Mega Thread Oh yeah ... did you know there are 17 other teams? - General AFL discussion #9 - Blues posters only

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Just reading the John Anderson's top 10 smartest trade deals (AFL.com) and got a little worried when I seen what Collingwood did in 2004 with MM there.

Basically traded away the opportunity to have Jordan Lewis and Mark Lecras to acquire Chris Egan and Chad Morrison with some other bits and pieces involved.

I know hindsight is a wonderful thing but I hope we dont have any sort of howler like this.

Then again is it Hawthorn just being better then most to to get these deals done as the Gunston deal in the same article is another great coup for them.


All coaches/recruiters have had howlers, Cameron Wood for pick 14 is the one from Micks past that has had me worried. Have to trust his experience and judgement will work out more often than not.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Well said.

Can we finally say end of an era at Geelong???
That's the scary part.
This year's team is a different outfit to the team of 07 and 08... Even 09.

We need geelong's people here now
 
Well said.

Can we finally say end of an era at Geelong???

And Chris Scott will finally have to start building his own premiership team. He has been working with the remains of Bombers team for the last couple of years and the 2011 team won the flag rather than Scott making any miracle moves from the coaching box.

It's like Parkins has always said about the Carlton '95 premiership team... any one could have walked in there off the street as coach and we still would have won the premiership that year.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

What a player.
So reliable - just went about his business with a minimum on fuss and got the job done every week.
Will be missed by the Cats.

Yep. Well said...and exactly the same could be said about Enright who will probably be next...

I remember a story in the HUN about the 'Two Coreys' way back when...they started around the same time, just two kids playing footy together...goddamn that club managed to put something freakish together...
 
St. Kilda are dumb as shit.

Their recruitment is among the worst in the league so they trade their 24 year old star ruck for an end of first round draft pick.

Can someone please end them?
 
St. Kilda are dumb as shit.

Their recruitment is among the worst in the league so they trade their 24 year old star ruck for an end of first round draft pick.

how quickly do you reckon McEvoy agreed to the trade.

St Kilda: Big Boy, you are a much loved player at the club but we have had an idea. We send you to the reigning premiers in Hawthorn and we get a draft pick and Randy Savage. Now what are your thoughts?
Big Boy: Where do I sign?
St Kilda: Now don't rush your decision, why don't you take some time to think about what this means for you and your family and your future football prospects.
Big Boy: Just give me the damn paperwork and a pen, so I can start packing my locker.
 
I saw James Reyne & Mark Seymour today at tafe this morning. They were doing a sausage sizzle.

None of the people in my class knew who they were :eek:


Was Mick Malthouse with them? Heard he enjoys a good sausage sizzle.
 
Not entirely convinced McEvoy is what Hawthorn need? He's an excellent contested mark and pretty good around the ground, but he's by no means a great tap ruckman.

Still think they've won the trade, strange decision by St Kilda.... you just don't trade promising 24 year olds you've put so much effort into unless you're forced to! Especially since they are so light on for players in that age bracket.
 
Not entirely convinced McEvoy is what Hawthorn need? He's an excellent contested mark and pretty good around the ground, but he's by no means a great tap ruckman.

Still think they've won the trade, strange decision by St Kilda.... you just don't trade promising 24 year olds you've put so much effort into unless you're forced to! Especially since they are so light on for players in that age bracket.


Think it'll suit Hawks very well actually. Hale is a decent ruck/forward and McEvoy is a decent ruck/floating back. Will work well with their zoning gameplan.

Trade was roughly about right for mine, Saints probably deserved a bit more but they aren't really looking to use their later picks anyway so anything Hawks could have given them in that vein wouldn't have been that great for them.
 
Jane Kennedy ‏@Jane_L_Kennedy For the Hawks fans

BWMls59CQAAw5Zd.jpg
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top