List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2016 Part 3

[NT.Thunder]

Gotta start pulling triggers - let's get among it

 

[Rorzza]

I would love WC to give number 88 to Mitchell to wear on is brand new WC jumper!

 

[orion21]

No.....you're not reading what you wrote, Adams, wants to go back to WA, its right there in your first post on this

Aish wanted to go home to SA- He didn't. Clarke wanted to go home to Perth-He didn't. There is always an option other than home when these players ask for a trade. Yes he wants to go home but that doesn't mean he actually will if other clubs talk to him and his manager....

 

[Kadog]

After reading that we're in actual discussions for Rockliff, I really really want him to come.

Hook a GD fish ffs Pies!

 

[GoalSneak07]

After reading that we're in actual discussions for Rockliff, I really really want him to come.

Hook a GD fish ffs Pies!

We did last season in Treloar and already signed Wells this offseason. Whilst I like Rocky, I'd prefer us look for our needs ie. a key back.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

If Marcus Adams wants to go home, fair enough, but what surprises me it's during the reign of the greatest man manager Bevo (whatever happened to his surname? He's just Bevo now.)
How did Bevo not manage this man?


( Folks point of thispost is only to highlight players coming and going happens everywhere.)

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Aish wanted to go home to SA- He didn't. Clarke wanted to go home to Perth-He didn't. There is always an option other than home when these players ask for a trade. Yes he wants to go home but that doesn't mean he actually will if other clubs talk to him and his manager....

So using your approach, lets trade Marsh to Brisbane. He will get more game time there and strengthen their back line
Simple...its done and dusted

But if think this can't work, ask yourself why it can't?

 

[Baltimore Jack]

If Marcus Adams wants to go home, fair enough, but what surprises me it's during the reign of the greatest man manager Bevo (whatever happened to his surname? He's just Bevo now.)
How did Bevo not manage this man?


( Folks point of thispost is only to highlight players coming and going happens everywhere.)

Clearly its Buckley's fault...the bastard

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Clearly its Buckley's fault...the bastard

Always is!

 

[Jonno94]

If Marcus Adams wants to go home, fair enough, but what surprises me it's during the reign of the greatest man manager Bevo (whatever happened to his surname? He's just Bevo now.)
How did Bevo not manage this man?


( Folks point of thispost is only to highlight players coming and going happens everywhere.)

It would all be about the money, Adams is 23 and just got drafted last year so he would be on regular draftee wages.

 

[Aishole]

Aish wanted to go home to SA- He didn't. Clarke wanted to go home to Perth-He didn't. There is always an option other than home when these players ask for a trade. Yes he wants to go home but that doesn't mean he actually will if other clubs talk to him and his manager....

I don't remember aish coming out and saying he wanted to go home? I recall him requesting a trade and nominating us.

 

[Apex36]

Aish wanted to go home to SA- He didn't. Clarke wanted to go home to Perth-He didn't. There is always an option other than home when these players ask for a trade. Yes he wants to go home but that doesn't mean he actually will if other clubs talk to him and his manager....

Aish never ever at any stage said that he wanted to go home to SA. That was an assumption that was made by supporters and the media.

 

[orion21]

So using your approach, lets trade Marsh to Brisbane. He will get more game time there and strengthen their back line
Simple...its done and dusted

But if think this can't work, ask yourself why it can't?

There is nothing wrong with us asking the question of would he be interested in playing for us!!!! Again YES he stated he wants to go home but that does not mean only Eagles and Freo should inquire about him. Many players change their minds. If its a no then that's ok, but we should be always looking to strengthen our list weaknesses and he would certainly help our backline...

 

[westozpie]

If Marcus Adams wants to go home, fair enough, but what surprises me it's during the reign of the greatest man manager Bevo (whatever happened to his surname? He's just Bevo now.)
How did Bevo not manage this man?


( Folks point of thispost is only to highlight players coming and going happens everywhere.)

 

[TradeDraft]

Barrett is such a flog, he's still saying that Collingwood put Aish on the trade table (through Gubby) even though Hine said that under no circumstances would he be traded. I really ******* hate Barrett.

That why I don't listen to Trade Radio as all they talk is Shit

 

[Saintly Viewed]

It would all be about the money, Adams is 23 and just got drafted last year so he would be on regular draftee wages.

Could be.
I just assumed he'd be given a medal or something....

I'm being cheeky ofcourse. Things happen at every club

 

[HFF]

Marsh may have not thought this one through well enough.
Freo after Hamling
WCE have options aplenty
Now Marcus Adams wants to go to WA too.

Nathan Brown similar boat.
Had a contract offer from us, waited it out due to North's interest.
They've since gone cold and our offer has been removed or reduced leaving him in limbo.

Either poor decisions by the players or poor guidance from their management.

 

[TradeDraft]

His first declaration was that we put Greenwood and Aish on the table, given it's now came out it was Greenwood to Brisbane I very much doubt Aish would be on the same table. Calling bullshit on this one.

At the members forum Buckley was scathing of the medias treatment of Aish early in the year. Wonder if this is connected, some sort of weird payback?

EDIT:
So, it seems Barrett is going with the same club, like Brisbane would want Aish back or Aish Brisbane.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-10-14/sliding-doors-afl-trade-period-heats-up

Barrett must be making a lot of Money as 99% stuff he says is Made Up or Has nothing behind it

 

[westozpie]

Totally agree Saintly, the Buckley haters carry on if a player leaves us that it's about bad culture or Buckley can't manage players, yet conveniently forget this sort of thing happens at every club

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Totally agree Saintly, the Buckley haters carry on if a player leaves us that it's about bad culture or Buckley can't manage players, yet conveniently forget this sort of thing happens at every club

There must be an absolute crap culture at GWS

 

[orion21]

Aish never ever at any stage said that he wanted to go home to SA. That was an assumption that was made by supporters and the media.

Pickering early at end of season and start of trade said on radio. I cannot remember which one, but I remember listening to it at work and thinking good luck to whoever gets him because he is overated at the time, that Aish would be happy to go back to SA as the lure of family was strong. Weeks later he nominated us.

 

[TradeDraft]

Wonder IF we do any Trades today?

 

[Aishole]

Pickering early at end of season and start of trade said on radio. I cannot remember which one, but I remember listening to it at work and thinking good luck to whoever gets him because he is overated at the time, that Aish would be happy to go back to SA as the lure of family was strong. Weeks later he nominated us.

Did aish ever nominate to go home? No. end of convo

 

[NT.Thunder]

I'd grab Hamling or Adams in a heart beat - I know they want to go West but they'd both be handy IMO

 

[TradeDraft]

Did aish ever nominate to go home? No. end of convo

Not that I remember. During the year there was Talk thar Carlton was in Talks with him