Traded Dan Houston - Joins Collingwood as part of 3-way trade with Port and GC

[Jeremias]

For anyone who missed the prior warning:

Take the Carlton v Collingwood shit fight elsewhere.

Infractions will be handed out.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

They want players more than picks. Yes they could get much more if they traded picks for future picks. But they won't put in jeopardy the deals for those incontract players.

That's not what they should do and its poor logic.

 

[Makeshift Park]

Ooof doubt he’d go to Richmond. Nice graphic though.

Houston and his management have never said otherwise publicly, and I suspect the Pies and the Tigers lists will be in a similar state of competitiveness in 2-3 years time.

 

[perplexed]

Why do Collingwood care about Port having 3 late 1st rd picks?

Dead cat strategy

 

[DopeMaster]

Houston and his management have never said otherwise publicly, and I suspect the Pies and the Tigers lists will be in a similar state of competitiveness in 2-3 years time.

Cool, sounds like a no brainer for Houston if true.

 

[nahnah]

Houston and his management have never said otherwise publicly, and I suspect the Pies and the Tigers lists will be in a similar state of competitiveness in 2-3 years time.

We will have LDU running around with Nick, it shouldn’t be too bad

 

[T2B_]

The cynic in me says the deal is done and they’re holding off announcing it to keep eyeballs on trade period and advertising dollars flowing.

Dunno if the deal is done or not but I've no doubt the other part of your sentence is true regardless.

 

[Makeshift Park]

We will have LDU running around with Nick, it shouldn’t be too bad

Given your mob is proposing cashing in next year's first rounder, I assume it'll be a straight swap for Naicos, as that will be all the capital you have left.

 

[nahnah]

Given your mob is proposing cashing in next year's first rounder, I assume it'll be a straight swap for Naicos, as that will be all the capital you have left.

don’t worry you’ll get a top 3 pick in compensation like usual

 

[Makeshift Park]

don’t worry you’ll get a top 3 pick in compensation like usual

Alas we'll have more spare salary cap than your mob, the Blues and the Cats combined next year, so meeting any offers will be a walk in the park.

 

[Visions]

Yep. We won't give you both this pick that we don't have and this other pick we don't have because you may exchange one of them with someone else.

Especially when pick 21 is from GWS. Didn't realise Collingwood were in the hunt for that one to be able to pass on.

Almost as if Jon Ralph has made this all up.....

 

[beez]

Ralphy’s making things up again…

The cynic in me says the deal is done and they’re holding off announcing it to keep eyeballs on trade period and advertising dollars flowing.

It wouldn’t take more than an hour for teams to canvass every single permutation and combination of picks/players back and forth and come to a middle ground.

Are we to believe that these incremental updates from Ralphy are the fruits of two list management teams labour over an entire day?

What the hell to they do with the other 8hrs and 57 minutes?

Contrived drama.

I honestly cannot get my head around people believing this.



But then again, perhaps I'm the idiot.

 

[10571z]

Houston and his management have never said otherwise publicly, and I suspect the Pies and the Tigers lists will be in a similar state of competitiveness in 2-3 years time.

Heard the same about Geelong.

 

[adammania9]

If an inexperienced AFL, 18 year old kid can be chosen as a pick 2 then Houston is double that value. The fact you ignorant low IQ numpties can't fathom that then that's on you. He's literally a top 5 player CONSISTENTLY this entire season and the ONLY player to remain top 5, that, and was top 10 last season with 2 AA blazers to go with it. Legit has ons of the best field kicks in the league. He's in his prime with years to go. That would take a few years minimum for a top 5 or even top 10 draftee to obtain and thats a maybe. So hes a top rated gun already. Only appears you numpties that dont watch more games than your own teams clearly explains why you've got no clue. Get that through your thick heads.

If North are smart they'll trade pick 2 with Fremantle for 10 & 11 then trade 11 and future 1st for Houston whilst still remaining in this year's draft. If Houston is smart & genuine, he'd accept going to North to be back in Victoria whilst also having more money and a potentially good team If all goes good. Better than Pies too. And I don't like North so that's giving them credit.

