- Jun 18, 2008
- 56,104
- 24,411
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- MUFC,BristolR, GB,Duke,LAA,NYK
swap for Ben Stratton would be nice
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Hawthorn after Goldsack
- Thread starter Unknown Identity
- Start date
- Tagged users None
People get very carried away with the words premiership player. If this was speculated 2 weeks ago we would all be saying lets see what we can get for him.
I like the sack but lets face it he is no world better. He is about 23 and still at best just in our best 22. We have Tom Young who looks a similar type and even jarred blight as well as looking at tarrant who will play the same role in a year or 2.
He is a hero and always will be because he is a collingwood premiership player but he is no better now because he has a medal around his neck. I reckon clubs win a flag and miss opportunties by refusing to trade premiership players and then a few years later they are down the bottom.
If we could get a decent forward or mid for him Id take it. If we could get lewis it would add even more depth to our midfield and IMO would be a trade in our favour. I doubt the hawks would do the deal with lewis TBH as I think they would be the losers in this deal.
I like the sack but lets face it he is no world better. He is about 23 and still at best just in our best 22. We have Tom Young who looks a similar type and even jarred blight as well as looking at tarrant who will play the same role in a year or 2.
He is a hero and always will be because he is a collingwood premiership player but he is no better now because he has a medal around his neck. I reckon clubs win a flag and miss opportunties by refusing to trade premiership players and then a few years later they are down the bottom.
If we could get a decent forward or mid for him Id take it. If we could get lewis it would add even more depth to our midfield and IMO would be a trade in our favour. I doubt the hawks would do the deal with lewis TBH as I think they would be the losers in this deal.
Good young kid but hardly what we need right now, particularly if Tarrant lobs on our doorstep.
- Banned
- #29
No doubt we'd have to sweeten the deal to get Lewis. Would be a bloody good get if we could though.
Zahki
Norm Smith Medallist
- Aug 13, 2009
- 5,548
- 529
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Hate to tell you but Blight is gawn. Anyway, I think the Sack performed pretty well over the finals and only had two really bad games this year where he lost the plot. I think it was the Adelaide game where he pretty much gave them half their score through turnovers? I'd still like to keep him though, he's a capable defender and the team does look better with him in than out.
- Sep 25, 2006
- 18,365
- 14,632
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- FC Barcelona, Liverpool, FC Bayern
This guy is rubbish.
Does not have one trait that is better than the Sack's.
Also, a 3rd rounder is rubbish.
Rubbish + more rubbish does not = adequate or fair, it only = more rubbish.
i guess for the right price but hawthorn won't want to give up to much for him.
I'm very surprised they haven't inquired about Fraser!
I'm very surprised they haven't inquired about Fraser!
- Aug 11, 2006
- 8,108
- 3,006
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
You think Goldsack can become the best player in the competition?
I would be happy if Goldsack becomes 1/3 of the player Goddard is.
@ Muston, Muston = Rusling
- Banned
- #37
You'll be able to get Muston for a bag of chips in a few weeks, so essentially it's Goldsack for a 3rd rounder.
Goldsack to reach the heights of Goddard
Lol, I've read it all!
I've only seen Muston play a few times and each time I've seen him play he's shown glimpses that he could become a handy player in numerous positions.
If Goldsack wants out then he's one I'd consider to be part of the deal.
If Goldsack wants out then he's one I'd consider to be part of the deal.
- Aug 11, 2006
- 8,108
- 3,006
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
There is a reason you only see Muston a few times, he is a cripple.
What was it? 3 ACLs to the same knee?
tackleberry
Debutant
Thats the way, sell off the bloke who you have seen less of. Fifty odd games over four years is not bad when the selection policy ( meaning consecutive games ) for some players has been a bit weighted.
He may not suffer from leather poisoning but he sure knows how to use the ball when he gets it.
Tall, fast and hard at it.
Maybe if he had blonde tips he might be worth keeping?
The Sack stays.
He may not suffer from leather poisoning but he sure knows how to use the ball when he gets it.
