-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Player X or Player Y (part 2)
- Thread starter 54Dogs
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
I'd seriously consider Justin Westhoff..... He'll basically be playing the Richo role on the wing and has been gathering touches with ease and kicking goals.
Beau Waters or Rick Ladson ?
Gray?^
On that, Pearce will be number one tagged, then Boak, will there be room left for Gray. Gray has been both BOG for us now R22 V NM, Internal Trial and Friday Night V Dogs. He's a freak at clearances.
At the same time Gia has been brilliant and is most likely in the premiership team, and Banner has been very impressive. So yeah, Banner and Gia.
I'd go with Nick Maxwell Crow_68. Captains are usually a good bet.
---
Okay, please forgive me, I have literally not been following any club but mine and can't go through all theses threads to find injuries, etc..
Hille or Ottens
Warren or Dangerfield
Kennelly or X.Clarke or Buckley or Waters or Paul Stewart* or someone of that price
And, has Barlow been upgraded yet? Thanks in advance guys.
*Paul Stewart has been super impressive this preseason but I may just might have rose-coloured glasses on. Probably in our best 22 atm, does anyone else think he'll do good?
On that, Pearce will be number one tagged, then Boak, will there be room left for Gray. Gray has been both BOG for us now R22 V NM, Internal Trial and Friday Night V Dogs. He's a freak at clearances.
At the same time Gia has been brilliant and is most likely in the premiership team, and Banner has been very impressive. So yeah, Banner and Gia.
I'd go with Nick Maxwell Crow_68. Captains are usually a good bet.
---
Okay, please forgive me, I have literally not been following any club but mine and can't go through all theses threads to find injuries, etc..
Hille or Ottens
Warren or Dangerfield
Kennelly or X.Clarke or Buckley or Waters or Paul Stewart* or someone of that price
And, has Barlow been upgraded yet? Thanks in advance guys.
*Paul Stewart has been super impressive this preseason but I may just might have rose-coloured glasses on. Probably in our best 22 atm, does anyone else think he'll do good?
Hille, they are both risky cos of obvious injury concerns, but Ottens is extra risky as Cats may be inclined to rest/nurse him through even if he is reasonably fit to make sure he is right for finals. If Hille is fit he will het consistent good TOG.
Throw Hunt and Ladsen into that mix. These 3 + Waters wil increase and should all be in 22. X is injured, Kennely may not score that well, and Stewart may not be in 22.
No news on Barlow but he is certainty to get upgraded; looks great.
Ryder and Gray
OR
McEvoy and Riewoldt
Ryder and Gray...
1 of Hille, Naitanui and Seaby
and
3 of Medhurst, Ziebell, Ballantyne and Dangerfield
and
3 of Medhurst, Ziebell, Ballantyne and Dangerfield
Gray or Porplyzia or Tippet?
Gray for mine, he looks like a gun in the making. Porps is injured. Tippett could should improve some too.
Melb Tengrove V Banner
Is it worth spending the extra 60K on Tengrove?
I Haven't with port been in the bottom 4 imo this year, they are gonna wanna play their young players..as well as Melbourne so go banner and save 60k
Armitage, josh kennedy (Syd), luke ball
Armitage, looks set to be a gun. Tackling machine.
Broughton vs. Fisher
Cooney vs. Deledio
Armitage vs. Masten
and finally:
Broughton/Cooney/Armitage vs. Fisher/Deledio/Masten
Armitage, looks set to be a gun. Tackling machine.
Broughton vs. Fisher, Gilbert seems to be the one the saints want to get lose
Cooney vs. Deledio, Cooney is more suited to supercoach
Armitage vs. Masten, Can't see masten having a good dreamteam year.
and finally:
Broughton/Cooney/Armitage vs. Fisher/Deledio/Masten
Thougts in bold
- Oct 27, 2009
- 10,131
- 20
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Banned
- #562
Goddard/Gray v Gram/Aker.
1st option easily
Goddard is a captain option and has the ability to average 100 again the year. Gray could be last years Higgins and showed promising signs on Friday night.
Gram is good but nowhere near Goddard's ability in DT. Aker is getting old, I struggle to see him averaging enough to be a keeper.
Pav or O'Keefe
- Oct 27, 2009
- 10,131
- 20
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Banned
- #564
Cheers for that.
- Banned
- #565
At this stage I would have to take Pav, he should average around 100 playing forward rather than midfield. ATM I actually have both in my team but if i had to choose one it would be Pavlich.
PS: I have completely lost interest of DreamTeam recently, has anything changed from March 1 when I started to lose interest? Like anyone who has come out from nowhere or any injuries.
Cheers, Lucky26
PS: I have completely lost interest of DreamTeam recently, has anything changed from March 1 when I started to lose interest? Like anyone who has come out from nowhere or any injuries.
Cheers, Lucky26
- Oct 27, 2009
- 10,131
- 20
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Banned
- #566
I'd actually go with O'Keefe. He'll be playing in the midfield while Pav will stay in the forward line and i'm not really convinced he'll score well with the delivery he'll get.
bartel and waters vs boyd and myers/ladson
thoughts?
thoughts?
psafootystar
Rookie
should my mids be
swan,selwood,mitchell,watson,ball,martin(shuey/banner,barlow)
or
swan,selwood,mitchell,watson,shuey/banner,martin(shuey/banner,barlow) +279k
who do you rate better shuey or banner?
swan,selwood,mitchell,watson,ball,martin(shuey/banner,barlow)
or
swan,selwood,mitchell,watson,shuey/banner,martin(shuey/banner,barlow) +279k
who do you rate better shuey or banner?
Out of Barlow, Trengrove, Scully, Martin, Banner, Sheuy which 3 should I have?
My thoughts.
- Oct 27, 2009
- 10,131
- 20
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Banned
- #571
Bartel and Waters. Both apparently in good form while Ladson isn't. Maybe Boyd and Waters will be good.
Gia/Ball v LeCras/Watson.
Masten or Ward?
the first choice by a big way.
At a push, Masten. But I think Shiels is a better option than both.
Maxwell/S. Stevens v Duffield/Ladson?
RedFeather
Senior List
Just a few quick ones:
Jackson Trengove v Lobbe.
- If you picked Lobbe; Trengove v Davis
Shuey v Lewis Jetta
Tippett v Kreuzer
Jackson Trengove v Lobbe.
- If you picked Lobbe; Trengove v Davis
Shuey v Lewis Jetta
Tippett v Kreuzer
- Status