Richards is a mature age, albeit seems like a decent yet still average player is worth a 4th round pick. Simple. He's not rated even against the current top 20 new 18 year old draftees.

Richards is not, and should not be a part of any deals and instead a separate one. Otherwise, yeah, he can go through the PSD and if Pies are stupid enough to re draft then that's on them and either way, he'll get more money so win - win for him and Port wouldn't care. Guaranteed. Dime a dozen player and port very well will pick up a far better small forward this draft.

Noble is only valued as a 20 to 40 pick. Again, decent yet average player that a top 20 current 18 year old draft crop is better value already.



Pies have absolutely nothing to bargain for in a deal for Houston. Simple.

Confused. If Port Adelaide don’t care whether Richards gets to them or not, and the Power will undoubtedly draft a better forward, why has the club offered him three years in an improved role?

If the Pies have nothing to bargain for in a deal, how come every man and his dog believe the deal is nearly settled?

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

That's not what they should do and its poor logic.

It's not poor logic. If it was they would have already traded 13 to another team.

 

[PortVic]

It's not poor logic. If it was they would have already traded 13 to another team.

They know their 13 is valuable for a lot of teams, so the longer they hold out, the chances of a better deal for GC.

 

[CCurnow3votes]

Given your mob is proposing cashing in next year's first rounder, I assume it'll be a straight swap for Naicos, as that will be all the capital you have left.

What’s left of the farm….

 

[Makeshift Park]

Alright, the blues and pies have given us a little sideshow, time to get real.

Who says no

North out: f1
North in: Houston

Essendon out: pick 9
Essendon in: north f1

Port out: Houston
Port in: pick 9

 

[carlton_99]

Alright, the blues and pies have given us a little sideshow, time to get real.

Who says no

North out: f1
North in: Houston

Essendon out: pick 9
Essendon in: north f1

Port out: Houston
Port in: pick 9

Couldn't it be as simple as North's F1 for Houston?

 

[Makeshift Park]

Couldn't it be as simple as North's F1 for Houston?

Then Port would’ve accepted it by now, it’d have thought.

It’s been mentioned by multiple reporters that they want to get into the 2024 first round.

So I think if North can get Port a single digit 2024 first rounder, the rubber might start hitting the road.

 

[perplexed]

Alright, the blues and pies have given us a little sideshow, time to get real.

Who says no

North out: f1
North in: Houston

Essendon out: pick 9
Essendon in: north f1

Port out: Houston
Port in: pick 9

It works, but I would really rather not give up our F1.

Time for another MEGATRADE

S: 7, F1 > 2
N: 2, F2 > Houston, 13, 23
GC: 13, 23 > F1, F2
P: Houston > 7

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Alright, the blues and pies have given us a little sideshow, time to get real.

Who says no

North out: f1
North in: Houston

Essendon out: pick 9
Essendon in: north f1

Port out: Houston
Port in: pick 9

Houston

 

[Makeshift Park]

It works, but I would really rather not give up our F1.

Time for another MEGATRADE

S: 7, F1 > 2
N: 2, F2 > Houston, 13, 23
GC: 13, 23 > F1, F2
P: Houston > 7

I was going for the Occam's razor approach, with the least moving parts.

I prefer yours too, but I don't understand how GC get Lombard, Rioli and Noble if they give away 13 and 23.

 

[perplexed]

I was going for the Occam's razor approach, with the least moving parts.

I prefer yours too, but I don't understand how GC get Lombard, Rioli and Noble if they give away 13 and 23.

Good point

Rioli for 6
Noble for 29
Lombard for 41,50 ........ and we'd need to find them another 500 or so points. Maybe Lukosius for F2 and 39 from Port.

 

[Makeshift Park]

Houston

Since none of the other Victorian suitors have been willing to make serious offers, I suggest Dan's management will evoke the words of that great philosopher Daryl Braithwaite, and tell him "that's the way its gonna be, lil darling".

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Since none of the other Victorian suitors have been willing to make serious offers, I suggest Dan's management will evoke the words of that great philosopher Daryl Braithwaite, and tell him "that's the way its gonna be, lil darling".

We'll go riding on the horses, yeahh!

Back to Alberton...