Lions Drafting Discussion 2010 (no trade talk) #2

[BigCat2]

Interesting draft to follow so far, In Hadley We Trust.

So first 3 picks of Polec, Karnezis and Lester. We got these boys in exchange for Brennan and 10. I reckon if we get 1 star and 1 serviceable player out of those 3, we will have come out on top.

 

[cotter101]

why did we get karnizez why not go for halahan or parker or mitchell or a ruck? shitttttttttt apart from that we are all good with green lester and polec

 

[dlanod]

Compared to the outrage the Redden selection caused, it would seem Hadley now has some credit in the bank with BF posters...or maybe the rage needs time to ferment.

Don't speak too soon.

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showpost.php?p=19606178&postcount=98

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showpost.php?p=19606512&postcount=113



Bene's first comment (pre-edit) had us missing Darling with our first three selections, for extra amusement.

 

[The Golfing Lion]

Redden was a question mark..... Wouldn't swap him now
O'brien was a question mark ..... Developing well
we have drafted for speed it seems and a quick tall backman in Lester ..... IHWT

 

[Axel.]

why did we get karnizez why not go for halahan or parker or mitchell or a ruck? shitttttttttt apart from that we are all good with green lester and polec

Because we don't need anymore inside mids. I rate Karz higher than Mitchell.

 

[lionshine]

Matt Spanger just picked up by the Swans but Curnow and Sewell are yet to be picked up!

 

[loyallion]

LMAO sorry I just saw that Paul Seedman kid what a dorky looking kid Collingwood picked him hes 188cm and 70kgs wow hes anorexic

 

[cotter101]

yeh i spose but karz we needed a ruck or forward maybe mitchell or cook? sureley you gotta rate them better than karz. im still happy with polec lester is a utility which is good and green is super quick and will help our pace issues anyway next year we can focus on filling holes for when key players leave.

and why did we have to go and try and trade risky i bet we all regret that. he used to suck and this year he come and wins the bf and pisses off because we tried to trade him. o well karmas a bitch

 

[mickeyblueeyes37]

C'mon Shannon Rioli next

 

[Axel.]

yeh i spose but karz we needed a ruck or forward maybe mitchell or cook? sureley you gotta rate them better than karz. im still happy with polec lester is a utility which is good and green is super quick and will help our pace issues anyway next year we can focus on filling holes for when key players leave.

and why did we have to go and try and trade risky i bet we all regret that. he used to suck and this year he come and wins the bf and pisses off because we tried to trade him. o well karmas a bitch

Cook got taken before our pick.

 

[dlanod]

Matt Spanger just picked up by the Swans but Curnow and Sewell are yet to be picked up!

Both'll be rookie selections at a guess, despite Barlow's success this year. One or both may be headed to GWS.

 

[dlanod]

Saints take a Gamble on Gamble... After Pattison and Smith last year, I'm surprised they're dipping again but I guess they figure they won't get anyone better to make an immediate impact at pick 70+.

 

[Haggis McHaggis]

why did we get karnizez

After losing Rischitelli, I reckon we needed to get a bit of Mediterranean flavour back onto the list

 

[lionshine]

Zephi Skinner taken by the Doggies with pick 88. Quigs he was your smokey!

 

[dlanod]

Saints still recycling!

 

[dlanod]

Looks like the PSD is:
GC
Richmond
Essendon
Hawthorn
Freo

Barring anyone else getting delisted or quitting before LL3.

 

[humbird]

wow blues got a dream draft.

Didn't they what. Good on them! Lester and karnezis?? WTF! Darling ang lycett were there! Disappointed!

 

[Nuggo]

Shows that there is a bit of concern with our KP depth. I actually like the sounds of the two KP players we picked up.

 

[Bucking Beads]

We probably needed a ruckmen but who am I to judge, I am just a keyboard warrior.

 

[Axel.]

Didn't they what. Good on them! Lester and karnezis?? WTF! Darling ang lycett were there! Disappointed!

There are still major question marks over Darling and i can understand why we passed on him. Karnezis is also a very good player, don't worry about it. With Lycett we don't really need another ruck. Leui with Clark backing up. We can still pick up Mccauley or another ruckman in the rookie draft.

We still had 2 compo picks so we can pick up a quality KPF and ruckman next year.

 

[dlanod]

We probably needed a ruckmen but who am I to judge, I am just a keyboard warrior.

I'm guessing one of McCauley or McCollough will be back on the rookie list, if not both.

 

[The Flying Belgian]

Didn't they what. Good on them! Lester and karnezis?? WTF! Darling ang lycett were there! Disappointed!

Why are they better than what we got? Because groupthink says so?

 

[charles202]

I don't think that we addressed our KPP stocks at all both Karnezis and Lester look much more like flanker types, that's all right though we are pretty thin on the ground in that area as well.

Do people think that both Polec and Green could go straight into the top 21, would certainly address a lack of pace in the middle and up forward.

 

[PertRoosOsborne]

thumbs up to the new crew..welcome!!

hope to see the pups out on the track ASAP

 

[Nuggo]

Common people these guys haven't even kicked a ball in anger for the Lions and you are hacking on them. WTF.