Draft Expert PMBangers' (and ‘friends’) 2022 Draft Board

[jimmcconnell]

Blake Drury, Cooper Harvey & Emille-Brennan I would've thought.

Surprised Isaac Keeler, Adam D'Aloia & Anthony Munkara aren't in his top 25.

I agree with this. The rest of the 25 seems pretty bang on.

 

[Couch Coach]

Has anyone got access to Kevin Sheahans Top 75 list that they could post up here? Not subscribing for 3 months just to check his list. Got kids to feed

I have posted it in the Collingwood draft thread if you want access.

Copied to 2022 AFL Draft General Discussion

 

[blueiris]

If shifter is putting some of those names in the 25 and also came up with a list for 2023 the guy has not been watching footy. I suspect the herald sun has done the lists and just put shifters name on the article.

Shifter was commentating the under 18’s on Saturday on Foxtel

 

[pushintheback]

Shifter was commentating the under 18’s on Saturday on foxte

Yeah I watched it. He only new about the likes of Ashcroft, Caddy, Davey, Sheezel, Hewett.
However, Cal Twomey knows everyone and their background. I’d like to see his top 25.

 

[pushintheback]

Also just to be clear I’m not saying the 25 are not worthy of being there I’m just saying there are a few in both the top 25 & 2023 lists that are glaringly obvious to have been missed by shifter.

 

[PMBangers]

Anyone in Kevin Sheehans top 25 that is a surprise?

TO be honest none of them are really out of place, I still maintain that after the top 15 (for me at least) it's fairly even for the next 15 with no one really standing up and forcing themselves above the pack at the champs yet

 

[briztoon]

Shifter was commentating the under 18’s on Saturday on Foxtel

Where is the list for 2023?

 

[pushintheback]

Where is the list for 2023?

Herald Sun

 

[briztoon]

Herald Sun

Sorry, I meant has the list been copied to BigFooty somewhere?

 

[Giant Strides]

Sorry, I meant has the list been copied to BigFooty somewhere?

Couch Coach posted it in the 2022 Draft Discussion thread.

Preview - 2022 AFL Draft General Discussion

Family connections in the 2022 crop here: https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/2022-afl-draft-general-discussion.1219047/#post-66340974

www.bigfooty.com

 

[briztoon]

Couch Coach posted it in the 2022 Draft Discussion thread.

Preview - 2022 AFL Draft General Discussion

Family connections in the 2022 crop here: https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/2022-afl-draft-general-discussion.1219047/#post-66340974

www.bigfooty.com

That’s the 2022 list. I thought pushintheback mentioned there was a 2023 list as well.

 

[Giant Strides]

That’s the 2022 list. I thought pushintheback mentioned there was a 2023 list as well.

Ah, sorry, didn't read the question properly.

 

[blueiris]

This is from Tuesday paper hopefully PM Banners doesn’t mind me posting this here

 

[pushintheback]

View attachment 1440817This is from Tuesday paper hopefully PM Banners doesn’t mind me posting this hereView attachment 1440818

Everyone of the 25 are good prospects but I question shifters knowledge when there are 2023 prospects that are playing in the carnival but haven’t actually made shifters list and vice versa there are kids on the list that aren’t playing in the carnival. It might be just me but I reckon if you’re a 2023 and in the VM squad and are playing you’re probably in the top 25. Some names that are clearly missing.
Mahmoud Taha - in VM squad
Logan Morris - in VM squad and played game 1 v The Allies
Nathan Philactides - in VM squad and played game 2 v WA and was arguably the best 2023 on the ground
Oliver Badr - Oakleigh chargers. Regularly selected in the 22. Not in the VM squad but worthy of a mention and would have had to have been close to making the squad.

Davo-27, PMBangers, Cal Twomey and The Rookie Me Central team are the ones that generally have accurate lists.

 

[weltschmerz]

View attachment 1440817This is from Tuesday paper hopefully PM Banners doesn’t mind me posting this hereView attachment 1440818

Dogs need Ryley Sanders. Between our AFLM and AFLW lists we already have a Riley, a Rhylee, and a Rylie.

 

[RedmanWasHere]

Dogs need Ryley Sanders. Between our AFLM and AFLW lists we already have a Riley, a Rhylee, and a Rylie.

Need to find a Baylee somewhere.

 

[PMBangers]

@Davo-27, @PMBangers, Cal Twomey and The Rookie Me Central team are the ones that generally have accurate lists.

PH no, not at all.

ModernArtillery is the guy you should all listen to tbh

 

[pushintheback]

PH no, not at all.

ModernArtillery is the guy you should all listen to tbh

ooops good call PMBangers
ModernArtillery considering you’re the conversation here, u wanna give us your 25 for 2023?

 

[Davo-27]

ooops good call PMBangers
ModernArtillery considering you’re the conversation here, u wanna give us your 25 for 2023?

i believe PMBangers and ModernArtillery are on the rookie me central team.

 

[briztoon]

i believe PMBangers and ModernArtillery are on the rookie me central team.

They certainly have different opinions on players, rankings, depth of the draft, etc.

 

[RedmanWasHere]

ooops good call PMBangers
ModernArtillery considering you’re the conversation here, u wanna give us your 25 for 2023?

Be better to put these lists in the 2023 thread.

 

[EagleMan87]

I suppose my reasoning here is that I think North have potentially created a log-jam of midfield talent that they've got to work through currently- admittedly I'm relying on Busslinger having a banger of a championships, but I can see that happening.
With WCE going after Hewett I'm also assuming that he'll have some really solid games to come- WCE haven't taken a top 10 pick since 2010 and I get the feeling there's going to be a lot of internal pressure to nail it, especially with some of the supposed issues they're experiencing internally atm (WCE fans I apologise if this is faulty info). Taking the best local talent can be a massive boon in terms of marketing after a rough year, too.

This is one of the first drafts I haven't been all in on a single athlete or two by this point in the year and I'm not sure if that's a good thing or not haha.

Our last top 5 pick was the Vic boy Gaff, and before that was Vic boy Judd: can't see us overlooking Wardlaw if he comes back from injury ok and no-one overtakes him.

 

[Eastcoasteagle]

Our last top 5 pick was the Vic boy Gaff, and before that was Vic boy Judd: can't see us overlooking Wardlaw if he comes back from injury ok and no-one overtakes him.

Also think we're a club not too worried about the marketing side, they'll go for best available.

 

[Eastcoasteagle]

Will Verrall is the forgotten man, late start to the season with groin issues and has missed a few during the season. Athletic and plays like a 4th mid once the ball hits the deck. Raw but later on in the draft or rookie is great value IMO.

Big game on the weekend so could even be in contention for SA's next game. Shows enough to suggest KPF wouldn't be totally out of the question.

After first two champs games, I think he's top 25. He's been a standout player.

 

[Davo-27]

After first two champs games, I think he's top 25. He's been a standout player.

Will Verrell has not played for SA yet, i think you are thinking of Callum Verrell of Vic Metro who has been great so far.