Round 3 trades

[TheOz]

Wow! 19 pages already!!!
A lot of folks looking at NVB, I'm still not convinced personally. Never been a big scorer, and his scores thus far have come in huge Crow wins. Sure, he'll likely give you a good price rise this week, but no certainty to continue going forward.
If I was in the same situation as others, I would have no qualms about making the Ablett -> Bontempelli trade. You can move Bont forward through DPP at a later date. Bont is a gun. Tag doesn't seem to bother him at all. When you are laying 10 tackles a game, even if his production is quelled a little, chances are he still puts up a decent score, especially for a 422k (eventual) forward.

NVB was a more than decent scorer when not being used as Adelaide's primary tagger, being used as a tagger killed his output for a few seasons. He has been relieved from tagging this season and for $215k is scoring well beyond that price, coupled with someone like Miller who doesn't look like he'll produce much, it should be a fairly straight forward rookie correction trade.

 

[tommyv49]

WITHOUT considering my team, rate the following from MOST important to LEAST important

INS
Fyfe
Bont
Oxley
Sinclair
Docherty
Van Berlo

OUTS
Ablett
Touk Miller
Cripps

INS
Ox
NVB
Fyfe
Bont
Sinc
Doch
(cash is king)

OUTS
Cripps
Ablett
Miller

 

[TN25]

That's a ******* bitch.

Sure is. Will probably go Ablett > Sloane instead, as there is no decent defenders other than Docherty around 400k.

Or do I go Ablett > Fyfe and Cripps > NVB/Vandeberg?

 

[TheOz]

Sure is. Will probably go Ablett > Sloane instead, as there is no decent defenders other than Docherty around 400k

I'm $2000 off from pulling off GAJ -> Pendles and Cripps -> Bont. Hate this ****ing game sometimes.

 

[TheOz]

Sure is. Will probably go Ablett > Sloane instead, as there is no decent defenders other than Docherty around 400k.

Or do I go Ablett > Fyfe and Cripps > NVB/Vandeberg?

I'd be getting Fyfe in ASAP if I didn't have him and Vandenberg who for his price is along with CEY the best of the mid rookie bunch.

 

[cdcanman]

NVB was a more than decent scorer when not being used as Adelaide's primary tagger, being used as a tagger killed his output for a few seasons. He has been relieved from tagging this season and for $215k is scoring well beyond that price, coupled with someone like Miller who doesn't look like he'll produce much, it should be a fairly straight forward rookie correction trade.

He has only had 1 season with an average greater than 80, not great for a fulltime mid

 

[TheOz]

He has only had 1 season with an average greater than 80, not great for a fulltime mid

Two seasons > 80 (84.5 and 83.9). Not numbers to write home about but for his price and role he is playing, 80 should be achievable.

 

[rocker_oz33]

I dont have enough to go.
Gaz to pendles.
Miller > NVB

Guess its either.
Gaz to sloane/jpk/Lewis and miller to NVB.
and Hold cripps.

Or miller to Sinclair and gaz to pendles miss the money from NVB.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

He has only had 1 season with an average greater than 80, not great for a fulltime mid

Happily take 80 average for $215k. He's not tagging and tackles a fair bit which helps.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

I dont have enough to go.
Gaz to pendles.
Miller > NVB

Guess its either.
Gaz to sloane/jpk/Lewis and miller to NVB.
and Hold cripps.

Or miller to Sinclair and gaz to pendles miss the money from NVB.

Gaz > JPK
Miller > NVB

If i were you...

 

[SnappyHappy]

Which 2 to bring in?

Bont & Smith
Sloane & Docherty
Pendles & Savage

 

[Richo Man]

Goodes > Oxley
Ablett > Fyfe

I'll eventually get Ablett back in because his break-even will be huge this week so he has to drop. Wish i'd gotten Fyfe from the start. Keeping Cripps in because he missed this week and feel he will bounce back. Wish I didn't pick up McEvoy. Haha.
These trades will leave me with $260k to play with.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

I'm so glad I did 2 quick trades before R1 started.

