Round 1 discussion

[Deliverance]

Dunno why your satisfied with not having Dusty. Bloke scored 50 in round 1 last year and how did his year turn out..

He won't better his average this year and is thus not going to be value or make or break your team.

 

[Da Breust]

Not worth a FD with such poor prospects for cash creation this year. Cash is king!

At least you know he'll play regularly when given the chance unlike Papley McGovern etc. You'll more than likely be wasting trades on blokes like them.

 

[Deliverance]

At least you know he'll play regularly when given the chance unlike Papley McGovern etc. You'll more than likely be wasting trades on blokes like them.

When, being the operative word. Cash cows are scarce this year. Adding extra FDs is folly.

 

[Da Breust]

When, being the operative word. Cash cows are scarce this year. Adding extra FDs is folly.

I'd saying adding blokes who are absolute fringe players is folly because they will inevitable be traded out making sweet fa cash.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Dunno why your satisfied with not having Dusty. Bloke scored 50 in round 1 last year and how did his year turn out..

loose value - will pick him up for 480k at about round 9

 

[KenTucker]

Need to play 1;

BenKen, Milera or McCarthy

thoughts?

Milera

2 of these to start on field in defence.
Dea
Tippa
Brown
Adams

Can't loop, already looping Weitering with Uber.

 

[Da Breust]

loose value - will pick him up for 480k at about round 9

Oh really, can you see what he scores for the next 8 rounds?

 

[joop]

Not worth it.

I'd be taking his 80 for sure.

 

[stevebbb]

Milera

2 of these to start on field in defence.
Dea
Tippa
Brown
Adams

Can't loop, already looping Weitering with Uber.

Lock Dea in
The other spot is difficult... Thinking Adams, reckon he'll take a few intercept marks

 

[Deliverance]

I'd saying adding blokes who are absolute fringe players is folly because they will inevitable be traded out making sweet fa cash.

Hey, if you want to bring in a guy who's played 0 AFL senior games, missed most of the preseason and may play round 5 at the earliest, just to get 80 points on the field, be my guest.

 

[Deliverance]

I'd be taking his 80 for sure.

But adding an FD to do it?

 

[Krujan]

But adding an FD to do it?

FD?

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

I'm adding Jack. Think he will be a good captain option for finals. Just waiting for his price to drop.

 

[Deliverance]

FD?

Floating doughnut.

 

[Souup]

Can not seriously believe we have people suggesting bringing in a floating donut for 80 friggen points. 80 POINTS.

If you start bloody Davis, Hewett or Gresham you can surely assume they'll score atleast 50. Which means you're only losing out on 30 points at worst in my estimation.

People have lost their minds after 1 game. But this happens every year so I'm not sure why I'm so surprised

 

[HawkAussie]

At the moment I am on 173 with two of my Carlton players.

 

[Da Breust]

Hey, if you want to bring in a guy who's played 0 AFL senior games, missed most of the preseason and may play round 5 at the earliest, just to get 80 points on the field, be my guest.

It's not to get 80 points. It's because I'd have more faith in him getting regular games when he's given the chance, which will be before you'd expect, then risk trades on rookies like Papley McGovern who are just filling holes atm.

 

[Da Breust]

Can not seriously believe we have people suggesting bringing in a floating donut for 80 friggen points. 80 POINTS.

If you start bloody Davis, Hewett or Gresham you can surely assume they'll score atleast 50. Which means you're only losing out on 30 points at worst in my estimation.

People have lost their minds after 1 game. But this happens every year so I'm not sure why I'm so surprised

Says the bloke who brings in Goetz so he can loophole round 1..

 

[joop]

But adding an FD to do it?

I've already got Petracca. He'll play soon. It's not vital to have all your players playing round 1.

 

[Deliverance]

It's not to get 80 points. It's because I'd have more faith in him getting regular games when he's given the chance, which will be before you'd expect, then risk trades on rookies like Papley McGovern who are just filling holes atm.

The original post was about bringing him in for the points. But as an aside can you guarantee Petracca any more than Papely?

 

[King Bont]

Pretty happy with this result last night. Wish dusty would have scored a bit more

 

[Da Breust]

The original post was about bringing him in for the points. But as an aside can you guarantee Petracca any more than Papely?

Can't guarantee it but am damn well more than confident. Risk we take I guess, good luck to you.

 

[Jiska]

The original post was about bringing him in for the points. But as an aside can you guarantee Petracca any more than Papely?

I can absolutely guarantee you'll make more cash out of Petracca, he'll score more, and play more games.

 

[Deliverance]

Can't guarantee it but am damn well more than confident. Risk we take I guess, good luck to you.

Just saying I'm not gonna change my structure to get Petracca in.

 

[Jiska]

Just saying I'm not gonna change my structure to get Petracca in.

Yes you are. It's just a question of when.