Lets be realistic. Best case scenario for Carlton was to get a first-round pick with the hope of developing a future KPF. That did NOT happen.
Next best case, in my opinion, was to get a decent forward who could plug the hole for at least a couple of years, while we try to develop our existing players - or possibly swing future deals for a KPF (like Roughead). This means we can remain competitive and doesn't put strain on our young guys (Kreuze, Waite) who will be playing out of their natural position in the forward line. This DID happen.
I don't know the details, but financially we will be in a good position for the future. This might be a small step backwards as far as on-field performance, but do you think the Fev-Bradshaw downgrade will really outweigh the improvement of everyone else across the board? I'm thinking only marginally, if at all.
I don't think this is a nightmare scenario for Carlton. The real impact of this trade will be seen in 1-2 years, when we make our next big move. We could look back on this day and say it was a turning point, for the good.
Next best case, in my opinion, was to get a decent forward who could plug the hole for at least a couple of years, while we try to develop our existing players - or possibly swing future deals for a KPF (like Roughead). This means we can remain competitive and doesn't put strain on our young guys (Kreuze, Waite) who will be playing out of their natural position in the forward line. This DID happen.
I don't know the details, but financially we will be in a good position for the future. This might be a small step backwards as far as on-field performance, but do you think the Fev-Bradshaw downgrade will really outweigh the improvement of everyone else across the board? I'm thinking only marginally, if at all.
I don't think this is a nightmare scenario for Carlton. The real impact of this trade will be seen in 1-2 years, when we make our next big move. We could look back on this day and say it was a turning point, for the good.