Opinion Player list management and game plan 2019 part 2

[MrChow]

would Gold Coast trade 6 and a late second rounder to us, for 10 and 15. With the proviso they don't trade Rozee and Rankine at 2/3. Thoughts?

1. Walsh
2. Luko
3. King
4. Smith
5. Rozee
6. Rankine

 

[philthy05]

Pls pls let us trade Amon and Neade for picks 50 and 70


Pls.

 

[dav3]

 

[philthy05]

We ****ed up massively by not putting Ebert on the table to join hombsch at gcs.

It would have taken balls to do it, but he is very expendable in our midfield and gcs would overpay for him.

What could we have gotten for him from gcs? 2nd rounder? More ?

Next year could be worth less if he doesn’t lift massively.

 

[Felipe16]

If Shiel was open to moving to Carlton as is being rumoured, a trade idea:

Carlton receive Dylan Shiel
Port receive Pick 1
GWS receive Pick 5, Pick 15

Wouldn't this make sense for all involved?

 

[Young Gun #6]

If Shiel was open to moving to Carlton as is being rumoured, a trade idea:

Carlton receive Dylan Shiel
Port receive Pick 1
GWS receive Pick 5, Pick 15

Wouldn't this make sense for all involved?

That is an overpay by Carlton.

 

[FallingLiefs]

is Connors Amon's agent?

just strolled in with Carlton.

 

[raglan road]

One thing about this off field group is they ain’t lyres.

If they got the vibe that Chad was going to leave at the end of the year then we have done the right thing.

Some questions need to be asked of Clarkson that’s for sure.

So Clarkson's to blame now? That's just your opinion on their credibility, I don't happen to share it.

 

[dav3]

is Connors Amon's agent?

just strolled in with Carlton.

Nope, might be to do with Beams

EDIT: Actually he's Shiel's manager too, so that'll be it

 

[Doctor Feel]

Every time I hear "Port speedster Karl amon" I lol.

Speedster.

 

[philthy05]

is Connors Amon's agent?

just strolled in with Carlton.

Mmmm

Blues only have 69 and 71. Picks that very rarely get used.

I would push for 69 and future 4th but can’t see that happening when we’re this inept.

 

[Coobk001]

Davies just said outright Chad wanted to go to Hawks - so not ousted by club..... said he wanted to go next year regardless to Hawks. So sounds like Chad wanted out, Davies was pretty clear cut to say that, interesting.

Don't get sucked into the rhetoric.

CD before and during the early phases of the trade period. " Wingard has NOT said he wants to be traded, when he does we'll have that discussion"

Then Wingard is traded, supporter base fuming

CD comes out and says "Wingard told us after the season he wanted to be traded"

Anyone that believes this shit is an idiot.

We all know he has been pushed out. It's bloody obvious, from posters in the know and leaks on this board, to the numerous posts pre-trade period by Chad highlighting his desire to NOT move, it is clear and we all know now that Wingard has been pushed out.

It's a disgrace and highlights how seriously wrong things are going within the club.

Not even the RCG crew or the lemming group could surely deny this.

 

[Black 18]

At least we didn't trade next year's 1st. Trading Wingard could still bring the top 3 pick he deserved...

Don't get too comfy.

You can still trade picks right up until the draft, and the during.

Heaps of time for Cripps to continue the destruction.

 

[Raffo]

Every time I hear "Port speedster Karl amon" I lol. Speedster.

Carn, the speed at which he can kick it OOF is elite

 

[Marmozet]

Every time I hear "Port speedster Karl amon" I lol.

Speedster.

Flashbacks to him getting run down against Carlton

 

[Vic_Vinegar]

WTF? Cocaine is a hell of a drug

 

[Pappagallo]

View attachment 575404 WTF? Cocaine is a hell of a drug

It’s certainly against the grain considering that it’s 11 years and counting since we finished that high after the regular season.

 

[Young Gun #6]

Analysis on the Trade show on Fox Footy:

Brad Johnson and Dal Santo
Grade: C
2019 Ladder Spot: 4th (Johnson), 8th (Dal Santo)

Interestingly they had Hawks slipping out of the 8.

 

[GremioPower]

I would like to see us trading fairly just once. It doesn't need to be overs. Really!

 

[MotlopRules]

Don't get sucked into the rhetoric.

CD before and during the early phases of the trade period. " Wingard has NOT said he wants to be traded, when he does we'll have that discussion"

Then Wingard is traded, supporter base fuming

CD comes out and says "Wingard told us after the season he wanted to be traded"

Anyone that believes this shit is an idiot.

We all know he has been pushed out. It's bloody obvious, from posters in the know and leaks on this board, to the numerous posts pre-trade period by Chad highlighting his desire to NOT move, it is clear and we all know now that Wingard has been pushed out.

It's a disgrace and highlights how seriously wrong things are going within the club.

Not even the RCG crew or the lemming group could surely deny this.

Yep, but just watch certain posters try to constantly peddle this 'Wingard was always leaving' bullshit as a way to exonerate the club.

Gaslighting at its finest.

 

[blackdiamond]

is Connors Amon's agent?

just strolled in with Carlton.

No, Liam Pickering

 

[charcolechaddy]

So Clarkson's to blame now? That's just your opinion on their credibility, I don't happen to share it.

I think he had his role to play, just like when he traded guys who then came down with mental health issues.

He has a knack of getting guys to the club he needs and convince them in a heart beat to come.

You can share what you like and I’m not saying it is fact , but if it did happen we may have dodged a bullet .

 

[Ports1870]

 

[philthy05]

For ****s sake we honestly couldn’t find someone to take Amon and Neade off our hands

 

[philthy05]

And dogs get a 2nd and 3rd rounder for a key defender that is injured more often than hombsch and hasn’t half the good games hombsch has had at AFL level.