List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2016 Part 4 - The Final Day: Sailing into the abyss ...

[Matt_352]

Don't think he said that at all did he?

Read the comments after his post

 

[WalterBlaknWhte]

Can someone post Hine's exact comments on Marley?

Tone was more important.

Went from Derek casual-monotone to being dismissive.

 

[Axl the great]

Jaeger must be getting really impatient with all the delays.
This is for him.
(Bad language warning)

 

[Alexander323bc]

Can someone post Hine's exact comments on Marley?

"I honestly don't know mate" DH

 

[TradeDraft]

Re: Will Hoskin-Elliott "We're just about to catch up with the boys from Greater Western Sydney now."

So I say he is Job 1. Hopefully mean be announced that Trade Soon

 

[Gone Critical]

Club backed his character very publicly after the assault case. I am guessing here but his off-field behaviour, his attitude and his associations since then may have really put some noses out of joint.

Have a feeling we don't know the whole story with Marley.

I mentioned in a previous post I got told a couple of months ago by someone with strong links to the club that Marley was gone and it was because of his off field issues.

 

[frizzle]

Listening to the Hine interview I don't think he was disrespecting Marley. I think he was just putting the ball in the Roos court.
Give us a reasonable offer.

 

[4#Didak#4]

It seems no club values anything we have to trade. Cloke, Witts, Williams all going for way less than BF posters seem to think they're worth (although the talk of a 1st or 2nd rounder for Witts was always delusional). Williams is the one that I think we'll ultimately regret the most.

Its a buyers market this year for some reason. This has been competition wide. Clubs just are not prepared to give much up this year. I am not sure if this is a reflection on the draft - whether it is particularly deep this year or not - or a new attitude that if a player wants to move like Cloke, Lewis then you effectively just let them go as long as you are not paying their salary.

I do not think it is a reflection of their true value, its just the current market. In other years you could definitely expect more. Last year Witts was valued at a first rounder and refused to go to GWS.

 

[Sunbot]

Did Hine say anything about Witts? Swans are chasing the pick 10 re JOM deal so it's lost. Seems as if we are getting low balled on Witts

 

[TradeDraft]

Listening to the Hine interview I don't think he was disrespecting Marley. I think he was just putting the ball in the Roos court.
Give us a reasonable offer.

Well I don't think Marley has a Ton of Fan at Collingwood

 

[good4footy]

We are giving Marley away for a packet of chips and if we still can't get a buyer he will be delisted I reckon. Hine very dismissive -also didn't sound like their is much of a conversation happening between Marley / manager and the club.

Whatever is happening for the kid off field, club not happy.

 

[HFF]

Just keeps getting better and better…Williams gone, this is just too good.
Ball butchering no more.

 

[JustInsideFifty]

The sometimes strange valuations these guys on TR put on players doesn't bother me, they're entitled to their opinion.
But when they don't know the basic f-ing rules around trading it really gives me the shits.

 

[cleomenes]

Deeply disturbed by what seems to be happening with Marley Williams. Is our club disfunctional?

 

[Aishole]

If we're looking at a very late pick for marley idk why we don't just ask for Black.

 

[Sunbot]

Marley was gone when he was fighting Harvey

 

[Scodog10]

Club backed his character very publicly after the assault case. I am guessing here but his off-field behaviour, his attitude and his associations since then may have really put some noses out of joint.

Have a feeling we don't know the whole story with Marley.

Keep going back to that mysterious absence early year...

 

[Sunbot]

Keep going back to that mysterious absence early year...

Spot on

 

[PieBeast]

Tone was more important.

Went from Derek casual-monotone to being dismissive.

"I honestly don't know mate" DH

Thanks but that could mean a lot of things.

 

[unplugged]

Wish Trade Radio would ban themselves from mentioning the PSD. Every 5 minutes it's mentioned.

 

[Dynamics]

I mentioned in a previous post I got told a couple of months ago by someone with strong links to the club that Marley was gone and it was because of his off field issues.

It makes a lot more sense than ditching him for one bad season.

 

[Apex36]

9 minutes ago
DEREK HINE HERE

The Pies are confident with everything on their plate today.

List manager Derek Hine said the Travis Cloke, Will Hoskin-Elliott and Jack Frost deals should get done.

"We've just got to finalise a few little details with Travis Cloke and Frosty."
Re: Cloke "We've got a heads of agreement in place."

Re: Williams "I wouldn't have a clue. Seriously."

Re: Will Hoskin-Elliott "We're just about to catch up with the boys from Greater Western Sydney now."

Re: Lynden Dunn – “He can fill a role for us"

Nothing on Witts?

 

[Bay Pie]

9 minutes ago
DEREK HINE HERE

The Pies are confident with everything on their plate today.

List manager Derek Hine said the Travis Cloke, Will Hoskin-Elliott and Jack Frost deals should get done.

"We've just got to finalise a few little details with Travis Cloke and Frosty."
Re: Cloke "We've got a heads of agreement in place."

Re: Williams "I wouldn't have a clue. Seriously."

Re: Will Hoskin-Elliott "We're just about to catch up with the boys from Greater Western Sydney now."

Re: Lynden Dunn – “He can fill a role for us"

WHE - My interpretation, GWS need to clear his salary before sorting a trade deal for Deledio. Hopefully 2017 3rd rounder.

Williams - I heard that and thought he was surprised anyone had expressed an interest in Marley. It sounded like no one has spoken to Hine about him.

 

[Reens]

Adam Tomlinson on the move possibly?

 

[TradeDraft]

Adam Tomlinson on the move possibly?

Nope. He has Re-Signed