Round 3 Trades

[Geelong_Bisons_#36]

2 choices this week.
Really only Butler the only rookie that I would like to get in but would have to swap Steele to mids meaning playing 2 rookies in the fwd line + WHE on field. Then trade Hanners out for Pendles.
Or get in 2 mid price mids who are killing it for Hanners and Florent. Would mean strong mids but miss out on Butler's cash generation.

Option 1:
Out: Hanners + Pickett
In: Pendles + Butler

Option 2:
Out: Hanners + Florent
In: Murphy + Oliver

Thoughts?

 

[fuic08]

So I picked Crouch as a Pod, still think he could average 100+, but with hanners spudding it up atm I want to rage trade. I could go Hanners and crouch, to Murphy and Bont and pocket 100k, is that temping enough?

 

[Dennis Trumpet]

Thoughts on McGrath being rested?

Will only be rested if his performance drops IMO

With the amount of depth we have running around at VFL level, if he gets rested, he might not make it straight back into the team.

 

[ROOINYOU]

Hannebery to Wines

Don't do it mate!...Wines has trapped many blokes before.

 

[ROOINYOU]

Have Steven, Smith, Bowes..

Steven gotta go, and likely Smith because Hibberd occupies the other bench spot..

Steven + Smith + 20k in bank = 697k

In Marchy, leaves 460k to go into mid or fwd.

Who? JOM, WHE, Oliver hmmmm

Oliver out of those...

 

[Eagling]

Hey guys; which of these teams would you prefer to be playing Round 3 with?

TEAM A:


TEAM B:

TEAM C:

 

[ROOINYOU]

So I picked Crouch as a Pod, still think he could average 100+, but with hanners spudding it up atm I want to rage trade. I could go Hanners and crouch, to Murphy and Bont and pocket 100k, is that temping enough?

Yep!...as long as your rooks are solid!

 

[freddy mercury]

Thoughts on McGrath being rested?

Could happen, if he gets rested it would most likely be when we travel.

 

[vast]

Thoughts on McGrath being rested?

Wont be for a while and will only be for 1 game, ran out the last qtr better than any of our other players so I am not worried about that at all.

 

[Chaisa]

Bowes > WHE looks a pretty obvious one for me.

Not sure on Trade #2. Want to get Nankervis in but him for Ryder or Roughead feels a bit sideways. If Otten plays R3 (and Lever is named) then he needs to come in for Hibberd/Smith, otherwise I'll wait a week and bring in Newman.

 

[ROOINYOU]

Don't worry about Treloar his winning lots of the ball eventually his scores will reflect that

Roughhead will only get better as well and with the GC this week could post 100+

Hanners is the worry, looks horribly out of form

Yeah Hanners the only one that I thought about...word is he hasn't had a drink since losing the granny last year.
...clearly his head is in a bad way

 

[GRUFFY]

DMountford > WHoskin-Elliott
JSteele > COliver

just fishing

 

[fuic08]

Yep!...as long as your rooks are solid!

I have Smith and Hibbberd on the bench in defence, rooks are very average. Burning 2 trades also but I've had it with Hanners already aha

 

[SC fish]

First trade McCarthy to Nankervis.

Possible second trade Pickett to Butler. Is Pickett worth persisting with?

 

[King_Steele]

First trade McCarthy to Nankervis.

Possible second trade Pickett to Butler. Is Pickett worth persisting with?

He'll be a slow burn. Should play most weeks.

 

[fuic08]

First trade McCarthy to Nankervis.

Possible second trade Pickett to Butler. Is Pickett worth persisting with?

He showed some signs today, I think he will improve in time

 

[juddola]

So many trades I need to do get rid of hanners, mills & lynch.

No nank, WHE or Marchbank

 

[craffles]

No probs

I should have remember this before I posted but both Hayward and Newman have only played 1 game therefore not on the bubble just yet

Cheers.

I think I'm looking at

Hanneberry -> Marc Murphy (just as good cash generation opp as a rookie selection)

Mitch Hibberd -> WHE via DPP

 

[Jak!x]

Possibly Taranto to WHE

 

[GRUFFY]

 

[Burzum]

Mills -> Oliver

 

[Verdun66]

Trading out JOM and Roughhead is absurd.

Seem like mid-rangers. Not going to make much money and be 70-90 scorers. Wines (or someone like that) going to get decent scores, and WHE will make money and hopefully continue to score ok. But as I said I will probably change my mind.

 

[Aishole]

Is it worth going O'Meara -> Oliver ? Or would a trade similar to bowes or pickett -> WHE be more beneficial. Im unsure

 

[Asho81]

Sandi --> Witts
Rookie --> WHE

OR

Sandi --> Nank
Steele --> WHE

Don't have Oliver or beams.... can't have them all I guess.......

 

[SC fish]

Sandi --> Witts
Rookie --> WHE

OR

Sandi --> Nank
Steele --> WHE

Don't have Oliver or beams.... can't have them all I guess.......

Why are you ditching Sandilands?