Rumour GFC 2018 Player Trading, Drafting, FA, Rumours, and Wish lists - PT4

[Cataholic]

Rumours that he and his sidekick Pack Specialist parade around here every year this time of year and patronize everyone telling us what's going to happen when in reality they've got NFI and 9 times out of ten end up getting it wrong.

Kelly ain't going to Freo. Never was and never is. It's really not that hard to work out yet they keep pedaling the same bullshit over and over giving people false hope in some lame attempt to prove to everyone how clever they are. Well guess what? They don't know shit.

Wow. You've got a hard edge these days Stan.......

Not saying you're wrong, but will say I'm shocked because I've always had respect for PO as a poster, and his knowledge in general. I've considered him one of the mainstays of this board......

Anyhow, it'll be interesting to see what has transpired when the dust settles re: Kelly. T
Hopefully a deal gets done somehow so we, and the club, can move on from the saga.

 

[Turbocat]

28yo, 2 years left on his deal and the Pies just lost a GF.
Eerily similar to Gibbs.

2 firsts should be what they should ask for.

Yes good observation .. two late R1's..get it done? Its all Pies have this years and next.

 

[Two Planks]

Yes good observation .. two late R1's..get it done? Its all Pies have this years and next.

Reckon Beams will get done for pick 18 and Tom Langdon in a 3 way deal

 

[mikey127]

He's a star, Beams. But like Jack Steven he's too old for us given where we're at. If he was 3-4 years younger, where do we sign?

If adding him got you another flag in the next year or 2...

 

[Turbocat]

Reckon Beams will get done for pick 18 and Tom Langdon in a 3 way deal

Maybe had not thought of that... what do the swans have... ? Bris are grumpy as Beems has been paid upfront

 

[dazbroncos]

If any of you can handle Parsons running around then surely Murdoch is bearable. The guy is inconsistent like most of our bottom tier - he's a perfect example of a player who has the attributes but not the mental side. Maybe the coaches are to blame and he would flourish under a different system/club.

There is a massive fundamental difference between Parsons and Murda. Murda plays hard. Parsons backs out of shit and is not physical at all.

Dont disagree on the inconsistent issues for both.

GO Catters

 

[Stan The Caddy]

Wow. You've got a hard edge these days Stan.......

Not saying you're wrong, but will say I'm shocked because I've always had respect for PO as a poster, and his knowledge in general. I've considered him one of the mainstays of this board......

Anyhow, it'll be interesting to see what has transpired when the dust settles re: Kelly. T
Hopefully a deal gets done somehow so we, and the club, can move on from the saga.

I'm sure they're both good fellas but I just don't like it when they patronize people and I'm not the only person that's ever brought it up either. Anyway, I've said my piece so I'll give it a rest.

And yes, interesting times ahead. I think in the end a deal will get done with WC but who knows...

 

[Cataholic]

I'm sure they're both good fellas but I just don't like it when they patronize people and I'm not the only person that's ever brought it up either. Anyway, I've said my piece so I'll give it a rest.

And yes, interesting times ahead. I think in the end a deal will get done with WC but who knows...

It seems someone is going to have to blink..... Who you thinking it'll be?

 

[bulletproof]

Lot of trades still to happen, Geelong don’t seem to be chasing anyone, not a bad position to be in. Try and take advantage of last minute chaos to improve draft hand.

 

[foodles05]

He might turn into a KPF for all we both know.
I can guarantee you one thing, I wouldve watched him play more than you have over the years.
Mrs is a Hawks supporter
But once again, I wouldn’t be trading out the next 10 years of Burton for 4 years of Wingard

hahaha obviously not close enough. He is 190. How many KPP at that height do you reckon.

 

[foodles05]

Apparently Burton is shocked and unhappy about being thrown up and wants to remain in VIC. I would love us to try and get involved and somehow bring him to Geelong. Reckon he just had second year blues this year and has heaps of talent. What do people think

 

[Grimoz]

Not sure how the Hawks can get Wingard for 15 and Burton, that seems like massive unders, Port are usually tight as a dolphins ass, they must really want him gone.

