List Mgmt. Rioli to Port Discussion

[HoneyBadger35]

Forgive the intrusion everyone, I come in peace.

 

[TerryFilk]

He was on the verge of being delisted according to the Port board prior to us being interested.

Now they want a straight swap.

He is the steak knives.

I think Port are desperate and think they can contend, Gray retired - they DESPERATELY need Rioli hence them being crazy enough to offer him 4 years.

27 and their future 2nd for Rioli and our future 3rd is what I’d be pushing for personally

 

[CountryLad]

If Graham decides to go to the power can see a three way trade possibly

Eagles give pick 2 ,38 & Rioli
Get pick 8,12 and 19

Port Give pick 8 and 27
Get. Rioli,Graham, pick 31

Tigers. Give pick 12,19 & 31 and Graham
Get. Pick 2 & 27

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Eagles being campaigners

Good

Very unlike us.

Feels like we’ve bent over backwards to get deals done recently. The last time I can recall us playing hardball was when Mitch Brown asked to go to St Kilda.

 

[FKASC]

Very unlike us.

Feels like we’ve bent over backwards to get deals done recently. The last time I can recall us playing hardball was when Mitch Brown asked to go to St Kilda.

Seems like we are more likely to get bent over when we are trying to acquire a player, not so much when someone wants one of ours.

 

[Goldfish]

27 would be fair though, so why?

That's the same pick as we got from Port for dropping from pick 12 to pick 14 last year... I think Rioli is worth a bit more than a 2 spot downgrade (and I assume that's how Port would look at it to given it was them we traded with in-draft last year).

 

[Obeanie1]

If Graham decides to go to the power can see a three way trade possibly

Eagles give pick 2 ,38 & Rioli
Get pick 8,12 and 19

Port Give pick 8 and 27
Get. Rioli,Graham, pick 31

Tigers. Give pick 12,19 & 31 and Graham
Get. Pick 2 & 27

Port get shafted there.

Rioli and Graham arent worth pick 8.

 

[the harry]

Very unlike us.

Feels like we’ve bent over backwards to get deals done recently. The last time I can recall us playing hardball was when Mitch Brown asked to go to St Kilda.

St Kilda owe us for saving them from getting Brown

 

[Altum Volantes]

Very unlike us.

Feels like we’ve bent over backwards to get deals done recently. The last time I can recall us playing hardball was when Mitch Brown asked to go to St Kilda.

Without us forcing Mitch Brown to stay, we’d have never known how useful a forward pocket/backup ruckman he was.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Let’s be realistic here, he’s barely done anything of note for 3 odd seasons (for obvious reasons), has question marks over his character and fitness, and is out of contract.

Refusing 27 if they offer it would be a weird hill to die on.

Reckon Rhino’s had a mare here.

 

[Monocle]

Let’s be realistic here, he’s barely done anything of note for 3 odd seasons (for obvious reasons), has question marks over his character and fitness, and is out of contract.

Refusing 27 if they offer it would be a weird hill to die on.

Reckon Rhino’s had a mare here.

CC rule number 1 of negotiating:

Never accept the first offer.

It's early days in the trade period so no hurry to rap things up on day one.

 

[Biggie]

Let’s be realistic here, he’s barely done anything of note for 3 odd seasons (for obvious reasons), has question marks over his character and fitness, and is out of contract.

Refusing 27 if they offer it would be a weird hill to die on.

Reckon Rhino’s had a mare here.

 

[WCEswift]

Port get shafted there.

Rioli and Graham arent worth pick 8.

They are in win now mode though, could be sniffed at

 

[Keys]

I think Port are desperate and think they can contend, Gray retired - they DESPERATELY need Rioli hence them being crazy enough to offer him 4 years.

27 and their future 2nd for Rioli and our future 3rd is what I’d be pushing for personally

I like this

If Port are backing themselves to make finals like they seem to be and we finish bottom 4 that swap of future 2nd/3rd is a downgrade from 30 to 40 for Port

We go into next draft period with 2xR2 picks and get to deathride Port for another season

 

[Lynch takes a mark]

Geez, 27 is more than fair.

 

[TerryFilk]

I like this

If Port are backing themselves to make finals like they seem to be and we finish bottom 4 that swap of future 2nd/3rd is a downgrade from 30 to 40 for Port

We go into next draft period with 2xR2 picks and get to deathride Port for another season

Yep I think they’d cave if we asked for that

Netting extra picks for next year is a smart investment too considering how good that draft cohort looks

 

[KERRPOW]

We should ask for next years first for rioli.

Port would think thats a late teens pick.

Id say top 10

 

[MrWoollie]

27 seems fair to me.
It's about where I had it when putting age, injury and history on the negative side of the equation against talent, length of contract and reported value of contract on the upside.

If we can somehow persuade a future 2nd in for a future 3rd out swap as well I'd be stoked.

 

[HoneyBadger35]

27 is a bit unders to me, but 27 and a future second is big time overs.

Get after them West Coast, make it happen.

 

[FKASC]

Yep I think they’d cave if we asked for that

Netting extra picks for next year is a smart investment too considering how good that draft cohort looks

If they cave for that, I’ll delete my account be very happy indeed.

 

[JDWCE]

Must say I’m surprised by the eagles. I respect this stance too. Unlike them and I rate it. **** off Port

 

[Carbine Chaos]

27 is a bit unders to me, but 27 and a future second is big time overs.

Get after them West Coast, make it happen.

Is it though? Out of contract, poor fitness record, poor discipline record, lack of exposed form, small forward position not worth as much as others.

I'd snap their hands off for 27.

But hey, if we somehow manage to wrangle more, I'll be impressed.

 

[woosha24]

Nah f*ck Port. Screw em to the wall. 27 and next year's first if they value Rioli's worth at 4 years with minimal clauses.

If they reckon they're in a window now then they can pay for their crack at the cup.

 

[CountryLad]

Big Trev “it’s pick 8 and your future first or get out “

 

[WCErevival]

Nisbett wants some feathers. Cant have Bell getting them all.

 

[MIKE85]

27 and Lycett. Make it happen Nessy