Match committee. 'Select Hawthorns best 23 players 2000-2024

[peetoo]

This is part of celebrating 100 completed years of Hawthorn football club in VFL-AFL
Its easy to fill a team with three and four time premiership players. We really are that lucky

So the 17 already selected are:

B Stratton Lake ______
HB Birchall Gibson Burgoyne
C Hill S Mitchell I Smith
HF Rioli _____ Puopolo
F Bruest Roughead Gunston
R Hale Hodge (c) J Lewis

I Sheils plus 4

Options for remaining 6 spots ordered with 2 time and 1 time premiership weighting

 

[Judd2Sewell]

If I was to pick our best team from 2000 to date, it would be:

Sicily - Lake - Burgoyne
Hodge - Gibson - Birchall

McEvoy - Lewis - Newcombe
Smith - Mitchell - Crawford

Moore - Roughead - Gunston
Breust - Franklin - Rioli

Bench:
T. Mitchell
Hill
Stratton
Day
Hale

 

[Lawsy]

Not too far off what I'd have too:

Dimma - Lake - Sicily
Burgoyne - Gibson - Birch

McEvoy - Hodgey - T Mitchell
I Smith - Mitch - Crawf

Moore - Rough - Gunners
Breust - Buddy - Rioli

Bench:
J Smith, Hill, J Lewis, Newcombe,

I think even now, this teams foot skills would cut through oppo structures and we'd score heavily despite the lack of pace that is so important in Mitch's current day team.

 

[extractasam]

Not too far off what I'd have too:

Dimma - Lake - Sicily
Burgoyne - Gibson - Birch

McEvoy - Hodgey - T Mitchell
I Smith - Mitch - Crawf

Moore - Rough - Gunners
Breust - Buddy - Rioli

Bench:
J Smith, Hill, J Lewis, Newcombe,

I think even now, this teams foot skills would cut through oppo structures and we'd score heavily despite the lack of pace that is so important in Mitch's current day team.

Came here hoping for some Joel Smith love and wasn’t let down

 

[Dewyyyyy]

Sicily - Lake - Burgoyne
Hodge - Gibson - Birchall

McEvoy - Lewis - T.Mitchell
Smith - Mitchell - Crawford

Moore - Roughead - Gunston
Breust - Franklin - Rioli

Bench:
Hale
Newcombe
Day
Hardwick