List Mgmt. COLLINGWOOD Trade and F/A Discussion 2023

[Mollythedolly]

With a bit more development, Ed Allan could play that type of role.

Draper, Macrae, Ryan, Carmichael and Harrison also in the discussion.

 

[Football God]

Haven't read the thread so apologies if mentioned but thoughts on Fyfe?

AFL Out of Contract Players in 2024

List of AFL players coming out of contract at the end of 2024.

www.footywire.com

Says he's out of contract, obviously unrestricted, played out of position (Similar to Titch)

Feel like he could rejuvenate his career under Fly, play in front of 80,000 every week and have one last crack at a flag.

 

[Doc1763]

Haven't read the thread so apologies if mentioned but thoughts on Fyfe?

AFL Out of Contract Players in 2024

List of AFL players coming out of contract at the end of 2024.

www.footywire.com

Says he's out of contract, obviously unrestricted, played out of position (Similar to Titch)

Feel like he could rejuvenate his career under Fly, play in front of 80,000 every week and have one last crack at a flag.

I'd love him at the Pies, but you wouldn't be pay overs for him now.

 

[brysie]

I just wouldn’t take Parish as a FA
Surely there are better players to invest our cap on

James Jordon from Melbourne is someone who has impressed me when I've seen him play and would provide good competition and eventually transition for our wings. He's also a free agent at the end of this season.

Kane Farrell from Port is also a player I hope we're monitoring. He's someone I think we could use to improve our depth in the forward or back half given his kicking abilities.

 

[Gold Rocks]

steal

 

[Jen2310]

steal

Jay Clark seems to think we should be in the race for him.

Port Adelaide high-flyer Mitch Georgiades is “one of the most fascinating contract situations” in the league this year, News Corp AFL journalist Jay Clark says with Collingwood a potential suitor if he remains in the SANFL.
The 21-year-old key forward is out of contract at the end of the season.

He played the first two games of the season for the Power, but was dropped for the Showdown after a 2.5 start to the season.

“I think he is one of the most fascinating contract situations in the AFL,” he said.

“Because if he is not in the team, then I think it really leaves him vulnerable of leaving the footy club.

“They have (Charlie) Dixon, they have (Todd) Marshall, I think Scotty Lycett could leave the footy club at the end of the year

“They want to keep Georgiades, they see his potential but so do other clubs around the competition.

“So if you could come at Mitch Georgiades with a decent contract but more around the opportunities and a spot.”


Georgiades is from Western Australia but Clark said he could be in play for Melbourne clubs such as Collingwood.

“You look at Collingwood, (Brody) Mihocek is ageing, (Mason) Cox is ageing. Yes they have Dan McStay but is he the prime key forward that they haven’t had for a while?”

Clark said Georgiades was a polarising player among list managers.

“List managers are looking at Mitch Georgiades and thinking is this guy a 200-game key forward or are we not sure,” he said.

“He is from WA, I don’t know if the WA clubs are mad on him I’m not sure they are banging down the door.

“So for the Melbourne clubs I think it is an interesting space … I think there is an opportunity for a Melbourne club.

 

[Johno9911]

Jay Clark seems to think we should be in the race for him.

I'm not sure if he's one for us personally. Given his size and style, he would appear to be far to similar to AJ and Reef at this stage (granted I know there are long term aspirations for Reef to become a mid). No doubt I think he has some talent, but I think in terms of a KPF we need to be looking at a genuine 195-200cm, contested marking KPF such as Ben King or Aaron Naughton type.

 

[JuniorB]

Jay Clark seems to think we should be in the race for him.

He's only 21 and has some ability.
For the right price he could be worth a shot.
We took Jay Rantall with our first pick, 40, in that draft.
Noah Cumberland went at 43.

 

[JuniorB]

I'm not sure if he's one for us personally. Given his size and style, he would appear to be far to similar to AJ and Reef at this stage (granted I know there are long term aspirations for Reef to become a mid). No doubt I think he has some talent, but I think in terms of a KPF we need to be looking at a genuine 195-200cm, contested marking KPF such as Ben King or Aaron Naughton type.

The problem with King & Naughton is what we'd have to give up to get either of them.

 

[Jen2310]

He's only 21 and has some ability.
For the right price he could be worth a shot.
We took Jay Rantall with our first pick, 40, in that draft.
Noah Cumberland went at 43.

Port also picked him with the pick we gave to bris for beams, who then on-traded it to port.

 

[JuniorB]

Port also picked him with the pick we gave to bris for beams, who then on-traded it to port.

Yes, the Beams trade really bit us on the bum.
If we'd kept our first round pick that year, we could have snared Sam De Koning.

 

[Johno9911]

The problem with King & Naughton is what we'd have to give up to get either of them.

