Prediction Changes: Round 5 Vs Adelaide Crows + Pre-match discussion

Remove this Banner Ad

Worth a listen


Tucker to play Peel reserves. Interesting use of Peel reserves this year to get very basic minutes into guys

Think Logue and Lobb come in at a minimum
Think it’s because the Peel league game is out in the country and they don’t want him to drive 2 hours on a rehabilitating hammy
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Yeah Peel Reserves and Colts are at Freo oval. League game is in Pingelly. The facilities at Pingelly look amazing but 2 hours drive each way is a hike.

Peel Reserves might win a game for once.
 
Last edited:
The way JL is talking it looks like Treacy will miss. Saying meek will be very stiff after the way he's played to be dropped. Would have loved a forward line of Treacy lobb tabs sturt and walters.

Jeez, I hope not. I actually think he was saying that so Meek will feel better about it when he pulls him in for a chat.

I don't really rate Adelaide in the ruck and reckon Darcy and Lobb can work them over without too much hassle. Saw enough against the Hawks to think that if Treacy gets a run of games he's going to blossom. I know he missed that first one, but hey, he's an 18yr old kid who's nerves put him off, they'll go once he sinks one. Also the likelihood is that he's going to miss a few through tiredness and possibly suspension, so I'd pick him when fit.
 
The way JL is talking it looks like Treacy will miss. Saying meek will be very stiff after the way he's played to be dropped. Would have loved a forward line of Treacy lobb tabs sturt and walters.
Didn't sound that way to me at all, Seems like Meek will miss, says that he has been good but we can't drop a small for Lobb and Meek seems the obvious one hence the talk about him
 
Jeez, I hope not. I actually think he was saying that so Meek will feel better about it when he pulls him in for a chat.

I don't really rate Adelaide in the ruck and reckon Darcy and Lobb can work them over without too much hassle. Saw enough against the Hawks to think that if Treacy gets a run of games he's going to blossom. I know he missed that first one, but hey, he's an 18yr old kid who's nerves put him off, they'll go once he sinks one. Also the likelihood is that he's going to miss a few through tiredness and possibly suspension, so I'd pick him when fit.

O'Brien is a very good (and perhaps underrated) ruckman. Has been a force over the last two weeks. I would argue he is #5 ruckman in the league after Grundy (the good Grundy, has had some quiet games this year), Gawn, Marshall and Naitanui.
 
O'Brien is a very good (and perhaps underrated) ruckman. Has been a force over the last two weeks. I would argue he is #5 ruckman in the league after Grundy (the good Grundy, has had some quiet games this year), Gawn, Marshall and Naitanui.

Fair enough, sounds like I need to pay more attention to him. I could have my purple specs on but I still think Darcy has him covered in the ruck, Lobb definitely not, but he'll beat him around the ground.
 
I legit reckon by the end of next season there's a chance darcy is the best ruckman in the comp.
i think he can average decent amount of disposals, score involvements, taps and goals. other ruckman do not have the forward craft that he does.
imagine these averages;
disposals; 15
score invovlements; 5
hitouts; 20 to 25
goals; 1.5

thats an unbelievable ruckman
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I legit reckon by the end of next season there's a chance darcy is the best ruckman in the comp.
i think he can average decent amount of disposals, score involvements, taps and goals. other ruckman do not have the forward craft that he does.
imagine these averages;
disposals; 15
score invovlements; 5
hitouts; 20 to 25
goals; 1.5

thats an unbelievable ruckman
He’ll never get that recognition because he’s not the flashy mobile ruckman but that’s a good thing IMO because he’ll be cheaper to keep. While he likely won’t be the best, I think he’ll be the most valuable considering his impact and contract
 
Didn't sound that way to me at all, Seems like Meek will miss, says that he has been good but we can't drop a small for Lobb and Meek seems the obvious one hence the talk about him
I agree, It just sounded to me like he wasn’t going to get dropped. We do know JL doesn’t mind playing a few games though.
 
Jlo is so hard to read. the media team could run a story about how fyfe was back into the team. then longmuir could hold a press conference and make me doubt fyfe was a walk up start.

longmuir is a sneaky slippery one.

#Never forget his treacy shenanigans.


Ha could not agree more!

Jlo is getting impossible to read, everyone commenting seems to have gotten a different read from his interview.

I am not sure that there will be any changes!!!!
 
Ha could not agree more!

Jlo is getting impossible to read, everyone commenting seems to have gotten a different read from his interview.

I am not sure that there will be any changes!!!!
I agree with this sentiment. I believe changes are unlikely - I just think having depth becoming available outside the current team is not a situation we are very familiar with here at Freo.
 
He’ll never get that recognition because he’s not the flashy mobile ruckman but that’s a good thing IMO because he’ll be cheaper to keep. While he likely won’t be the best, I think he’ll be the most valuable considering his impact and contract
Pretty soon, Mr Gawn will have to "Hold the door!"
 
He’ll never get that recognition because he’s not the flashy mobile ruckman but that’s a good thing IMO because he’ll be cheaper to keep. While he likely won’t be the best, I think he’ll be the most valuable considering his impact and contract
This is perfect, because you don't want to over-invest in your ruckman.
 
The way JL is talking it looks like Treacy will miss. Saying meek will be very stiff after the way he's played to be dropped. Would have loved a forward line of Treacy lobb tabs sturt and walters.

Treacy was with the forwards when the WAFL boys went off the ground and at the end. He will play.
 
This is perfect, because you don't want to over-invest in your ruckman.
Yeah, you'll seriously never have to pay him more than 500 - 600k. I'd rather what he puts out and have 400k to put somewhere else and have Grundy getting some empty stats
 
Would something like this be too tall?

Colyer Sturt Frederick
Treacy Taberner Lobster

With Darcy on the interchange and Meek in the middle. My thoughts are we lock Darcy in the forward line, Meek rucks in the mid and helps in the backline. Lobster roams around and gets us out of trouble.
 
Would something like this be too tall?

Colyer Sturt Frederick
Treacy Taberner Lobster

With Darcy on the interchange and Meek in the middle. My thoughts are we lock Darcy in the forward line, Meek rucks in the mid and helps in the backline. Lobster roams around and gets us out of trouble.
I think so. It's hard to justify 2 rucks + Lobb.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Prediction Changes: Round 5 Vs Adelaide Crows + Pre-match discussion

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top