News Gone: Alex Keath wants to be traded to the Bulldogs

[SuperBashBros]

Hold out Reid. Involve 13 or let him walk to PSD. I dont think any supporter will be angry with it after its explained.

 

[Crow till I die]

You have control of his contract, it wouldn't matter.

You just force a trade a year later, which even at a reduced value does still send a message.

We have given more than enough players away for next to nothing this trade period - time to play hardball and unfortunately for the Dogs, keath is the one that it will hopefully happen with

 

[SaltPeter]

if Keath nominates for the draft, is it the main draft or the preseason draft (if it is still around). If it is te main draft, we can now threaten to use pick 28 on him to his manager which falls before the bulldogs picks after 13. However if it is the preseason draft then GC may take him but if not, we finished below the dogs so we can absolutely guarantee we will take him before them - again to lever the bargaining position

I doubt it. In both drafts Keath will include his contract demands. I imagine if its 4 years on big coin we'd pass. The best opportunity for us is to negotiate a contract before he nominates for the draft.

 

[the universal]

I wonder if we had approached any Bulldog players as a swap. Naughton will do.

Naughton would be close to untouchable.

 

[GROTTO]

We have actually stuffed this up badly. We should not have caved on greenwood so easily and then we could have told both you can go to the PSD if a deal can't be struck. GC could only take one and we would have been in a good spot to take the other back - a great great bargaining tool to get better draft capital. I'd take a pick around 20 for both (one going PSD and the other forcing a better trade) rather than 3 or 4 picks in the 50's and 60's and off into the future

We lost our best contested pack mark with Greenwood going. I was fine for him to go, but at a decent price, I think we caved in.

We will bend over for Keath too, its coming. Lube up.

 

[GROTTO]

Naughton would be close to untouchable.

Naughton would be like three 1sts and your first born kid.

 

[pjcrows]

We lost our best contested pack mark with Greenwood going. I was fine for him to go, but at a decent price, I think we caved in.

We will bend over for Keath too, its coming. Lube up.

If a mid is your best contested pack mark then it's time for a full rebuild.

 

[Brenton Davy]

Naughton would be like three 1sts and your first born kid.

Unders

 

[Golumless]

We have given more than enough players away for next to nothing this trade period - time to play hardball and unfortunately for the Dogs, keath is the one that it will hopefully happen with

To be fair in most cases it was out of necessity.

Greenwood was baffling, and I look forward to that explanation as to why.

 

[Anzacpaul]

I reckon this should be a three way trade:

Bulldogs
In: Keath, Pick 17
Out: 13, 45

Geelong
Out: 17, 36, 37
In: Jenkins, 13, 45

Adelaide
In: 36, 37
Out: Jenkins, Keath

Yuk

 

[hey shorty]

To be fair in most cases it was out of necessity.

Greenwood was baffling, and I look forward to that explanation as to why.

It would want to be a good one.

 

[Scorpus]

To be fair in most cases it was out of necessity.

Greenwood was baffling, and I look forward to that explanation as to why.

I'm still waiting for that explanation on Jarryd Lyons

 

[BACCS]

I reckon this should be a three way trade:

Bulldogs
In: Keath, Pick 17
Out: 13, 45

Geelong
Out: 17, 36, 37
In: Jenkins, 13, 45

Adelaide
In: 36, 37
Out: Jenkins, Keath

Ah what? We get reamed in that trade and Geelong get pick 13?

 

[BACCS]

I'm still waiting for that explanation on Jarryd Lyons

You bag that deal and just pose that ridiculous one for Keath that this board would erupt over?

 

[hey shorty]

Ah what? We get reamed in that trade and Geelong get pick 13?

That's well overs for JJ

 

[Scorpus]

You bag that deal and just pose that ridiculous one for Keath that this board would erupt over?

I would have accepted a straight swap for pick 32.

Two picks in the 30s is more than enough given Jenkins has no value and Geelong have too many picks

 

[BACCS]

That's well overs for JJ

It’s overs for JJ but not even close for Keath, can’t see JJ being apart of that deal anyway

 

[ShadeyP]

Justin Reid is about to be traded for a box of Krispy Kremes .

 

[Doc_]

What time is the deadline?

 

[BACCS]

I would have accepted a straight swap for pick 32.

Two picks in the 30s is more than enough given Jenkins has no value and Geelong have too many picks

We are better off letting Keath go for nothing than accept that, Jenkins should have nothing to do with this deal.

 

[Scorpus]

We are better off letting Keath go for nothing than accept that, Jenkins should have nothing to do with this deal.

We could on trade those two picks to Fremantle for pick 22 and give them more points for their first round NGA kid.

Its way better than nothing or pick 45. And we're going to get nothing for Jenkins so may as well try and extract value

 

[GROTTO]

630pm is the deadline?

 

[6BTS]

The reason the Dogs are offering unders is because we have a history of caving at the trade table, their banking on us doing it again. Time to grow a pair and let Keath go for nothing to send a message that we're not accepting unders at the trade table anymore. If we cave, it will be used against us next year, again.

 

[jenny61_99]

630pm is the deadline?

6:30 your time? So 15 minutes away?

 

[CutAboveTheRest]

This is my concern

Standard Reid