Official 2012 Trade Period Discussion (#2)

[Turly]

Lulwot? Is this serious?

Yes a great leader on and off the field.

Why is that so hard to believe??

 

[iGNITER]

Murphy is a dud. Probably a case of a club overrating someone because they were a role player for a top club. Hawthorn's Toovey.

Pretty happy with Toovey to be honest. Im sure your new coach would love to have him as a small defender.

 

[Hard_to_Beat]

McIntosh has passed all of Geelongs fitness tests.

He is no longer officially "injury riddled"

Pick 15.

 

[alfy!]

McIntosh has passed all of Geelongs fitness tests.

He is no longer officially "injury riddled"

Pick 15.

Is that what you want or what you've heard? I seriously doubt we'd give up pick 15 for him.

 

[Sin City]

McIntosh has passed all of Geelongs fitness tests.

He is no longer officially "injury riddled"

Pick 15.

At least be realistic.

 

[Sharks On A Plane]

Absolutely its Serious! Highest order type guy! To be honest, in a way in the Category of not hugely naturally skilled but works his arse off to get every bit of value out of that skill! He isn't the most creative user of the ball but is a guy you set a job in the backline then you just worry about your other guys as you know he will do his! Doesn't use the ball as well as our other backs and that is why he struggled for a spot. IMHO it says more about our side then him that he isn't in the teams best 22/25!

Please punctuate the following sentence for me:

Myra had the baby

 

[Jab]

Please punctuate the following sentence for me:

Myra had the baby

Myra had the baby!

Happy now, Elaine?

 

[Geddy Lee]

Please punctuate the following sentence for me:

Myra had the baby

Myra! Had! The! Baby!

 

[bombermick]

Murphy is a good pick up for the Suns. He's not the greatest player, but he'll give experience to their backline and by all reports will set a good example.

 

[TheLastEmperor]

McIntosh has passed all of Geelongs fitness tests.

He is no longer officially "injury riddled"

Pick 15.

Not your crap again

 

[Varicho]

McIntosh has passed all of Geelongs fitness tests.

He is no longer officially "injury riddled"

Pick 15.

You obviously enjoy being ridiculed...

 

[demon_dynasty13]

Geez Melbourne are just throwing darts out at anyone, and hoping one of them sticks...

smells of desperation.

it does doesnt it. i'm not sure that neeld was the best choice as coach for their club.

LOL

Mark Neeld working the media beautifully

He has has you in the palm of his hand. Beautiful to watch.

 

[Footy Smarts]

McIntosh has passed all of Geelongs fitness tests.

He is no longer officially "injury riddled"

Pick 15.

Now we just wait for him to be traded to Geelong for pick 55 and Orren Stephenson. It'll be almost as fun as that time Caddy was certain of going to North...

 

[BEEG]

Surprised Geelong are chasing HMac

All i have heard from them for 2 years is how much ruck depth they have at the club

 

[alfy!]

Surprised Geelong are chasing HMac

All i have heard from them for 2 years is how much ruck depth they have at the club

We do have great guys coming through, but no legit number 1 ruckman. We hope HMac can fill that role.

 

[coryne]

McIntosh has passed all of Geelongs fitness tests.

He is no longer officially "injury riddled"

Pick 15.

Bwahahahahaha. Is this coming from the same "source" you used when telling everyone Caddy was going to North, or just what you are HOPING you get for him ???

 

[pantskyle]

Bwahahahahaha. Is this coming from the same "source" you used when telling everyone Caddy was going to North, or just what you are HOPING you get for him ???

Don't forget the first rounder for Pedersen.

 

[scottwade]

Also Silvagni apparently delisted so can be signed as a delisted free agent, wont cost a thing. Pretty young too. Was good last year.

You've lost me.

Are you suggesting Freo are delisting a senior list player and then re-sign him, but not through the draft?

 

[Wizard]

You've lost me.

Are you suggesting Freo are delisting a senior list player and then re-sign him, but not through the draft?

What would be the purpose of doing that??

 

[Varicho]

LOL

Mark Neeld working the media beautifully

He has has you in the palm of his hand. Beautiful to watch.

He should probably focus on the making that shambles of a list he has work. And your palm seems to be wrapped around your knob.

 

[Username_lost]

Andrew Lowther from AFL.com.au reckons "McIntosh for - at best - Geelong's late second round (currently pick 36)" He also said McIntosh is almost a certainty to be traded to Geelong. Sounds about right to me.

 

[carltonsux]

any news on the gumbleton front??

 

[Username_lost]

any news on the gumbleton front??

there's a rumour floating around that his 'discs are gone' based on a medical report, but I don't know.

 

[Freddy Bassett]

Murphy is a dud. Probably a case of a club overrating someone because they were a role player for a top club. Hawthorn's Toovey.

Toovey is a bloody good player. Very harsh

 

[ziad]

there's a rumour floating around that his 'discs are gone' based on a medical report, but I don't know.

that would not be good