Rumour GFC 2022 Player Trading, Drafting FA, Rumours and Wish lists PT2

[Tony Barber]

Bloody hell.
I was just looking at the spreadsheet above and saw how many points GWS has?

Which club will find the key and unlock access to some of that?
They haven’t even traded Hopper and Bruhn yet.

It seriously is nuts. Brisbane must be drooling.

 

[Finknottle]

His name is Easva Ratugolea. Maybe if you showed some respect your comment would be taken seriously. Chump? Chris Scott, Andrew Mackie and others on this blog rate Sav.

Woops - Esava

 

[Turbocat]

Think Port are gonna have to get that ruling for the Future 2nd, as that's the only way we acquiesce to trading him, IMO - as Pick 30-35 this year is useless to us

But it will not be to be used for us...its for JHF deal

 

[Hvashera2]

The Collingwood board told me to piss off, after I said Pick 18 is most likely to be used for O Henry...

Just told them Bobby Hill contract offer is more than O Henry offer, and that Pick 18 is a pretty decent deal, considering he's OOC and wanting out, and also not Best 22.

Then they started ranting about splitting Pick 7 and taking SDK... Lol

Now I get it... How feral opposition boards can become. I haven't done that in a while, but oh well, it was amusing.

Firstly all boards are feral, especially this time of the year.
You forgot to mention that a number of us are ok with 18. Not ecstatic but it's the best of a bad situation.
At the same time, we're happy to keep Ollie if Mackie wants to low ball us with pick 38. There is precedent for players being forced to stay and thriving (eg Papley). Even those who left eventually (T Kelly, Gibbs, Lobb) provided good service to their clubs before leaving.
The point is that it wouldn't be a disaster for us if Ollie stayed. It provides more time to build bonds with team mates, put his case forward for a regular spot in the seniors etc. If he still wants to leave next year, his value is likely to go up even further. Win win

 

[Goggin Our Best]

So who would be interest in Copper Stephens and what would thay pay?

I think Geel should keep him - 2023 wil be make or break for him

But in the games hes played - i really liked the energy/effort/enthusiam he brought to every contest he was involved in - and he looked like he concentrated when he played

You compare that to Narkle - polar opposite in those facets

 

[Turbocat]

They have 33 and 43 but neither is good to us as we have too many picks and no list spots. We need to turn that pick into a future 2nd so we can then send our future 2nd out for bowes and 7 and do bruhn.

we need to do Gold Coast first. And then scramble for Bruhn if we must.

 

[CatToTheFuture]

By all reports Mackie lowballing all deals… reported he has offered pick 38 for Henry, and a future first and future second coming back for Bruhn, turn it up. Not sure on the Bowes deal but bulking on a second going back. Sounds too greedy, but hopefully just posturing. Lets get these deals done! Surely if we get all three and go to the draft with pick 7 and a spec pick its a great outcome….

It's a nothing brain fart by Rendell.

It's standard practice but the media just want something to throw darts with because they want negative stories on us as a counter narrative. If it's all one way for us they'll lose a lot of listeners and clicks

 

[Turbocat]

I think Geel should keep him - 2023 wil be make or break for him

But in the games hes played - i really liked the energy/effort/enthusiam he brought to every contest he was involved in - and he looked like he concentrated when he played

You compare that to Narkle - polar opposite in those facets

Id just like to know who woudl be interested and what tehy would offer. Most clubs will smell a bargain..so I doubt we trade him

 

[Boxhead_31]

Look he is a bit of a smart aarse - but was that sledge against Nth Melb - Geel were a mile in front and they kicked another goal - andMackie said look its only Nth Melb - but it was alot better and cleverer than that - thats why im asking

Was something like "It's a shame we are playing this well and its only Nth Melb"

 

[Jumping Jack]

Look he is a bit of a smart aarse - but was that sledge against Nth Melb - Geel were a mile in front and they kicked another goal - andMackie said look its only Nth Melb - but it was alot better and cleverer than that - thats why im asking

I think your referring to a game Vs North where Mackie (in earshot of North players) was asking Cats players during the game, if they got 4 pts for beating North, or only 2.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Vivy]

If any of you were listening, that was me that just called, haha

Onya Nick

Good listening

 

[Lana]

Something like
18 for Bruhn and 44, values Bruhn at 31 under DVI

38 and 44 to someone like Richmond for 31

31 to Collingwood for Henry

 

[Goggin Our Best]

Was something like "It's a shame we are playing this well and its only Nth Melb"

No it was better than that - he was on the backline - and Geel kicked another goal and he said something so the Nth Melb players in the vicinity heard it

 

[UnitedWarrior93]

Something like
18 for Bruhn and 44, values Bruhn at 31 under DVI

38 and 44 to someone like Richmond for 31

31 to Collingwood for Henry

31 isn’t getting Henry to the club.

