MVP Round 11 Votes vs St Kilda

[EaglesVille]

6.Bradbury
5.Mackenzie
4.Hurn
3.Scooter
2.Shuey
1.Wilson

 

[illwizard]

5- EMac
4- Shuey
3- Brown
2- Scooter
1- Naitanui

 

[Dark Sharks]

5. Mackenzie
4. Scooter
3. Naitanui
2. Darling
1. Wilson

Priddis last quarter doesn't make up for the previous 3.

 

[Shupe]

FiveStrings - Has there ever been a time a player has got 5 votes from every single poster, thus the average you give them in the POTY a 5?

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

FiveStrings - Has there ever been a time a player has got 5 votes from every single poster, thus the average you give them in the POTY a 5?

Gaff in Round 17 last year - think that might have been the derby?

Ochre would be the person to ask about previous years.

 

[The Falcon Strike]

I was umming and ahhhing over our BOG, opened the votes and felt I'd be carded if I went the other way

So.....

5. Emac
4. Hurn - devastating with ball in hand, turned the tide early
3. Cox - quality rucking and some important grabs
2. Shuey - first time I've seen work through a hard tag and perform well
1. Darling - thought he competed tirelessly all day and was rewarded with three goals.

Liked shepp and Wilson as well. Would really like to see shepp put some bulk on and try out in the midfield


Ummmm - we have resorted to Adam Selwood in the forward line.... For the love of god why?

He is a tagged or small defender and at the moment a very ordinary one. Should be a depth player at best

 

[Evelyn208]

5. Mackenzie

Did anyone else play?

4. Priddis
3. Shuey
2. Wilson
1. Hurn

 

[WCEbrody]

5.Mackenzie
4.Shuey
3.Naitanui
2.Hurn
1.Darling

 

[nefarious]

5. Mackenzie
4. Scooter
3. Hurn
2. Wilson (he's gonna be good)
1. Shuey

Cox, Kerr and Priddis weren't too far behind - as usual. Masten was painfully quiet at the times we needed him most.

 

[fidstar]

5 - MacKenzie
4 - Hurn
3 - Kerr
2 - Priddis
1 - Wilson

 

[larrikin]

I dare someone to not give Mackenzie 5 votes...

He wasn't even listed in the best players on the afl site match summary....

5. Emac
4. Hurn
3. Shuey
2. Wilson
1. Cox

Keep in mind I did watch this game with about 1000 Bintangs on board.....

 

[TassieEagle]

5. Emac - not even close, gave Crywoldt a bath and kicked a couple of pretty handy goals
4. Wilson - muy bueno debut
3. Hurn - Dat disposal!
2. NicNat - Seemed to lift us at pivotal points as only he can do
1. Darling - Loved his work with JK

HM - Priddis, Shuey, Kerr

 

[bodazoka]

5. McKenzie
4. Hurn
3. Priddis
2. Wilson
1. Darling

 

[The Passenger]

He wasn't even listed in the best players on the afl site match summary....

sums them up really. and named riewoldt as saints best on ground for his inspirational 1 goal. did take 9 marks but anyone watching that game knows that his influence was largely quelled.

 

[Big Tones]

5 Emac
4 Shuey
3 Priddis
2 Cox
1 Wilson

-1 Asel, Hams

 

[Shupe]

5 - Big Easy - EMACCCCC
4 - Little Shoe - Shuey
3 - Tree trunks - Hurn
2 - Train - Blayne
1 - Clutch - Priddis

 

[larrikin]

sums them up really. and named riewoldt as saints best on ground for his inspirational 1 goal. did take 9 marks but anyone watching that game knows that his influence was largely quelled.

Will be interesting to see the coaches' votes.

 

[QS]

Sorry Emac, but I thought Hurn was better overall.

5. Hurn
4. McKenzie
3. Shuey
2. Wilson
1. Cox

HM: Darling (was unlucky on a number of occasions and used his body well), NN sublime taps, Shep (if only for that contest).

 

[eaglespremiers]

Sorry Emac, but I thought Hurn was better overall.

Oh, this guy.

 

[BradWCE]

5. Mackenzie
4. Hurn
3. Shuey
2. Naitanui
1. Wilson

 

[The Falcon Strike]

Sorry Emac, but I thought Hurn was better overall.

5. Hurn
4. McKenzie

I was tossing up between the same two

 

[eaglespremiers]

I was tossing up between the same two

Speaks well of Hurn's disposal as he only had it 14 times.

 

[QS]

Speaks well of Hurn's disposal as he only had it 14 times.

Disposal doesn't mean everything, especially as a defender.

Interesting on the couch they singled out Priddis as dragging us over the line

 

[Dark Sharks]

Sorry Emac, but I thought Hurn was better overall.

5. Hurn
4. McKenzie
3. Shuey
2. Wilson
1. Cox

HM: Darling (was unlucky on a number of occasions and used his body well), NN sublime taps, Shep (if only for that contest).

You can't be serious - Said John Mcenroe

 

[QS]

You can't be serious - Said John Mcenroe

We all see things differently! Anyway, no need to defend my awesome votes