List Mgmt. Contract, Trade and Draft Discussions - 2024 Post Season

Whose future picks would you have preferred?


  • Total voters
    216

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
  • Thread starter
  • Moderator
  • #2


Quick links



Trade period
In:
12, F1, F2, F3, 73, Baker, Owies, Graham*
Out: 3, 63, F4, Barrass, Darling

*Free agent

Done deals

  • Jai Culley, Alex Witherden and Coby Burgiel delisted






  • Zane Trew, Jamaine Jones and Jordyn Baker delisted

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Just take the F1 and F2 on offer for TB from the Hawks at this stage. On trade the F1 to Richmond for Baker.

Take that over 15* and Baker and Hawks F1.

We need picks now, not 2025 draft
Imagine if we give them one future first and Richmond's team pull a Collingwood while ours surges to the grand final.

We'd all be wetting more than our own beds.
 
I can very much see a 2, 25, 44 for 5 and 9 deal coming between the Dees and North pantskyle

44 goes to Brisbane as main piece for Sharp, North probably take Tauru and Trainor. Dees get one of FOS and Lalor.
12+14+Tom de Koning +Moir

For TB and 3?
Otherwise **** off
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Imagine if we give them one future first and Richmond's team pull a Collingwood while ours surges to the grand final.

We'd all be wetting more than our own beds.
We’d be giving them the Hawks F1.

Very real option but better then trading back from 3 to 12 imo. At least we will also have their very low 2nd round as well to pair with our low 2nd rounder to bundle up and move right up again next year into the first round
 
Carlton & Hawks this, Baker wants that - let’s maybe get some shit done that actually benefits US

I find a lot of these trade rumours are based on the assumption that the plastic interstate clubs are feeders to the real heart and soul Victorian clubs. Look at the ridiculous trade scenarios floated for Harley Reid last year as a recent example.

Imagine the uproar if it was suggested Carlton would sell a pick 3 for two middling picks.
 
So we're into the 8th day of trade period and just two players have been traded:


A.Neal-Bullen for pick 28, and;
J.Darling for pick 68


Both were completed on day 1.



Riveting stuff this.


Further evidence that regardless of how long the period is, nothing gets done until there is a deadline involved.

Shouldn't be any more than five days (Mon-Fri).
 
[emoji6][emoji[emoji6]][emoji[emoji6]][emoji[emoji6]]" data-quote="WCEConnor" data-source="post: 0" class="bbCodeBlock bbCodeBlock--expandable bbCodeBlock--quote js-expandWatch">
He missed [emoji[emoji6]] games, and played a variety of roles in a bottom team. If you think Owies > Ryan, your on drugs.

And that’s another point. Ryan misses games, is never fit and actually isn’t in competition with owies for a spot…


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Just walk Baker through to the PSD. Tigers won't take him. Get him for free but unfortunately our club doesn't have the gumption to do that. We need to keep every possible pick in our current state not split a pick where we are going to get a guaranteed gun.
 
So we're into the 8th day of trade period and just two players have been traded:


A.Neal-Bullen for pick 28, and;
J.Darling for pick 68


Both were completed on day 1.



Riveting stuff this.


Further evidence that regardless of how long the period is, nothing gets done until there is a deadline involved.

Shouldn't be any more than five days (Mon-Fri).

That's a very cynical outlook.

Won't someone please think of the advertising revenue.
 
Few saints posters had a crack at a 3 team trade based off the Rhino tweet from yesterday.

SAINTS give: 8, F1, 27
SAINTS get: 3, 18, 51, Eagles F3

RICHMOND give: Baker, 18, 51
RICHMOND get: Saints F1, 27

EAGLES give: 3, F3
EAGLES get: 8, Baker

Points wise it works out (rates Baker at pick 10)

Your F3 can go to Richmond if need be.
 
Few saints posters had a crack at a 3 team trade based off the Rhino tweet from yesterday.

SAINTS give: 8, F1, 27
SAINTS get: 3, 18, 51, Eagles F3

RICHMOND give: Baker, 18, 51
RICHMOND get: Saints F1, 27

EAGLES give: 3, F3
EAGLES get: 8, Baker

Points wise it works out (rates Baker at pick 10)

Your F3 can go to Richmond if need be.
Eagles don't rate Baker anywhere near 10 though....
 
Few saints posters had a crack at a 3 team trade based off the Rhino tweet from yesterday.

SAINTS give: 8, F1, 27
SAINTS get: 3, 18, 51, Eagles F3

RICHMOND give: Baker, 18, 51
RICHMOND get: Saints F1, 27

EAGLES give: 3, F3
EAGLES get: 8, Baker

Points wise it works out (rates Baker at pick 10)

Your F3 can go to Richmond if need be.
Thats the best scenario I’ve seen for the Eagles in a while
 
Few saints posters had a crack at a 3 team trade based off the Rhino tweet from yesterday.

SAINTS give: 8, F1, 27
SAINTS get: 3, 18, 51, Eagles F3

RICHMOND give: Baker, 18, 51
RICHMOND get: Saints F1, 27

EAGLES give: 3, F3
EAGLES get: 8, Baker

Points wise it works out (rates Baker at pick 10)

Your F3 can go to Richmond if need be.
Pick 10 for Baker? Are you high?
 
Few saints posters had a crack at a 3 team trade based off the Rhino tweet from yesterday.

SAINTS give: 8, F1, 27
SAINTS get: 3, 18, 51, Eagles F3

RICHMOND give: Baker, 18, 51
RICHMOND get: Saints F1, 27

EAGLES give: 3, F3
EAGLES get: 8, Baker

Points wise it works out (rates Baker at pick 10)

Your F3 can go to Richmond if need be.
With only looking at the Eagles line, can the eagles f3 and make it 7 instead of 8.

We wouldve been ok with 3 for 6+Baker, 7+Baker will do fine
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top