Round 3 Trades

[JDavey]

Questions to answer this week. Any thoughts?

1. Should I turn JOM or Steele into WHE?
2. Should Mountford become Preuss?
3. Is Hannan still worth picking up?

 

[Judd_Magic]

Questions to answer this week. Any thoughts?

1. Should I turn JOM or Steele into WHE? - NO
2. Should Mountford become Preuss? - YES
3. Is Hannan still wort picking up? - NO

 

[rocker_oz33]

I was on Hannah watch.Might give him a miss.
Pity Puress hasn't got dpp.

 

[Spacedog]

Ive got mountford, hibberd, pickett, and parfitt. Dunno what to do with these spuds

 

[CasuallyDressed]

Ive got mountford, hibberd, pickett, and parfitt. Dunno what to do with these spuds

I'm sure they'll come good...

 

[big_bazza]

Ok well as much as id like to keep both of SPS and Simpkin because i know both will get alot better through out the year i think i have to **** them off. Oscar Elliot is a must have and trading these 2 out is the only way i can get him in without tinkering with premos.

SPS > Butler via Parfitt

Simpkin > Oscar Elliot

 

[GRUFFY]

2 trades
DMountford > WHE
JSmith > CMarchbank
COliver can wait another week as Steele will also get a payrise and Taranto could be the fall guy for Newman but we'll see
Nothing is certain, that's for sure haha

 

[CasuallyDressed]

Oliver in for Steven.

Another rookie is becoming WHE.

 

[Me Myself and I]

After Freo's two efforts so far, surely Balic gets selected this round. Three games for Peel, three games their leading possession getter - 30, 33 & 29. Reckon if he's not in this week he might as well go and tell Lyon where to go using some choice words.

 

[Mitchell54]

Is Steele to Nank worth it?
Don't need him as backup as I have Preuss

 

[big_bazza]

Ive already had a change of heart and instead gone Sandi > Witts and then Pickett > Oscar Elliot which still leaves me with SPS/SPP m8/m9 and only having to start one of Simpkin/Houston/Eddy to start each week up front.

****ing rucks are giving me brain damage this year, now im thinking i could go even more extreme and swap Ryder instead of Sandi to witts and free up another 120 k for the coming weeks. This game drives me bloody mental but i wouldnt have it any other way.

 

[Test Tickle]

Btw not making any trades no need
Is 2300 a good score??

No

 

[GRUFFY]

Trying to decide over trades for this week, any help appreciated..
TTaranto>COliver + DMountford>DButler
vs
JSmith>CMarchbank + DMountford>WHoskin-Elliott

may seem obvious but going different to teams ranked around me could be the way
Oliver on field 95+
Butler on bench, Stewart on field 50+
vs
WHE onfield 70+
Marchbank onfield 70+

I'm leaning towards Marchbank & WHE atm because I get to keep Taranto and I'm still tearing up over his phonecall with his dad

 

[pincrusher]

What are the thoughts on the Preuss report for the knee into the back of Thurlow? Is he likely to get suspended?

 

[srobbo]

Apparently Houston and Eddy may be out next week as Hartlett and Pittard will return. Port fans may know more but will definitely affect a lot of people's teams

Good. Then I can loophole Steele/Roughy's score @ F6

 

[The Lemon]

Taranto just got 75?

Anyway, with Kelly and Break even of 49, he's going for Otten, hoping he plays. Should make some cash there.

2nd trade might be Dunstan to Marc Murphy. I don't think its wise to go Hanners to Murph, but then again Hanners has been shit
Or other option is to upgrade to WHE
Can someone tell me what the differential between another 100 for WHE and 40 for Parfitt.

That was before everyone played.

I'm just going Ryder to Oliver

 

[The Lemon]

What are the thoughts on the Preuss report for the knee into the back of Thurlow? Is he likely to get suspended?

I reckon he will get a fine with a early guilty plea. It was silly and unco but Sam Mitchell got away with it for years

 

[MotlopMagic]

Mills > Marchbank
J Smith > WHE

Sent from my HTC_0PJA10 using Tapatalk

 

[m!nt]

The ship hasn't even been launched yet mate, plenty of room if you want to jump aboard

Ships don't launch mate

 

[stevebbb]

Anybody think Oliver might get tired as the year goes on? 19 yo solid boy, only a couple preseasons under his belt. Dead set gun who will score great, feel like might slow down a bit though. For $380k though... Hmm

 

[King_Steele]

Anybody think Oliver might get tired as the year goes on? 19 yo solid boy, only a couple preseasons under his belt. Dead set gun who will score great, feel like might slow down a bit though. For $380k though... Hmm

Could be a decent M8 but I can't see him averaging 110+ which is what you want in the midfield.

 

[stevebbb]

Could be a decent M8 but I can't see him averaging 110+ which is what you want in the midfield.

Realistically thought you're never going to end up with 8 players averaging 110+. Having a couple players averaging ~105 is fine I think

 

[King_Steele]

Realistically thought you're never going to end up with 8 players averaging 110+. Having a couple players averaging ~105 is fine I think

Very true.

I wouldn't be against it, I'm focusing on WHE & Nank.

Higgins/Oliver are tempting.

 

[pincrusher]

Anybody think Oliver might get tired as the year goes on? 19 yo solid boy, only a couple preseasons under his belt. Dead set gun who will score great, feel like might slow down a bit though. For $380k though... Hmm

Only reason I'm not considering him. Only 2nd year in the system. Statistically players need 4 before they have the tank to reach their potential. There are a couple of exceptions (Bont comes to mind) but for the most part they just can't maintain the consistency at that age.

Will probably be the first picked in my team..... in 2019.

 

[stevebbb]

Very true.

I wouldn't be against it, I'm focusing on WHE & Nank.

Higgins/Oliver are tempting.

Yeah Higgins looks amazing in the middle. Another I'm considering. $420k for a forward who is playing full-time mid that loves to kick goals. I'd be very surprised if he doesn't end up a top 2 forward averaging over 100.