MRP / Trib. Nankervis Straight To Tribunal

[Roachy8]

They need to be consistent though. I have no arguments if they are consistent Nank's bump was clumsy. If Nank gets 4 Stewart should have got 5 or 6. And what's the bet if one of the media darlings like Cripps will get zero if it means they will be out for finals.

Consistency is a major challenge sadly as incidents that look the same generally have marginal differences.

Nank's was less brutal and late than Stewart's IMO.
Stewart aught to have got 5 but got 4 - without this years AFL "added loading" I would say Nank aught to be 2 or 3 but will get 4 I think.

& then you throw in the Cripps debacle last year, I'm happy to say he was contesting for a very hard ball in dispute and got 'unlucky' but due to the outcome should have got 2 regardless - but of course somehow he got off.

Compare this to our Mansell one this year - 3 for that very very 'normal' football contest was ridiculous IMO.

 

[Muddiemoose]

Consistency is a major challenge sadly as incidents that look the same generally have marginal differences.

Nank's was less brutal and late than Stewart's IMO.
Stewart aught to have got 5 but got 4 - without this years AFL "added loading" I would say Nank aught to be 2 or 3 but will get 4 I think.

& then you throw in the Cripps debacle last year, I'm happy to say he was contesting for a very hard for ball in dispute and got 'unlucky' but due to the outcome should have got 2 regardless - but of course somehow he got off.

Compare this to our Mansell one this year - 3 for that very very 'normal' football contest was ridiculous IMO.

Stewart’s hit was also last year

The landscape has changed so no point trying to draw a comparison in terms of the punishment

 

[Roachy8]

Stewart’s hit was also last year

The landscape has changed so no point trying to draw a comparison in terms of the punishment

I think that's what I said - last year v this year being considering significantly differently.
Based on this years criteria and trends Stewart would be looking at up to 6.
Based on last years criteria and trends Nank would be looking at 2 -3 IMO.

BUT - he will get 4 and probably fair enough....

 

[Muddiemoose]

I think that's what I said - last year v this year being considering significantly differently.
Based on this years criteria and trends Stewart would be looking at up to 6.
Based on last years criteria and trends Nank would be looking at 2 -3 IMO.

BUT - he will get 4 and probably fair enough....

Yeah 100% agree

 

[Football Tragic]

I think Nank will get 4 weeks. The AFL seem to be going extra hard on Richmond this year and Nanks act was more severe than Mansell's. I honestly think the AFL is scared shiteless over all this class actions and are trying everything they can to prove how seriously they are taking it. They always seem to have a bugbear they focus on each and every year - centre circle, hands in the back, slide rule, rushed behind, deliberate out of bounds, protected area, stand rule, abusing/touching umpires, etc etc etc and they almost always are reacting to an event or incident. This year, its all about the head and will continue to be until the law suit has run its course.

I just hate it when the powers that be, add extra wood to the tribunal fire, just so that our players are burnt to a crisp on yet another AFL witch hunt.

 

[Punt rd end]

Surely it couldn't be more than degooey's

 

[Muddiemoose]

Surely it couldn't be more than degooey's

Wouldn’t think so but who knows

Think it will be 3 but wouldn’t be shocked if it’s 4 either and both probably in the range of being the correct punishment as well imo

 

[_RT_]

 

[_RT_]

Old mate Tovey is up again. See Toby in 2024

 

[_RT_]

 

[captain blood 17]

One week for this mate

View attachment 1735114

Times have changed and Nank has form. Let's see who's closer to the pin. You go 1, I'll go 4.

 

[_RT_]

 

[_RT_]

 

[beema limapep]

Times have changed and Nank has form. Let's see who's closer to the pin. You go 1, I'll go 4.

Let me be clear, if that's worth 4, even in 2023 this website will have a mutiny on its hands.

 

[beema limapep]

Shout out to the Zit. Love your work mate. Keep on poppin'.

 

[_RT_]

 

[tiger_tough]

AFL asking for the 4 weeks, as expected. Nankervis accepting responsibility and trying his best to show his remorse, as expected.

3 weeks coming up.

 

[Gunit]

Zitman is back

 

[_RT_]

 

[_RT_]

 

[_RT_]

 

[beema limapep]

By the whole falling on our sword approach, Nank might get 5-6 at this rate.

 

[Coach_Required]

Heard Meehan is part of our defence team specialising in biomechanics.

5 weeks in coming.

 

[_RT_]

 

[Mr Unbelievable]