Lambert/Steele > Vandenberg
Brown > Oxley

 

[BrissyLions101]

If ablett gets a 100 odd with his 240ish break even, how much value does he stand to lose?

 

[brahj]

I think I fluked it this year with rookies, the only one I'm going to miss the round 3 boat on is Hogan.

Cripps > Van Berlo
Ablett > Kennedy

Now that I have some Gary money I'll probably look to move Newnes to Smith next round.

 

[ManWithNoName]

KK -> Docherty
Clem 'Spud' Smith -> NVB

I think I'm set.

 

[brahj]

If ablett gets a 100 odd with his 240ish break even, how much value does he stand to lose?

Around $50k I think.

 

[TheOz]

If ablett gets a 100 odd with his 240ish break even, how much value does he stand to lose?

With a 100 he'll go down to ~$677,500 (-$57,100)

 

[Lums23]

For me this week,
I'm pretty set on Goodes -> Oxley. Gives me about 130k to play with.
Unsure of what to do with the next move. Value opinions on the following options.
I could:
Option 1: Stand fast, pocket the $$$ for a rainy day
Option 2: Turn either Cripps/Sheed -> Wallis
Option 3: Lumumba/Newnes -> any premo defender

Option 1,2 or 3? What say you BF peeps?

I'm leaning towards Option 2 FWIW

I like number 1. Don't like option 3 at all, and I don't think Wallis will be a keeper

 

[JPod_31]

Gaz to pendles/Jkp or Sloane.
Wait on Cripps see if named alot are getting on NVB he will make good coin.

Cheers
Should i do Gaz-JPK and Miller-VB?

 

[BrissyLions101]

With a 100 he'll go down to ~$677,500 (-$57,100)

Will pose good value in a couple weeks for sure then, or for how long it takes his shoulder to get right

 

[TheOz]

Will pose good value in a couple weeks for sure then, or for how long it takes his shoulder to get right

Another 100 the week after will see him lose another $50k odd.

 

[dipper86]

Massive dilemmas gents.

Ablett & Cripps > Bontempelli & B Smith

*Moving Newnes to the midfield.
B: B Smith Shaw Hibberd Higgins Saad McIntosh
M: Fyfe Pendlebury Dangerfield Bontempelli Griffen Newnes Vandenberg Heeney

or

Ablett & Cripps > Kennedy/Sloane & Rich

B: Shaw Hibberd Newnes Higgins Saad McIntosh
M: Kennedy/Sloane Fyfe Pendlebury Dangerfield Griffen Rich Vandenberg Heeney

or

Ablett & Cripps > Kennedy/Sloane & NVB

B: Shaw Hibberd Newnes Higgins Saad McIntosh
M: Kennedy/Sloane Fyfe Pendlebury Dangerfield Griffen NVB Vandenberg Heeney


My head hurts......give me something.

 

[okeydoke7]

Screwed up with my rookies. Missed out on Hogan, Oxley, Mcintosh. Didn't back myself with Van Berlo or Rich. Didn't back myself with Sam Fisher either.

ATM I am unhappy with Tom Lamb, Patrick Cripps, Miller, Goodes and N.Brown.

I think my most important trades here would be Brown and Goodes into Mcintosh and Oxley. I will miss Hogan. Won't be able to get on the gravy train of NVB or Rich. And will hold Cripps and Lamb for now.

Thoughts?

 

[brahj]

Screwed up with my rookies. Missed out on Hogan, Oxley, Mcintosh. Didn't back myself with Van Berlo or Rich. Didn't back myself with Sam Fisher either.

ATM I am unhappy with Tom Lamb, Patrick Cripps, Miller, Goodes and N.Brown.

I think my most important trades here would be Brown and Goodes into Mcintosh and Oxley. I will miss Hogan. Won't be able to get on the gravy train of NVB or Rich. And will hold Cripps and Lamb for now.

Thoughts?

As far as numbers go for those that you have missed and the round 3 price rise, your priorities should go in this order: McIntosh, Hogan, Van Berlo, Oxley

Personally, I'd get rid of Cripps and Brown and get McIntosh and Van Berlo in.