Opinion Recruiting and List Management Team: Hamish Ogilvie, Justin Reid & Co

Should Hamish Ogilvie and Justin Reid be sacked?

  • Both should be sacked

  • Only Hamish Ogilvie should be sacked

  • Only Justin Reid should be sacked

  • Neither should be sacked


Results are only viewable after voting.

Remove this Banner Ad

RETIRE, TRADE or DELIST
Elliot Himmelberg
Hugh Bond
Lachlan Gollant
Lachlan Scholl
Rory Sloane
Patrick Parnell - R
James Borlase - R
Will Hamill - R

DELIST AND ROOKIE
Chris Burgess

ONE YEAR DEAL
Ned McHenry
Taylor Walker
Brodie Smith

TWO YEAR DEAL
Brayden Cook
Sam Berry

That's six main list spots, plus two MSD picks that stay as rookies.

I'm sure we could cut either of Smith and McHenry as well - I'm just not sure we do.
 
2 months ago Nicks is negotiating his contract and telling the board we are on an upward trend and finals bound.
5 weeks into the season and he blames the club for a s**t squad and we need to trade players in because our recruiting has been terrible

North - maybe win.
Port - lose.
Collingwood - lose.
Brisbane - lose.

I expect one of those losses will be a ten goal belting; even without it, if we're 2-8, he's gone by mid year.

If we lose this weekend, untenable.
 
North - maybe win.
Port - lose.
Collingwood - lose.
Brisbane - lose.

I expect one of those losses will be a ten goal belting; even without it, if we're 2-8, he's gone by mid year.

If we lose this weekend, untenable.

More importantly this thread is about getting rid of the guy that has stuffed up for the past 12 years. Don’t let him screw another one up and start a decent list


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
 

Log in to remove this ad.

More importantly this thread is about getting rid of the guy that has stuffed up for the past 12 years. Don’t let him screw another one up and start a decent list


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
Which begs the question, who is the best talent identifier?

Rekon Melbournes recruiter has done well recently.
 
So we need to trade him to the team that picks before us.
It would be worth keeping Ogilvie on staff so that we know who not to pick in the first round
 
RETIRE, TRADE or DELIST
Elliot Himmelberg
Hugh Bond
Lachlan Gollant
Lachlan Scholl
Rory Sloane
Patrick Parnell - R
James Borlase - R
Will Hamill - R

DELIST AND ROOKIE
Chris Burgess

ONE YEAR DEAL
Ned McHenry
Taylor Walker
Brodie Smith

TWO YEAR DEAL
Brayden Cook
Sam Berry

That's six main list spots, plus two MSD picks that stay as rookies.

I'm sure we could cut either of Smith and McHenry as well - I'm just not sure we do.

Tex needs to go if we get a new coach. Time for a new leadership and culture. Smith as well.
 
10 spots at least
Which means we should make the most of taking 2 players in the mid season draft.

Also, should be aiming for 1-2 free agents & trades.

It's hard to turnover 10 players in a season, so we are going to need to keep a few.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Let’s hear it
I can tell your an educated soul so I won't cheapen it with a lazy response, I am in the middle of moving house so I will break it down properly at a later date. Suffice to say though that any keyboard commentary using the words" you ain't man enough " is posturing as an alpha male but to the wise it's really just a toxic male defence mechanism. Things I'm sure would be very different in the real world 😊
 
GWS have had a great five years...which is a worry as they passed over Curtin
Maybe maybe not. I would also look at who they preferred instead of saying they passed over XXX

Sometimes it comes down to list structure and need
 
Which means we should make the most of taking 2 players in the mid season draft.

Also, should be aiming for 1-2 free agents & trades.

It's hard to turnover 10 players in a season, so we are going to need to keep a few.
Yes it’s a really bad position to be in. Mediocrity will continue to be rewarded.
 
RETIRE, TRADE or DELIST
Elliot Himmelberg
Hugh Bond
Lachlan Gollant
Lachlan Scholl
Rory Sloane
Patrick Parnell - R
James Borlase - R
Will Hamill - R

DELIST AND ROOKIE
Chris Burgess

ONE YEAR DEAL
Ned McHenry
Taylor Walker
Brodie Smith

TWO YEAR DEAL
Brayden Cook
Sam Berry

That's six main list spots, plus two MSD picks that stay as rookies.

I'm sure we could cut either of Smith and McHenry as well - I'm just not sure we do.
What the fxxk?

I’d hold onto bond and borlase before givin Ned mcgarbage and smith another year..

Have you not been watching our fxxkn AFL games?

Borlase is decent depth… and Bond has actually been playing good footy for us in the SANFL..

Anyone who thinks we should keep Ned McShit should have their opinions instantly questioned.
 
RETIRE, TRADE or DELIST
Elliot Himmelberg
Hugh Bond
Lachlan Gollant
Lachlan Scholl
Rory Sloane
Patrick Parnell - R
James Borlase - R
Will Hamill - R

DELIST AND ROOKIE
Chris Burgess

ONE YEAR DEAL
Ned McHenry
Taylor Walker
Brodie Smith

TWO YEAR DEAL
Brayden Cook
Sam Berry

That's six main list spots, plus two MSD picks that stay as rookies.

I'm sure we could cut either of Smith and McHenry as well - I'm just not sure we do.
I'd rather keep Bond than McHenry or Smith.
 
Yeah, I think that's a reasonably widespread opinion.

I'd be fine with that, but I was trying to be realistic.
Realistic to how our management thinks isn't going to cheer up anyone at the moment though
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion Recruiting and List Management Team: Hamish Ogilvie, Justin Reid & Co

Back
Top