- Sep 26, 2012
- 36,169
- 55,209
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I'd have Dale over Beams even though Beams won BnF
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 6 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
What about Bobby ‘Norm’ Hill?I have thought about malthouse vs mcrae and it's a tough one. but for me malthouse longevity to make 2 grand finals with a not so great playing list and then to win a flag a decade later still warrants more recognition. however mcrae has every opportunity to prove his longevity in coming years too.
Let’s not go too farWhat about Bobby ‘Norm’ Hill?
Easily ahead of Adams or Liccura
Norm Smith in a flag team.Let’s not go too far
Norm Smith in a flag team.
Something Adams and Licca can only dream of.
Licurria was a plodderSo JDG in for Buckley as premiership players are instantly better?
Adams arguably played a better grand final. Only difference was the team lost.Norm Smith in a flag team.
Something Adams and Licca can only dream of.
No current season stats available
No current season stats available
No current season stats available
No current season stats available
No current season stats available
No current season stats available
No current season stats available
No current season stats available
No current season stats available
No current season stats available
No current season stats available
No current season stats available
No current season stats available
No current season stats available
No current season stats available
No current season stats available
Without Buckley, we weren't given a hope. Licca played such a blinder that night. And Ben Johnson's tackle on P.Burgoyne, wowee.Adams arguably played a better grand final. Only difference was the team lost.
Licuria had 40 touches in one of the most famous finals wins in club history. Not that I would name Licca, but put some respect on their names.
j Daicos has to be in the first team imo. AA, BnF in premiership year etcMy post-2024 team
Last year's flag helped a few players consolidate their positions, though it's not the be all and end all of picking my side. Those who didn't win premierships deserve as much respect for making us as good as they could
Only footy played in the 21st century (2001-) counts
B: Brayden Maynard* - Ben Reid - James Clement
HB: Jeremy Howe* - Darcy Moore* - Heath Shaw
C: Steele Sidebottom* - Dane Swan - Dale Thomas
HF: Jordan De Goey* - Travis Cloke - Alan Didak
F: Leon Davis - Anthony Rocca - Jamie Elliott*
R: Brodie Grundy - Nathan Buckley - Scott Pendlebury*
I: Jack Crisp* - Chris Tarrant - Nick Daicos* - Taylor Adams
And for some amusement, a reserves team
B: Ben Johnson - Simon Prestigiacomo - Nick Maxwell
HB: Heritier Lumumba - Shane Wakelin - Scott Burns
C: Josh Daicos* - Dayne Beams - Adam Treloar
HF: Tarkyn Lockyer - Brody Mihocek* - Will Hoskin-Elliott*
F: Paul Medhurst - Darcy Cameron* - Bobby Hill*
R: Darren Jolly - Paul Licuria - Luke Ball
I: Shane O'Bree - Isaac Quaynor* - Jarryd Blair - Josh Thomas
Lumumba, Grundy, Beams, Adams.CHANGES AT END OF 2024:
INS: J.DAICOS, N.DAICOS
OUTS: D.THOMAS, T.LOCKYER
FB J.CLEMENT J.HOWE* B.MAYNARD* HB J.CRISP* D.MOORE* H.LUMUMBA C S.SIDEBOTTOM* N.BUCKLEY (c) J.DAICOS* HF A.DIDAK T.CLOKE D.BEAMS FF L.DAVIS A.ROCCA C.TARRANT RR B.GRUNDY S.PENDLEBURY* (vc) D.SWAN INT N.DAICOS* P.LICURIA T.ADAMS - S.BURNS COACH: MICK MALTHOUSE
A quarter of the way through the century for the mathematically illiterate, and two famous additions come in.
Nick is on the bench for no other reason than he has only played 3 seasons and the midfield is incredible however it is obviously only a matter of time before he is in starting 18.
Thoughts?
CHANGES AT END OF 2024:
INS: J.DAICOS, N.DAICOS
OUTS: D.THOMAS, T.LOCKYER
FB J.CLEMENT J.HOWE* B.MAYNARD* HB J.CRISP* D.MOORE* H.LUMUMBA C S.SIDEBOTTOM* N.BUCKLEY (c) J.DAICOS* HF A.DIDAK T.CLOKE D.BEAMS FF L.DAVIS A.ROCCA C.TARRANT RR B.GRUNDY S.PENDLEBURY* (vc) D.SWAN INT N.DAICOS* P.LICURIA T.ADAMS - S.BURNS COACH: MICK MALTHOUSE
A quarter of the way through the century for the mathematically illiterate, and two famous additions come in.
Nick is on the bench for no other reason than he has only played 3 seasons and the midfield is incredible however it is obviously only a matter of time before he is in starting 18.
Thoughts?
Yeah I reckon he did a good job with the teamMan you guys are idiots. Bloke has initiated a friendly discussion on our board about what our best side is so far this century. Grow up
Your recency bias is a bit muchWhat about Bobby ‘Norm’ Hill?
Easily ahead of Adams or Liccura
How many Norms did Adams and Licca win?Your recency bias is a bit much
Is that all you're in with the club for? Respecting those who won premierships and not those who didn't? Very ordinary from youHow many Norms did Adams and Licca win?
I respect Adams and Licca enormously. But if I’m picking a side from the 21st century I’d have Hill ahead of them.Is that all you're in with the club for? Respecting those who won premierships and not those who didn't? Very ordinary from you
Man you guys are idiots. Bloke has initiated a friendly discussion on our board about what our best side is so far this century. Grow up