- Oct 9, 2014
- 1,869
- 3,422
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspur FC
Don't mind the idea but pretty sure Brown is a free agentMight get slaughtered for this one.
St kilda trade: pick 10 to GWS
GWS trade: pick 16 and Steele to St kilda
Pick 32 to collingwood
Collingwood trade: jack frost or Nathan brown to St kilda
I agree on rating Steele but it's not really the deciding factor in the trade here, he's not a treloar commanding big value, fact is he's a fringe player and his full ability/potential won't be seen until he's a genuine mid like he will be with us, so his value isn't especially high, although certainly not low like some GWS players traded like sumner etc. I know the club views him in the second round trade bracket, and like their chances of getting him with a high 3rd, which we don't/won't have. 2017 2nd is fair value, even if we win the premiership and it's pick 36, don't think the giants can ask for too much more.No but in a trade thread where I rate a player, and a club that wants to trade him in dont see the value, a comparison to one of their own players I thought would get some thoughts about the value.
It might have been a bad approach I took, but I thought it was relevant.
I think I better just leave this thread. I just rate Steele as a player and have seen him play quite a bit.