List Mgmt. Pick your Round 1 team for 2014

[blaze036]

Yea you forgot the Seed

I don't have the seed in my best 22 at the moment.

A strong first few VFL games would probably get him in, but with shaw and toovey missing from the defence I think we need to put defenders back there who are actually good at defending to make up for this absence. Whilst seedsmen provides good run and carry and can deliver a nice 55 metre pass his defending is weak and has very little accountability.

Perhaps if we get toovey back we have more flexibility to bring an attacking player in or if young breaks down again he is the logical replacement.

Probably harsh to not have him as an emergency but I guess that means we are building good depth.

 

[nahnah]

FB: Tooves Brown Williams
HB: Seed Keefe Sidey
C: O'bizzle Ball Young
Hf: Beams Reid Elliott
FF: Reid Cloke Fasolo
RR: Grundy Pendles Swan
Int: Adams Thomas Caff Goldsack
Emg: Karnezis Blair Sincs

Depth: Broomy, kennedy, dwyer, pick 6, pick 10,
Love that team.... three emergencies unlucky but will get games obviously. Caff and goldsack will have to perform or they will be replace quickly.

 

[blaze036]

Can't see Toovey being rushed back for round 1.

It's a long season, sinclair is capable of holding down the fort early on while toovey gets eased back into it

 

[Sub_Zero]

Can't see Toovey being rushed back for round 1.

It's a long season, sinclair is capable of holding down the fort early on while toovey gets eased back into it

lol you have Mooney in over Ball, Seedsman, Goldsack and Macaffer

 

[blaze036]

lol you have Mooney in over Ball, Seedsman, Goldsack and Macaffer

Yep, one of our best VFL players and his improvement curve is very steep, has electric pace that we need.

Goldsack and macaffer had disappointing years imo, seedsmen is very overrated and I think Ball is well into his twilight sadly with all the injuries he has had

 

[Spuddd]

Ok, this is an edit of my first post here, given the new trades.

Team as it stands today
FB: Williams, Brown, Toovey
HB: Young, Reid, Sidebottom
C: Thomas, Ball, Obrien
HF: Beams, White, Adams
FF: Elliot, Cloke, Seedsman
Foll: Grundy, Swan, Pendlebury
Bench: Blair, Mcaffer, Goldsack
Sub: Dwyer

First to come in in case of poor form or injury (in preference order):
Backs; Maxwell,
Mids; Sinclair, Karnezies, Fasolo (wing)
Forwards; Lynch/Karnezies (depending on whos out), Fasolo, Dwyer
Ruck; Witts, Hudson

Hopefully never have to see pull on the Black and White again:
Marty Clarke

 

[Baird]

Goldsack and macaffer had disappointing years imo, seedsmen is very overrated and I think Ball is well into his twilight sadly with all the injuries he has had

Still better options then Mooney

 

[blaze036]

Still better options then Mooney

in 2013 yes, I'm assuming his development continues on its quick upward path

 

[jhndos]

Maxwell Capt VFL
Fasolo get real why do we rate him so high he has done FFFall will be gone 2015

FB Williams Brown Keefe
HB Seedsman Reid O'Brien
C Sidebottom Adams Young
HF Beams Lynch / White ?????? wish it was Garlett
F Swan Cloke Elliot

Foll Grundy Ball Pendles

Int Goldy Dwyer Karnesis Blair /Sinclair/ Caff /Hudson/Fasolo

 

[magpies2013]

B Williams brown maxwell
Hb toovey Keefe young
C obrien pendles sidebottom
HF goldsack white beams
F Elliott clocke Reid
Foll Grundy swan ball
Inter fasalo Adams Blair Kennedy
Emerg seed mccaffer wits
Seedsman to soft for my liking

 

[sr36]

in 2013 yes, I'm assuming his development continues on its quick upward path

Has there really been that much improvement?

 

[blaze036]

Has there really been that much improvement?

Well to go from never ever playing a game of football in 2011 to one of our best VFL players in 2013 I would say his improvement is fairly decent

 

[sr36]

Well to go from never ever playing a game of football in 2011 to one of our best VFL players in 2013 I would say his improvement is fairly decent

I only saw tv games, but to me he was far from one of our best VFL players.

 

[Pies12]

B: Williams Brown Goldsack
HB: Sidebottom Keefe Toovey
C: Beams Swan O'Brien
HF: Elliot White Adams
F: Reid Cloke Fasolo
R: Grundy Ball Pendlebury
I: Young Sinclair Macaffer Thomas

EM: Kennedy Seedsman Dwyer Karnezis

 

[blaze036]

I only saw tv games, but to me he was far from one of our best VFL players.

There was only 1-2 collingwood VFL games on tv all year wasn't there

 

[sloth6]

Tooves Brown Williams
Seedsman keefe sidebottom
Young Ball Harry O
Fasolo White Beams
Elliot Cloke Reid

Grundy Swan pendles

Inter from: Goldsack, Blair, Adams, Macaffer

 

[Jonno94]

Yep, one of our best VFL players and his improvement curve is very steep, has electric pace that we need.

Goldsack and macaffer had disappointing years imo, seedsmen is very overrated and I think Ball is well into his twilight sadly with all the injuries he has had

By your logic, we should draft Usain Bolt and stick him in our 22.

 

[sr36]

There was only 1-2 collingwood VFL games on tv all year wasn't there

Not many. Which is why I asked whether he has actually improved much, because in the incredibly small sample that I saw, he looked the same limited player that he was the year before.

 

[sr36]

By your logic, we should draft Usain Bolt and stick him in our 22.

I'd be all for that.

 

[blaze036]

By your logic, we should draft Usain Bolt and stick him in our 22.

ok

 

[Breakthelines]

I don't have the seed in my best 22 at the moment.

A strong first few VFL games would probably get him in, but with shaw and toovey missing from the defence I think we need to put defenders back there who are actually good at defending to make up for this absence. Whilst seedsmen provides good run and carry and can deliver a nice 55 metre pass his defending is weak and has very little accountability.

Perhaps if we get toovey back we have more flexibility to bring an attacking player in or if young breaks down again he is the logical replacement.

Probably harsh to not have him as an emergency but I guess that means we are building good depth.

But you have Mooney? Sorry, Mooney is a bum. Should have been delisted!

 

[blaze036]

But you have Mooney? Sorry, Mooney is a bum. Should have been delisted!

Well no, anyone who has seen him play in 2013 could not possibly make that opinion with a straight face

 

[Breakthelines]

Well no, anyone who has seen him play in 2013 could not possibly make that opinion with a straight face

So you Believe his performances at AFL were good?

 

[blaze036]

So you Believe his performances at AFL were good?

Well seeing I clearly said that isn't the answer obvious?

 

[Breakthelines]

Well seeing I clearly said that isn't the answer obvious?

Obviously we were watching different games...