nah…Gaff is a very average footballer at best. He is slow, not a very good kick but does add some value as a player who runs and provides an option for players under pressure. This alone does not warrant the dollars he gets and I have to say I would rather give others a go and see if they can develop as players for the future than persevere with someone that other teams don’t even try to limit as he does very little damage.Ridiculously harsh on Gaff - he’s turned into a bigger punching bag than Andy Brayshaw’s glass jaw this year.
Go back and watch his delivery into the forward line on the weekend - when given the opportunity to actually play in his best role, he is still a contributor and we are a better team with him out there.
Shuey has no consistent base of fitness or form due to his continual injuries. He’s harder to gauge but again, he was improved again against Richmond. That all said, he’s 32. He’s probably going to go around again next year but another mid term injury could happen at any moment and end it all.