Tall, fast and hard at it.
Maybe if he had blonde tips he might be worth keeping?
The Sack stays.
TradeDraft
Post-Human
Muston? Dowler? What? Hell no! Goldy has them both covered. Wow.
I like the Jordan Lewis one though. However, I get the feeling we'd be offered steak knives for Goldsack, which is why their not targeting Brown or Reid, but the guy just in the 22 who was only included the second week.
We could hope for a Gary Moss or someone like that. I say Keep The Sack. I would certainly take Lewis though.
I like the Jordan Lewis one though. However, I get the feeling we'd be offered steak knives for Goldsack, which is why their not targeting Brown or Reid, but the guy just in the 22 who was only included the second week.
We could hope for a Gary Moss or someone like that. I say Keep The Sack. I would certainly take Lewis though.
wonder if hawthorn would want Anthony?
XPISTO
Senior List
We delisted him didn't we?
Anyways, I would hate to see Goldy do but you have to listen to their offers. Goldy is just so flexible and he proved that against the Saints so preference is to keep him.
Why is everyone so keen on Lewis? Is he that good? Yeh he's tough but we have Blair and Beams coming through to fit that role I recon...
clogwearer
Idiot Savant
Only dropped by to offer congrats in another thread, but I noticed this and figured, while I'm here...
I hope the Pies stay wary. The Hay/Thompson trades have already been alluded to, and we look like being on the losing end of the Williams deal. All credit to Hawthorn for getting what they did from those trades (throw Croad in as well) and good luck to them, but it's probably time other clubs put on the cynical glasses in any trade deal.
I hope you don't come out second best if this goes ahead. If you have to trade, get someone who will be an asset to your club.*
* I have to add to this that I don't think the Roos lost completely in the Thompson deal, but it was fraught with danger.
I hope the Pies stay wary. The Hay/Thompson trades have already been alluded to, and we look like being on the losing end of the Williams deal. All credit to Hawthorn for getting what they did from those trades (throw Croad in as well) and good luck to them, but it's probably time other clubs put on the cynical glasses in any trade deal.
I hope you don't come out second best if this goes ahead. If you have to trade, get someone who will be an asset to your club.*
* I have to add to this that I don't think the Roos lost completely in the Thompson deal, but it was fraught with danger.
I love the Sack, but this is 2 years in a row he's been floated for trade. Not that it matters a great deal, but didn't he also follow the Hawks before we drafted him.
I'd be interested in a deal, bcause as much as I love Goldy, we do him no justice using him as a fringe player, but he really is stuck behind Maxy, Harry, Heater, Tooves for that defensive role and might be looking something more permanent.
Would have to be a good deal. Lewis is nice. This is probably complete rubbish, and there is no way Goldsack would get the deal done, but I've heard Mitchell possibly wants out, and there is more to the captaincy issue than they are letting on. Again, I think thats rubbish, but I heard it from a mate who follows the Hawks and has some minimal inside knowledge as best.
I'd be interested in a deal, bcause as much as I love Goldy, we do him no justice using him as a fringe player, but he really is stuck behind Maxy, Harry, Heater, Tooves for that defensive role and might be looking something more permanent.
Would have to be a good deal. Lewis is nice. This is probably complete rubbish, and there is no way Goldsack would get the deal done, but I've heard Mitchell possibly wants out, and there is more to the captaincy issue than they are letting on. Again, I think thats rubbish, but I heard it from a mate who follows the Hawks and has some minimal inside knowledge as best.
NT.Thunder
K2 Party Platter
- Jun 19, 2007
- 22,748
- 20,099
- AFL Club
- GWS
- Other Teams
- Pies
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/103821/default.aspx
Who could it be?
I would say possibly a 3-way about to happen but probably not the right time
Who could it be?I would say possibly a 3-way about to happen but probably not the right time
the mighty T
Premiership Player
if the price is right, im okay with it.
but no spud package of muston or dowler should be considered at all
id take lewis though
but no spud package of muston or dowler should be considered at all
id take lewis though
