Is Ben Reid going to Sydney next year?

[magpie_marty]

I posted about Reid to the swans earlier in the year and it was the first thing I thought of when he was dropped. I didn't consider that both Reid's could go to a third team like Richmond dees dogs saints Roos GC or Hawks but you never know if that's what they want.

Reid spent a fair bit of time on the pine at the weekend. Wasn't really that effective against the power. Too tall or poor matchup most of the time. Thought he was injured at quarter time but he came back on 10mins in. He did say he wasn't playing forward this year and was swung forward the very next game.

All things all if it's just a blip so be it but I wouldn't be that torn if he was traded given His injury history. Best of luck either way to Ben Reid and hope he's back at the top fir the pies soon

I hope it's not true but alas player movement will now become much the normal thing as it is and has been in the Rugby League for many years.

 

[Leviathan Pie]

I'm honestly ok with that.

Played a stinker against Port.

Think he's cooked.

 

[Markfs]

If he plays in the twos then he is gone. If he doesnt play then its bucks. if he plays but plays well then he is angling to go to the swans. if he plays but he doesnt play well then he is just waiting on which club his brother gets traded to.

 

[MyManLynch]

Yes, that's the Nutcracker alright...

As long as he doesn't play like the Sugar Plum Fairy

 

[AshW]

B Reid for Jones please

 

[pablo disco bar]

Bre

Nah apparently we want Casboult!

Brett or levi!???
whiskeytown and i are mates with casboults cousin.....and he is a unit!!

 

[pablo disco bar]

I daid it earlier and got shot down reid for alir alir and a 3rd round pick

 

[No SPIN]

My contacts say that he is on the outer. Bucks never liked him of course but that isnt unusual for Bucks. It's no coincidence that he was giving an interview a week or so back saying that he wanted to play with his bro..... if he's dropped again in the next 3 months we will know for sure... well it's usually being dropped 3 times but i think twice might be enough this time

What rubbish - on the outer and not liked by Bucks.
Obviously a fabrication, in an attempt to add substance to your speculation and to also justify starting this thread.

 

[loki04]

I'm honestly ok with that.

Played a stinker against Port.

No he didn't and I hope it is because of injury or are we tanking early?

 

[loki04]

What rubbish - on the outer and not liked by Bucks.
Obviously a fabrication, in an attempt to add substance to your speculation and to also justify starting this thread.

He is fishing.

Look at his posting history he only likes to take the piss of genuine posters.

No doubt someone has posted something similar about 1 player and he wants to take the piss out of them *trying* to be funny. He then gets a kick out of posters like you who don't realise he does it.

 

[Howezat]

I hold my breath every year with Ben, and you just know when we are really contending his body will let him down.

 

[Markfs]

What rubbish - on the outer and not liked by Bucks.
Obviously a fabrication, in an attempt to add substance to your speculation and to also justify starting this thread.

I think we take accusations of fake news very seriously around here. I understand if you're in a state of denial about all of this.... it seems that bucks just cant cope with coaching guys that he played with ...

 

[Braybrook Son]

Hey guys, not coming to troll, but how can you be dropping Reid? If anything he plays forward? Buckley and coaching panel has to go surely

 

[loki04]

Hey guys, not coming to troll, but how can you be dropping Reid? If anything he plays forward? Buckley and coaching panel has to go surely

Same reason you play your pick 6 Scharenberg in the VFL despite him getting 35 disposals in nearly every game there as a CHB. NFI.

 

[CFC2010]

What rubbish - on the outer and not liked by Bucks.
Obviously a fabrication, in an attempt to add substance to your speculation and to also justify starting this thread.

Didn't think you were that gullible No SPIN..........Markfs gets another one.

 

[CFC2010]

I think we take accusations of fake news very seriously around here. I understand if you're in a state of denial about all of this.... it seems that bucks just cant cope with coaching guys that he played with ...

Markfs he is on the "don't sack Bucks team" go easy on him mate.

 

[Braybrook Son]

Probably came back too early from his injury to properly contribute. That and, whilst Dunn is in the team and performing, he hasn't got a spot down back. Perhaps not showing enough as a forward.

How many games have you played him forward this year?

 

[unplugged]

How many games have you played him forward this year?

I could be wrong in saying this but only 2 from memory. The game where he injured himself and the game where he came back from injury. So technically his most recent two games.

 

[loki04]

How many games have you played him forward this year?

Be lucky to have played 4 quarters of footy forward over 2 games.

 

[Markfs]

Markfs he is on the "don't sack Bucks team" go easy on him mate.

we need to nobble him then. any friend of bucks is enemy of mine. nothing personal of course. but every year since bucks started coaching, the team has finished lower on the ladder. not many people know that. I think its critical. we had a dynasty in 2011. now we need a complete rebuild

 

[Vicky Park]

If he plays in the twos then he is gone. If he doesnt play then its bucks. if he plays but plays well then he is angling to go to the swans. if he plays but he doesnt play well then he is just waiting on which club his brother gets traded to.

This is one of the best analyses of a player's situation that I have seen on BF. I'm convinced.

 

[Markfs]

This is one of the best analyses of a player's situation that I have seen on BF. I'm convinced.

Thanks. I have an app that you can put several scenarios in and it gives the answers to what happens. I use it for approaching women in pubs...

 

[Vicky Park]

Thanks. I have an app that you can put several scenarios in and it gives the answers to what happens. I use it for approaching women in pubs...

You dont need an app. The answer to everything is that its Bucks' fault. Always.

 

[Frank Gallagher]

And Tony Shaws taking over from Buckley next year.

 

[TW Sherrin]

How many games have you played him forward this year?

Surprised a dog supporter would doubt bucks.

He knew Travis was cooked last year but you guys didnt.