- May 28, 2008
- 16,902
- 4,882
should head back to the vfl.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Rumour Nahas wants a move
- Thread starter mcuzzy
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Surely Melbourne would taken him off your hands for a second or third rounder.
They'd go much higher than that
Port Melbourne?
- Jan 23, 2007
- 4,570
- 3,239
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Not even Crazy is that crazy to consider him
Silverado
Club Legend
I hope you're also happy to give jack the flick based on that assumption?
Never seen a more petulant child on the field
Since Richo
- Aug 17, 2006
- 23,677
- 22,258
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Good luck to him, but I can't see him attracting much interest. He's done well to get to 80+ games, but I don't see him getting to 100. Just disregarding the fact that he hasn't been too flash this year, he's too old for a developing/rebuilding team to consider him and he's not good enough to be in any of the contenders' best 22s.
Name a team that would be interested in him as more than maybe a rookie list lifeline...I honestly can't think of one.
Name a team that would be interested in him as more than maybe a rookie list lifeline...I honestly can't think of one.
No thanks. We just let go of TDL, don't need another soft inconsistent small forward.
- Banned
- #60
Has been a massive disappointment all year.
Has been given lots of chances, but just stinks it up every time.
Is too small, gets rag dolled, can't kick it far, can't stick a tackle cos of his size, has a bad attitude, is not as quick as many think. Doesn't kick goals, and hasn't got the tank to play midfield. Hasn't got many tricks either.
Is that enough reasons?! So guilty as charged, vfl is probably his only option now.
Has been given lots of chances, but just stinks it up every time.
Is too small, gets rag dolled, can't kick it far, can't stick a tackle cos of his size, has a bad attitude, is not as quick as many think. Doesn't kick goals, and hasn't got the tank to play midfield. Hasn't got many tricks either.
Is that enough reasons?! So guilty as charged, vfl is probably his only option now.
Top_4_Tiger
Club Legend
- May 29, 2008
- 2,690
- 1,588
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Yeah that was shocking - such a poor attitude and he does it publically! Poor attitude. At least Mitch Morton had dignity and towed the team line when he was out of favour, so I'm happy for Mitch. But nahas is not a team first player... His body language as a sub in round 1 was the nail in the coffin for me.
Not to mention he's a small forward with poor skills. As a small forward, you need elite kicking skills and the ability to rove a pack - he struggles with both.
Has also tried kicking goals from the boundary 45 metres out without looking for a teammate because he's playing for himself. This is from a player that struggles to kick 30 metres with a man on the mark.
Having said that, he can be a good player.
I just hate his attitude and question the consistency of a small forward who can't kick.
Exactly, his stupid attitude is holding him back.
"His stupid attitude"?
As a poster said earlier... what about Jack Riewoltd? he has the worst attitude in the AFL and continuosly sooks.
For what its worth i think Nahas is a good player when allowed to play his role which is an outside runner..
top % in AFL last year for tackles, defensive pressure and 2nd @ richmond for goals
couldn't have been a fluke
As a poster said earlier... what about Jack Riewoltd? he has the worst attitude in the AFL and continuosly sooks.
For what its worth i think Nahas is a good player when allowed to play his role which is an outside runner..
top % in AFL last year for tackles, defensive pressure and 2nd @ richmond for goals
couldn't have been a fluke
Top_4_Tiger
Club Legend
- May 29, 2008
- 2,690
- 1,588
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Very different type of poor attitude. Jack is capable of providing leadership and is a good clubman off-field, apples and oranges.
Nah. We only wanted Post and McGuane.
Suckling2Gunston
Team Captain
He's stupid too it seems, either that or his manager reamed him in contract negotiations.
Suckling2Gunston
Team Captain
He would be horrible in either of those sides. Small crumbing forwards are the first to suffer in a struggling side. Less inside 50's equal less opportunities, combined with the fact he can't play anywhere else and has no tricks, he ain't going nowhere unless it's the VFL.
- Banned
- #68
Didn't realise Nahas had two Coleman medals a best and fairest and an All Australian to his name
Brotherfox
Team Captain
I think everyone is disappointed in Jack . He is a good player at times , yes I do realise the accolades , but he could be such a better player .
What is it with Richmond forwards and attitudes ? yes I' m talking about Richo also .
Imagine playing forward for Richmond this past decade, probably the most frustrating job in football at times
Zach Package
Prespakis2Tsatas
one of the last of the ben nason generation.
getting rid of him and king would be real progress for the tiges
Brotherfox
Team Captain
that's true but you cant show that frustration as a leader .
I agree but I'm more prepared to cop it from a player of Riewoldts calibre than I am for someone like Nahas
Brotherfox
Team Captain
wow , bombers and tigers supporters agreeing on something !
send us to fix up the middle east !!
send us to fix up the middle east !!
