Round 1 discussion

[DERIBERATE]

202 from Gibbs/Kerridge and Menadue's 80 is on my mids pine. Not quite a big enough score from Menadue to rejig my mids and get his 80, unlike the Mcintosh bonanza last year.

 

[big_bazza]

1850 or something.

Pretty irrelevant though when it has Kerridge as 26, for example.

Yeah my 3 players (weits,menadue,kerridge) were projected to get 92 between them and they scored 253

 

[superfraser]

Rance, Menadue, Wietering and Kerrige, for 354.

 

[toxic]

Need to play 1;

BenKen, Milera or McCarthy

thoughts?

BurnKen

 

[gutsroy]

354/4.

Can't watch the replay till later in the week but happy as Larry with Menadue, Weitering, Kerridge and Richmond's greatest ever Jehova's Witness*

Put my degree in Amateur Psychology to use & left out Dusty, impossible to say after one game if it'll pay off (but clearly it will, absolute masterstroke)

Pored over whether to go with Cripps and Doch but went with others in the end, can see Cripps in particularly making those of us that left him out regret it.

Good scores from Murphy, Gibbs, and Kayne La-a-a-mbert, the Sheepish Lion for the Tiges. Big effort from Edwards just to get up for Rd 1, OK score to boot

* No idea how many there have been other than Rance, but reckon he'll be through to the semis without dropping a set, just quietly.

 

[SC fish]

Need to play 1;

BenKen, Milera or McCarthy

thoughts?

BenKen. I am going BenKen over McCarthy and Papley.

 

[felsty]

Are people seriously not happy with Menadues score on the bench? Or are they just not seeing it as worth a floating donut to be called in? The guy scored great.. so happy he is on my field!

 

[Me Myself and I]

Need to play 1;
BenKen, Milera or McCarthy
thoughts?

I reckon McCarthy best for the long term. Because playing Hawks this week his scoring could be reduced, so Kennedy.
But it's certainly a good choice you have to make each round.

 

[Pedro]

5/440 solid start to SC16.

FOOTYS BACK MOFOS!!!

Same for me. Pretty happy with no sub 80 scores from 3 rookies.

 

[Deliverance]

Are people seriously not happy with Menadues score on the bench? Or are they just not seeing it as worth a floating donut to be called in? The guy scored great.. so happy he is on my field!

Not worth a FD with such poor prospects for cash creation this year. Cash is king!

 

[Krujan]

Are people seriously not happy with Menadues score on the bench? Or are they just not seeing it as worth a floating donut to be called in? The guy scored great.. so happy he is on my field!

Passed on Dusty and have Menedue's 80 on my forward bench. I still have 500k in the bank and could easily turn BenKen or McCarthy into Monty for the fwd loophole this week. However my forward line is quite strong already and the left over cash could be better used to bolster my moneyball defence and just start one of BenKen/McCarthy or Papley on field. Hmm decisions...SC is srs bzns

 

[DuckYeah]

lol at the Weitering baggers /tossers.

Where are you now?? Silence i tells ya......



******* tossers jumping the gun after 1Qtr as usual!

JW - 84 and Dustbin Martin 85, yet 400k nearly $$ difference!

Look at the carry on, its round one haha

 

[DuckYeah]

2/166 from rookies isnt bad!

I dont have weitering, but put that 100 grand into another player that should punch out 100's.. Im not considering it a wasted pick just yet

 

[DuckYeah]

Passed on Dusty and have Menedue's 80 on my forward bench. I still have 500k in the bank and could easily turn BenKen or McCarthy into Monty for the fwd loophole this week. However my forward line is quite strong already and the left over cash could be better used to bolster my moneyball defence and just start one of BenKen/McCarthy or Papley on field. Hmm decisions...SC is srs bzns

Burning trades early?

 

[Krujan]

Burning trades early?

What?

 

[Deliverance]

lol at the Weitering baggers /tossers.

Where are you now?? Silence i tells ya......



******* tossers jumping the gun after 1Qtr as usual!

JW - 84 and Dustbin Martin 85, yet 400k nearly $$ difference!

We're all waiting until round 3 before jumping in.

No Dusty either here.

 

[Deliverance]

2/166 from rookies isnt bad!

I dont have weitering, but put that 100 grand into another player that should punch out 100's.. Im not considering it a wasted pick just yet

Let me guess, you have Kerridge and Menadue. Snap!

 

[Wild Bill]

Where do I find the scores from last night?

 

[Deliverance]

Where do I find the scores from last night?

Fanfooty

 

[gutsroy]

Where do I find the scores from last night?

If you go to 'player stats' under the game day section on the SuperCoach site, it should show all scores. Or fanfooty.com.au and click on the game.

 

[Double the Fist]

I was a bit worried when he was 18 at QT and 23 DT. Missed the first half so must've had a couple of clangers. Fixed it up with some beautiful kicks in the last though.

I really didn't like many of the other defensive options, and I figured Doch should at least reach 92 with natural improvement. But he did score 145 last year round one, so we'll see. I'll take it though.

I ummed and ahhhed about doch, had some leg problems last year IIRC. Decided to go with Simpson and roll the dice with Kade Kolo (GCS) Both he and Doch should have good years with natural progression.

 

[KenTucker]

Weitering
Kerridge
Menadue E (can loop with Petracca)

 

[Deliverance]

Menadue E (can loop with Petracca)

Not worth it.

 

[Jiska]

Where do I find the scores from last night?

Scroll back a few pages

 

[Da Breust]

We're all waiting until round 3 before jumping in.

No Dusty either here.

Dunno why your satisfied with not having Dusty. Bloke scored 50 in round 1 last year and how did his year turn out..