 

[Grimoz]

Apparently Burton is shocked and unhappy about being thrown up and wants to remain in VIC. I would love us to try and get involved and somehow bring him to Geelong. Reckon he just had second year blues this year and has heaps of talent. What do people think

Wingard + 48 to Hawks, 15 + Burton to Geelong, 20 + 22 + 35 to Port, Kelly to West Coast

In saying that I believe that Port requested that Burton be included so you would think if he says no he will stay at the hawks and not move to a rival like us.

 

[you pick one]

hahaha obviously not close enough. He is 190. How many KPP at that height do you reckon.

I wouldn't be surprised if he comes back with Jack Darling both 191 and Pavlich one of the best of all times at 192 as well as the best ever Carey 192 for starters.

 

[calder_daddy]

I wouldn't be surprised if he comes back with Jack Darling both 191 and Pavlich one of the best of all times at 192 as well as the best ever Carey 192 for starters.

I was going to just ignore the ignorant comment, athleticism has everything to do with it.
Height very little

 

[catempire]

Apparently Burton is shocked and unhappy about being thrown up and wants to remain in VIC. I would love us to try and get involved and somehow bring him to Geelong. Reckon he just had second year blues this year and has heaps of talent. What do people think

Not going to happen but I rate him highly.

 

[Stan The Caddy]

It seems someone is going to have to blink..... Who you thinking it'll be?

It's hard to know without knowing exactly what WC's initial offer was but both clubs are usually reasonable with these sorts of things so it could end up being a case of both clubs blinking a tad.

 

[ReebusMaximus]

Hawthorn going hard for Scully. A two-way gut runner like that is exactly what we need. Unfortunately we a) probably don’t have the cap space and b) don’t have the medical department to get the ankle right.

Mayes from Brisbane is another one that’s been thrown up with Port Adelaide showing interest. Would love us to have a look at him too in order to add some more class ball users off HBF, but can’t see it happening.

 

[Grimoz]

Hawthorn going hard for Scully. A two-way gut runner like that is exactly what we need. Unfortunately we a) probably don’t have the cap space and b) don’t have the medical department to get the ankle right.

Mayes from Brisbane is another one that’s been thrown up with Port Adelaide showing interest. Would love us to have a look at him too in order to add some more class ball users off HBF, but can’t see it happening.

With what? A pack of salt and vinegar chips? They have absolutely no currency, and will have even less when Wingard comes. Scully is worth a top 10 pick in my opinion, he is a gun.

 

[BORIS332]

Lot of trades still to happen, Geelong don’t seem to be chasing anyone, not a bad position to be in. Try and take advantage of last minute chaos to improve draft hand.

Draft picks can be swapped all the way up to the draft, I don’t think there’ll be much of a scramble next week.

 

[THE CAT WRANGLER]

Hawthorn going hard for Scully. A two-way gut runner like that is exactly what we need. Unfortunately we a) probably don’t have the cap space and b) don’t have the medical department to get the ankle right.

Mayes from Brisbane is another one that’s been thrown up with Port Adelaide showing interest. Would love us to have a look at him too in order to add some more class ball users off HBF, but can’t see it happening.

HAWKS showing us how to do business, who would you prefer wingard & Scully or Rowan and Dalhaus

 

[BORIS332]

Hawthorn going hard for Scully. A two-way gut runner like that is exactly what we need. Unfortunately we a) probably don’t have the cap space and b) don’t have the medical department to get the ankle right.

Mayes from Brisbane is another one that’s been thrown up with Port Adelaide showing interest. Would love us to have a look at him too in order to add some more class ball users off HBF, but can’t see it happening.

Mayes wants to go home to SA I believe.

 

[Cataholic]

HAWKS showing us how to do business, who would you prefer wingard & Scully or Rowan and Dalhaus

How will they get both players? ?

 

[Grimoz]

HAWKS showing us how to do business, who would you prefer wingard & Scully or Rowan and Dalhaus

Are they.....how many players have they landed so far?

 

[MacStradbroke]

HAWKS showing us how to do business, who would you prefer wingard & Scully or Rowan and Dalhaus

Rohan & Dahlhaus were free. What was the comparison again?