catempire
Premium Platinum
They love picking Bowes as sub. That would be my guess.Who would you pick as sub then? Tuohy?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
They love picking Bowes as sub. That would be my guess.Who would you pick as sub then? Tuohy?
I’ll be mad and someone will have missed out who didn’t deserve to. Like Mannagh.
They love picking Bowes as sub. That would be my guess.
First final
In - Rohan
Out - Humphries (omit)
Shall I see myself out now
Nah mannagh snd humphries are lock ins.
After henry today i think rohan is sub at best.
I'm a fan of Rohan, but we can't play both Henry & Rohan in the same 22
Both struggle with the other in the side, and play at their best when they're the lone 3rd tall option
Only way i see both playing in the same team from here is if one of our two KPFs go down - I'd opt for Rohan ahead of Hawkins in that situation, unless Tom is definitely right to go (which I doubt)
Do we need rohan as sub though?From today Bews out for Rohan as sub makes sense. Neither are that versatile but Rohan is playing much better and I'd back him over Mullin or Clark. If MOC or Guthrie can get back and play a VFL game maybe them as sub after the first week of finals is possible.
With Blicavs playing down back it's a big question who SDK comes in for. SDK for a small makes us look too tall and lumbering. There's no way they drop Blicavs so I think SDK for Stanley is most likely. Which I hope is what happens but SDK has to be 100% to come in as number 1 ruck.
I think we'll make it to a prelim and have a 30/70 shot for advancing from there. 30/70 again after that if we made it.Pretty accurate view.
Hoping you predicted a good finals series
I will feel spoilt if we win this year but it’s not unthinkable!I think we'll make it to a prelim and have a 30/70 shot for advancing from there. 30/70 again after that if we made it.
Unlikely flag contenders, but not in "it is unfathomable" territory.
No, but Dangerfield has an even stronger correlation with us winning in 2024.Anyone up for doing that for every player on our list?
No, but Dangerfield has an even stronger correlation with us winning in 2024.
A random side note: We've won all but 1 game where Bowes had 23+ disposals as well. 7-1.
Yeah I realise it's a silly finding. But find the quiet Bowes games and you generally find the ones we have struggled in.Get him to the kick outs
Lana Would you select all three of Stanley, SDK and Blicavs for our Qualifying Final? I know you've often argued in favour of going smaller in defence to give us more rebounding ability. Not saying that I endorse dropping SDK or Blicavs but just curious to know your thoughts on our best structure.
A lot of bloody hard calls to make. There isn't a just a single right answer, as long as the plan is coherent and we aren't taking injured players into a match I'm pretty satisfied. ( my personal red lines are no Mullin, No Hawkins, only one of Rohan and O.Henry in the 23, no Knevitt) I'd be perfectly fine going into a final with Henry and Kolodjashnij as our only two KPD as long as we have enough quality ball movers to fit the other 5-6 places, if one of them is Bews or Mullin then I'd prefer to bring in the extra tall.
Question mark of Stanley is how many good quarters does he have in him. This weekend was a bit of a stress test for him. He didn't get much help. Was really good for most of the game,
Moving Blicavs out of the midfield has its merits, it is clear he doesn't have the movement he had two years ago. Lets our secondary ball winners getting more time in there then they usually do, I don't think that it is a lack of fitness that Bruhn plays 60ish% game time, we're trying to fit in 7 guys in a car with 5 seats. Blicavs has fit in down back much more naturally than I had thought he would. With more height down back we have less pressure for Stewart to drift back. We had Tuohy in defence for a bit over a month, to initially cover that Stewart role. With Blicavs down back, Tuohy was back to the skinny side wing.
Is SDK doing good enough as a KPD this year to warrant being selected into a final when he hasn't played for 5/6 weeks. With Blicavs back and more importantly in good form, I don't see a need for it.
It'd be a bit of a gamble but if Stanley has a stinker in week one of finals then SDK as a ruckmen for week 2, would be my call. I have a feeling that for us to win it this year we'll have to pull out some bullshit trick to get an advantage.
I think it is likely that Bews out SDK in, with Tuohy to the sub as the likely change. Blicavs to the wing
I'd leave SDK out, take Bews out as the sub, don't see an obvious in, I want something offensive but with possession chain potential (No Rohan/O.Henry)
I wish Guthrie was fit enough to gamble him as the sub. Might be Clark as the last man standing, doesn't really fit the bill I want, best of the remaining options.
Truthfully, I’m not sure. First final guess
B: Z. Guthrie - J. Henry - Kolodjashnij
HB: Stewart - SDK - Humphries
C: Dempsey - Bowes - Holmes
HF: Miers - Neale - Close
F: Stengle - Cameron - O. Henry
R: Stanley - Dangerfield - Bruhn
I: Blicavs - Duncan - Atkins - Mannagh
Sub: Rohan
Reckon the Hawk comes in when fit.
Bews SDK Kolo
Z Guthrie J Henry Humphries
Dempsey Stewart Holmes
Miers Cameron Close
Stengle Neale Rohan
Stanley Dangerfield Bruhn
Blicavs Bowes Mannagh Clark
Sub : O Henry
Touhy and Duncan to be the Mooney and Milburn of 2011