While I do agree a King/Naughton would cost a lot more than Mitch, I personally think we are better of paying up for a genuine KPF (if we have the means and capital too) rather than counting our savings with another "not-quite" key-forward. We've been down that path a number of times - Jesse White, Quintin Lynch etc (heck even Kreuger, though I do have high hopes for him), it might just be time we open the purse strings and pay up for the genuine gun KPF?

 

[JuniorB]

While I do agree a King/Naughton would cost a lot more than Mitch, I personally think we are better of paying up for a genuine KPF (if we have the means and capital too) rather than counting our savings with another "not-quite" key-forward. We've been down that path a number of times - Jesse White, Quintin Lynch etc (heck even Kreuger, though I do have high hopes for him), it might just be time we open the purse strings and pay up for the genuine gun KPF?

Naughton would be good - he can play at both ends too.
Was a mad Collingwood supporter growing up.
He shares a house with Lippa.
Come on Lippa! Get in his ear!

 

[Bianconeri]

Jay Clark seems to think we should be in the race for him.

We have enough undersized key forwards

 

[Fat Jesus]

We have enough undersized key forwards

Ben King is the one to get.

 

[Couch Coach]

While I do agree a King/Naughton would cost a lot more than Mitch, I personally think we are better of paying up for a genuine KPF (if we have the means and capital too) rather than counting our savings with another "not-quite" key-forward. We've been down that path a number of times - Jesse White, Quintin Lynch etc (heck even Kreuger, though I do have high hopes for him), it might just be time we open the purse strings and pay up for the genuine gun KPF?

Genuine gun KPF: If it's a Cameron, Lynch, Naughton, King, etc. is fine.

However we have to be carefull as we could get flake like Daniher, Hipwood, etc.
They have to be able to do more than just mark and kick. They need to be system players like Mihocek. (Tackle, 1%, etc.)
McStay and Mihocek bring others into the game and a great for our current style.

 

[Do_Beta_Rapport]

We have enough undersized key forwards

This.

Georgiadis is listed at 192cm. Hard pass.

 

[brysie]

Genuine gun KPF: If it's a Cameron, Lynch, Naughton, King, etc. is fine.

However we have to be carefull as we could get flake like Daniher, Hipwood, etc.
They have to be able to do more than just mark and kick. They need to be system players like Mihocek. (Tackle, 1%, etc.)
McStay and Mihocek bring others into the game and a great for our current style.

This in my opinion is spot on - our gameplan doesn't justify spending a large portion of your cap on a single player, unless they're head and shoulders above the competition in that position.

Cameron is probably the most versatile player in the game and, arguably, the best. Naughton is quite similar in his ability to get around the ground, has a better contested marking capability than Cameron, however lets himself down in front of goal often.

Daniher is maybe the most frustrating player in the game. I fully expect him to kick 5 against us tomorrow night, before reverting back to quirky at best and erratic at worst. Hipwood is a luxury player - soft as butter. Reminds me of Schache.

In terms of realistic options, or those that don't involve us selling the farm (thereby lowering the risk), one of Sydney's tall forwards such as Amartey or McLean might be smart options.

 

[left at home]

This.

Georgiadis is listed at 192cm. Hard pass.

Never got why others wanted him so bad, good average footballer so far

 

[Fat Jesus]

Give me Toby Greene

4

Toby Greene

Age

30

Ht

182cm

Wt

85kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

22.7

5star

K

12.5

5star

HB

10.2

5star

M

4.8

5star

T

3.0

5star

G

1.2

4star

D

17.5

4star

K

9.5

4star

HB

8.0

4star

M

4.8

4star

T

1.0

2star

G

2.3

5star

D

26.6

5star

K

12.4

5star

HB

14.2

5star

M

4.8

5star

T

3.6

5star

G

0.0

1star

. It's like having 2 DeGoeys in the team.

 

[No SPIN]

Jay Clark seems to think we should be in the race for him.

His Kicking is woeful

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Jay Clark seems to think we should be in the race for him.

Ewwwww. No.

 

[Pistol Night]

Give me Toby Greene. It's like having 2 DeGoeys in the team.

He would be a force in a team like ours now. Easily the best mid size forward in the comp. I love him but thats unpopular i think as most people prefer squeaky clean personalities over ability these days

 

[Fat Jesus]

Ewwwww. No.

Don't know much about this kid.

 

[Fat Jesus]

He would be a force in a team like ours now. Easily the best mid size forward in the comp. I love him but thats unpopular i think as most people prefer squeaky clean personalities over ability these days

We would be unstoppable with someone like him in our team.
Ben King is good looking into the future for us.
Right now Toby would suit flys game plan. Beast