![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/collingwood.png)
TheLip
Team Captain
I'm thanking you because you rate Collingwood's medicos the best in the world.Why are you thanking me? Beams was dropped because he was shit, or the medico's made a balls up last week?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I'm thanking you because you rate Collingwood's medicos the best in the world.Why are you thanking me? Beams was dropped because he was shit, or the medico's made a balls up last week?
One goal in 7 finals suggests he just stinks it up in finals. Wont be the first and wont be the last player it happens to.
Quelle Surprise! Right on cue the offended Saints fan joins the conga line. Seriously Finger, are you still so ashamed of your club that you can't bear to be seen in their colours? Honestly, they weren't that bad this year.One goal in 7 finals suggests he just stinks it up in finals. Wont be the first and wont be the last player it happens to.
Yeh, we'd just ignore the fact he's been one of our best players since coming back into the side won't we?Either way, he wasn't getting a game this week ..and everyone knew it .
I'm thanking you because you rate Collingwood's medicos the best in the world.The rest is just trolling which I wouldn't waste time responding to!
![]()
No they didn't. He had been in great form prior to the Prelim, probably the best form of his career. Do you drop a player on one bad game?
You're welcome then I guess, I didn't realise you were on the Collingwood medical staff.
I wasn't trolling, I just don't think you can have it both ways, whatever the reason is for him not playing. Either he went into the game injured (poor decision), he got injured early which is why he couldn't get a kick, but still wasn't subbed (poor decision), or he got injured in the 3/4 and was just shit, which means his form wasn't because of injury.
No they didn't. He had been in great form prior to the Prelim, probably the best form of his career. Do you drop a player on one bad game?
So let me understand this. Either what you're saying is that the best medicos in the world all have x-ray vision and can see a soft tissue injury from a mile away or you happen to know all of the workings of the team's decisions in terms of who they sub and when.
Sorry, but if that isn't trolling then I've never seen it albeit that it is such an idiotic proposition.
I wasn't trolling, I just don't think you can have it both ways, whatever the reason is for him not playing. Either he went into the game injured (poor decision)
he got injured early which is why he couldn't get a kick, but still wasn't subbed (poor decision),
or he got injured in the 3/4 and was just shit, which means his form wasn't because of injury.
Malthouse did it in important finals to Malaxos and Worsfold.
If he thought it would win him the game, he would do it in an instant.
A guy who averaged 27.5 touches and 1.5 goals since coming back from injury in Round 19, and only gets 2 touches in a game, and people don't believe he was actually injured.
Special minds.
Malthouse did it in important finals to Malaxos and Worsfold.
If he thought it would win him the game, he would do it in an instant.
Simple, go back 4 posts from yours!Could you define "trolling" please.
So he thought it was ok to go into a prelim injured ..but not a Grand Final ?
special minds![]()
So he thought it was ok to go into a prelim injured ..but not a Grand Final ?
special minds![]()
Simple, go back 4 posts from yours!![]()
Did he use injury as an excuse? Or did he do it last year for Davis, for that matter?
It doesn't make much sense they would lie about this. Apart from anything else, if he was fit he would surely be an emergency ahead of Sinclair.
There is a chance he may have been dropped anyway, but I really doubt it. I can't see any reason to not believe Malthouse.