to get a game soon. Murphy + McAnt + Rowe = One AFL standard small forward.

Frampton looks good with ball in hand but as a key defender he is a liability.

 

[Slippery Pete]

Frampton looks good with ball in hand but as a key defender he is a liability.

 

[hey shorty]

Jones should also be on the chopping block. He looked lost out there today. Surely Hamill/Mcpherson are better longer term defensive options.

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

First half yes, putrid.

2nd half made a number of good plays. I'd have one of those 2 in for Brown though

 

[hey shorty]

Schoenberg was good against Port and then we reduced his midfield minutes, we are messing with his head and confidence.
ROB should go.

But if we are serious about rewarding performance, Hamill and Berry have to come in.

Good is a bit much, he had a great 2nd half but was ordinary in the first.

He needs a spell in the 2s but there's 2 senior guys I'd flick first, but we won't.

 

[LoBu]

Hang on, just to be clear. The same Crouch who ignored Laird streaming inside F50 for a clear goal so he could shank a kick to the forward pocket and out of bounds? That Crouch?

I'm talking about the Crouch that nobody wanted for free last year

 

[SydCrow]

View attachment 1369047

what about Guelfi???

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

No to McAsey coming in, if anyone comes in for Frampton we should go back to Murray. McAsey isn't even playing the key back role in the Snaffle.

My thinking is Worrell is next in line - play him on the more mobile Riewoldt.

Butts can take Lynch.

 

[George Kramer]

Good is a bit much, he had a great 2nd half but was ordinary in the first.

He needs a spell in the 2s but there's 2 senior guys I'd flick first, but we won't.

If I said great you’d have a point. I said good, I think an ordinary half and a great half would get you good wouldn’t it?