 

[Lana]

31 isn’t getting Henry to the club.

He isn't even worth that. It'd be charitable offer.

 

[CatRiot]

Firstly all boards are feral, especially this time of the year.
You forgot to mention that a number of us are ok with 18. Not ecstatic but it's the best of a bad situation.
At the same time, we're happy to keep Ollie if Mackie wants to low ball us with pick 38. There is precedent for players being forced to stay and thriving (eg Papley). Even those who left eventually (T Kelly, Gibbs, Lobb) provided good service to their clubs before leaving.
The point is that it wouldn't be a disaster for us if Ollie stayed. It provides more time to build bonds with team mates, put his case forward for a regular spot in the seniors etc. If he still wants to leave next year, his value is likely to go up even further. Win win

Yeah, fair enough. Pretty sure that low ball is just a conversation starter, we won't have the list spots for many picks this season.

 

[Tony Barber]

If the club are willing to deal him I would be very worried if I was the other club chasing him.

Wait. What?
What are we talking about here?

 

[Goggin Our Best]

I think your referring to a game Vs North where Mackie (in earshot of North players) was asking Cats players during the game, if they got 4 pts for beating North, or only 2.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Thats it - thats the one

 

[Hinkley29]

Firstly all boards are feral, especially this time of the year.
You forgot to mention that a number of us are ok with 18. Not ecstatic but it's the best of a bad situation.
At the same time, we're happy to keep Ollie if Mackie wants to low ball us with pick 38. There is precedent for players being forced to stay and thriving (eg Papley). Even those who left eventually (T Kelly, Gibbs, Lobb) provided good service to their clubs before leaving.
The point is that it wouldn't be a disaster for us if Ollie stayed. It provides more time to build bonds with team mates, put his case forward for a regular spot in the seniors etc. If he still wants to leave next year, his value is likely to go up even further. Win win

Tim Kelly stayed at Geelong for 2 years after being drafted. That is the same number of years that Ollie Henry has been at Collingwood. And the same number of years that Taylor Adam’s was at GWS.

 

[foxdog50]

Agree with all that.
Fyi 3 live picks is only if sav is traded and simpson delist and re rookie as of today we can use 1 pick only.
If sav goes we have to get the best mature kpd we can in the rookie draft.

Know of any names that could be that KPD player?

 

[Grimoz]

According to "Lachlan" on Trade Radio, Geelong players are given free meat from a butcher and free dental work for the life of their playing contracts....

If they keep winning premierships ill give them all free meat and im not even a butcher

 

[Vivy]

Gees watching trading day ... King has real got the cratchits up .... his just dirty ...I think over JHF situation.

and when told GWS want to trade with them to get Cadman he really got his back up.

Wasn't long ago when he was on record on Whateley's show, unhappy with Noble floating the idea of priority picks for North.

 

[you pick one]

If any of you were listening, that was me that just called, haha

Something went wrong right from the start but they stuck with you your phone was so muffled it was near impossible to understand what you were saying.They should have stopped you and cleared the line up but said you had been hanging on for a long time so continued.

 

[Vivy]

Firstly all boards are feral, especially this time of the year.
You forgot to mention that a number of us are ok with 18. Not ecstatic but it's the best of a bad situation.
At the same time, we're happy to keep Ollie if Mackie wants to low ball us with pick 38. There is precedent for players being forced to stay and thriving (eg Papley). Even those who left eventually (T Kelly, Gibbs, Lobb) provided good service to their clubs before leaving.
The point is that it wouldn't be a disaster for us if Ollie stayed. It provides more time to build bonds with team mates, put his case forward for a regular spot in the seniors etc. If he still wants to leave next year, his value is likely to go up even further. Win win

All valid points but based around those players being contracted.

Henry is out of contract. Being forced to stay isn't a thing for out of contract players.

 

[Turbocat]

Firstly all boards are feral, especially this time of the year.
You forgot to mention that a number of us are ok with 18. Not ecstatic but it's the best of a bad situation.
At the same time, we're happy to keep Ollie if Mackie wants to low ball us with pick 38. There is precedent for players being forced to stay and thriving (eg Papley). Even those who left eventually (T Kelly, Gibbs, Lobb) provided good service to their clubs before leaving.
The point is that it wouldn't be a disaster for us if Ollie stayed. It provides more time to build bonds with team mates, put his case forward for a regular spot in the seniors etc. If he still wants to leave next year, his value is likely to go up even further. Win win

Just what do you think is the correct value for him then ...considering he is OOC.


Jordan Clark was P15 and we got 22 ..with a slight change of futures. ... upgrade 4th round