Round 13 trades

[THECHIEFTON]

Thanks for your reply!

In another thread someone said Birchall was carrying some sort of back injury.

Never been a big fan of either player but Duffield seems more inconsistent.

Just needed someone to reassure me Birchall is a good pick... I can find a unique choice elsewhere.

Houli, Ellis or Malceski.

 

[Lotch]

Houli, Ellis or Malceski.

Don't want to have too many players from the same team this year (even though byes have passed).

But do you think Malceski will be higher than Birchall at the end of the year?

I could also bring in Shaw next week and instead trade Laird to a forward and shift Staker back.

Still stuck between Birchall, Malceski or even Hartlett.

Thoughts?

 

[toxic]

I suppose it was a bit silly by me not to include the players I already have but see the bolded.

Would you pull the trigger this week and get either Jack, Selwood or Mitchell, or would you wait one week and get Swan/Watson, remembering that the league win is a priority.

get jelwood

 

[Donakebab]

So Docherty has been named. Keep him in the side and hope he avoids the vest or drop him, move Vlastuin back and trade in Hrovat?

Pulled the trigger, couldn't stand the thought of Docherty getting the vest and dropping. Voss, you're a real campaigner.

 

[THECHIEFTON]

Don't want to have too many players from the same team this year (even though byes have passed).

But do you think Malceski will be higher than Birchall at the end of the year?

I could also bring in Shaw next week and instead trade Laird to a forward and shift Staker back.

Still stuck between Birchall, Malceski or even Hartlett.

Thoughts?

Not really sure but Malceski can rack them up. Doesn't usually get the attention like Birchall can get. Shaw and Birchall are the safe options.

Hibberd or Heppell are options to.

 

[raymagoo]

Pulled the trigger, couldn't stand the thought of Docherty getting the vest and dropping. Voss, you're a real silly.

No thought of doing it to within an hour of the first game to see who sub was?

 

[Donakebab]

No thought of doing it to within an hour of the first game to see who sub was?

Playing the Sunday game, I'd already done Murhpy > Jack and Gray > D.Martin.

Plus TBH, Docherty is destined to lose money and make me rage.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Yeah agree with that but just not sure who to bring in. Money isn't a massive issue (can afford up to about $600,000).

Swan, Watson and Dangerfield would be great but have the bye this week so I'll still have to cop a zero for this week.

Not sure about Cornes and Barlow.

Playing for a league win though so could just go with one of the latter three anyway, just not sure if it is worth doing it this week or next week.

Pretty sure you can choose from: Lids/Cotchin/Barlow/Jelwood/Jack/JPK/Fyfe
So many choices there mate!

 

[Judd_Magic]

Kadog
Love SC so all good!

In terms of your next trades and bench cover you need cash, it might be Docherty or Staker or Nicholls out as a cash grab - probably Nicholls in 2 weeks at 340K ish for Mcbean, you can then turn Docherty into Beau Waters or a defender around the 440K mark, hopefully moving Goodes to D7
After that It'll be waiitng for Mitchell to cash up rapidly then ditch him for Nic Graham or another rookie and upgrade Hrovat ot Kmart

Have to backup what Kadog said Toxic.

You have a great supercoach brain and I enjoy reading your replies in here to people and your trade ideas.

I need to get Stevie J in the next couple of weeks to finish my forward line (Staker 6th forward ) and didn't have any idea how to get the cash in to get Stevie J till I read what you said about downgrading Nicholls in a couple of weeks time for cash.

That's a great idea as I have McBean as my R4 anyways and Cox in the forward line so I can downgrade Nicholls for the cheapest ruck spud around and use the cash to upgrade Staker or B.Kennedy to Stevie J.

Cheers mate and keep up the good work while making those puppies look great!

 

[Jiska]

Who is the best premium defender to get?

Already have Gibbs, Goddard and Birchall.

Heppell is pretty consistent and has DPP, Shaw s the one you want tho.

 

[Conca Truck]

I've had another idea. What about Maric?
So need to pick one out of Maric, Goldy and Wilbur

 

[toxic]

I've had another idea. What about Maric?
So need to pick one out of Maric, Goldy and Wilbur

pick who you think has the best finals run - most importantly there team will be trying come late August / September. Don't want that early surgery player

 

[Conca Truck]

pick who you think has the best finals run - most importantly there team will be trying come late August / September. Don't want that early surgery player

It's tough. I see Maric as a bit of a risky choice and I hv some spare cash so may go with two of the true premiums. Both have a similar run home, thanks for your help though toxic!

 

[Embleberry]

Jelwood or Cotchin to finish off midfield with intention of upgrading Priddis before/during finals (GAJ, Pendles, Watson, JPK, Barlow, Dangerfield, Priddis, TMitchell, Viney)

NRoo or DMartin to complete forward line (Nic Nat, Walker, Rockliff, Buddy, JJK, Staker, Neade) I want to bring in SJ in the coming weeks as well for Staker/Neade if cash permits otherwise I think Buddy will have to go :S

 

[NUFC Tiger]

If they don't play, they won't rise/fall in price

Thanks mate!

 

[NSWCROW]

This post is proudly brought to you by Shannon Hurn's PISSWEAK flipping ankle -

Probably Kommer > Hrovat or Hunter
Only other option is Tabberner

 

[larson]

Is it stupid to now buy Ellis? He looks to legitimately be one of the best defenders

 

[toxic]

Is it stupid to now buy Ellis? He looks to legitimately be one of the best defenders

if you think he'll be top 6 defenders, then doesn't matter what price he is - if you consider him a keeper then just get him. its that time of year when just make the hard calls and live with them

 

[big bootaaaaah]

if you think he'll be top 6 defenders, then doesn't matter what price he is - if you consider him a keeper then just get him. its that time of year when just make the hard calls and live with them

in other words yes stoopid get ibbo at least he's in a defensive team