Autopsy Round 16, 2021: Collingwood v St.Kilda

[SaintersUnite]

Feel bad for Ross, a BnF winner and has been serviceable this year yet people still talk about letting him go after wins.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[#gosaintas]

Let’s get this out there ….sick of people saying he’s not being offered big dollars .he is.
Connors ( Billings Mgr ) has met with StKilda ..2 clubs have offered over $200 thousand
what StKilda have offered……restricted free agent .he why he hasn’t signed fielding offers.
Little doubt Billings has played injured , majority of the year .
Hardly trains, most of the sessions only very very light , little or no participation in match simulation.

So rest him to get better

 

[Noidenous]

Ross, a BnF winner

X2

 

[Stewart66]

So rest him to get better

Thought just said it …..he needs an operation .

Resting it useless .

 

[snails13]

The Dunstan's, Long's and McKenzie's are relics of a bygone era of tryers. We have enough tryers who can also kick the ball without them and they're all only playing because of our outs. Who of them stays in when any 3 of Paton, Gresh, Jones, Clark, Hanners, Carlisle, Frawley, Coffield, Bytel et al. come back?
Answer? None.

Yet none of the latter players have never had 25 plus Disposals 5 games in a row,which Spook has.

 

[Crusty Undies]

Remove Hanners, Carlisle & Frawley from the equation. None are best 25 going forward. Paton & Clark come in for possibly Highmore & Connolly. Gresh & Jones for Billings & Ross when they are traded. Battle & Coffield battling it out for 1-2 positions. See how Wood continues to perform. On paper we have decent depth when we have minimal injuries.

Paton and Clark come in for Long and McKenzie without even the question of a second thought. Any 1 of Gresh, Jones, Bytel or Hanners let alone all shouls play ahead of Dunstan because they all bring stuff he doesn't that Crouch and Steele already bring. The last month we've plaued 4 frankly ordinary teams and Dunstan has looked good but I guarantee next week against Brisbane against another big mid group he'll get shown up.

 

[Crusty Undies]

Yet none of the latter players have never had 25 plus Disposals 5 games in a row,which Spook has.

Hanners certainly has and his 25 are double the quality of Dunny's. The rest aren't playing for touches bar Bytel who's in his 2nd year and who also has 18 great touches compared to 25 meh touches.

 

[Ephemeral Hope]

Poor old Harv's might be the first caretaker coach to get the arse.

We tried to save his reputation with those junk time goals

 

[Moquo]

Beat collingwood on their home ground in crap weather to keep our finals chance alive. Gutted.

 

[Ephemeral Hope]

Hanners certainly has and his 25 are double the quality of Dunny's. The rest aren't playing for touches bar Bytel who's in his 2nd year and who also has 18 great touches compared to 25 meh touches.

Hanners is an unfair comparison. The bloke is genuinely our most talented player uninjured. Three time All Australian and a player of the year once.

 

[snails13]

Hanners certainly has and his 25 are double the quality of Dunny's. The rest aren't playing for touches bar Bytel who's in his 2nd year and who also has 18 great touches compared to 25 meh touches.

Which 5 games in a row has Hanners got 25 plus in a Saints guernsey

 

[Saint12]

Thought just said it …..he needs an operation .

Resting it useless .

What's his injury

 

[Noidenous]

Which 5 games in a row has Hanners got 25 plus in a Saints guernsey

25+ SPF on the sidelines.

 

[AirWinmar]

Which 5 games in a row has Hanners got 25 plus in a Saints guernsey

I think we'd need to worry about the 5 games in a row before the possessions he gets. He has missed 5 games in a row though of you look at it that way

 

[saint66au]

A win is a win but we have to find a way to kick more than 8-10 goals a game. It wasnt Collingwoods sterling defence that stopped us kicking more goals, it was our own disorganisation and game plan that seemingly bans players leading straight out in front of the footy in the corridor. Our goals came from chaos balls, free kicks and a couple of contested marks. Look how often the Pies hit a bloke lace out in space inside 50 even when they were playing poorly. Luckily De Goey is a hack set shot.

If our attack was as organised as our defence, we'd have kicked 18 and been 70 points in front at 3/4 time

Not a new problem either

 

[SaintBilly]

Great win. Gutsy and hard fought. It was a very tough game. Yeah we gave away late goals but so many stood up. How great is it to see players like Dunstan and D-Mac standing up and earning their place in the team!! Terrific!

 

[Stewart66]

What's his injury

Plantar Fascitis

 

[Saint12]

Plantar Fascitis

Oh.... well atleast he is giving it a good rest

 

[Mat Mann]

Plantar Fascitis

and a knee issue

 

[bergholt]

Everyone on here and elsewhere is underplaying Jack Sinclair’s year. He reminds me of Corey Enright - never loses a contest, never misses a target or a tackle. He’ll be top few in the B&F and if he keeps going like this he’s good enough for AA.

 

[KingsRansom]

Everyone on here and elsewhere is underplaying Jack Sinclair’s year. He reminds me of Corey Enright - never loses a contest, never misses a target or a tackle. He’ll be top few in the B&F and if he keeps going like this he’s good enough for AA.

Agree, been in our best in most games I reckon

 

[SaintBilly]

Sinclair is second behind steele for bnf this year. Outstanding season which has all but reinvented his career.

 

[g_TRAIN]

Man does silly thing, man doesn't ackowledge silly thing, people go wtf!!?

Mason Wood with 22 possessions, I hope someone on sitting on the bench took notice.

Turning out to be a good pick-up.. Has looked good this year and suspect we give him another 1-year contract.

 

[pebblesofsand]

Sinclair is second behind steele for bnf this year. Outstanding season which has all but reinvented his career.

Lucky to be getting game. Should have kept Hind and delisted Sinclair and DMac.

 

[Stewart66]

and a knee issue

More his foot from my observations