Round 3 Trades

[Goats]

Options

Hibberd to Heater
Naughton to Bonner

Or.

Hibberd to Heater
ZGL to Ryan

In leaning towards option 1. Thoughts?

Option 2, easily.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Is it worth going Hibberd > Shaw instead of Simpson to fund Naughton > Bonner?

If I did swap Hibberd > Simpson my only other option would be to trade Sicily or Lobb down to Bonner and keep about $200k in the kitty

 

[Andrewy]

Bonner = the 2018 burnman

Everyone aboard the burn train

?????

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Is it worth going Hibberd > Shaw instead of Simpson to fund Naughton > Bonner?

If I did swap Hibberd > Simpson my only other option would be to trade Sicily or Lobb down to Bonner and keep about $200k in the kitty

If you really want Bonner it's worth it.
More risk with Shaw though

 

[Kadog]

Bonner = the 2018 burnman

Everyone aboard the burn train

Hope so. It’ll be funny if Piggerd starts pumping out some numbers after the swap.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Hope so. It’ll be funny if Piggerd starts pumping out some numbers after the swap.

When Lewis's calf falls off maybe.

 

[toxic]

Hope so. It’ll be funny if Piggerd starts pumping out some numbers after the swap.

It'll happen

 

[GT619]

As soon as hibberd gets dropped. Watch him ton up this weekend

 

[DraftPunk]

What are we thinking with ZGL?

Is it better to just hold him, or could be a a good downgrade target in 4 weeks?

 

[GT619]

When Lewis's calf falls off maybe.

He’s still going 85% DE hibberd he’s just not getting as much

 

[rocker_oz33]

Hibberd getting dropped .

 

[WaynesWorld19]

What are we thinking with ZGL?

Is it better to just hold him, or could be a a good downgrade target in 4 weeks?

Use the search function .....think this question as been asked & answered a dozen times ?

 

[Kadog]

What are we thinking with ZGL?

Is it better to just hold him, or could be a a good downgrade target in 4 weeks?

I’m holding for now. He’ll be straight in best 22 when he recovers.

 

[rocker_oz33]

He’s still going 85% DE hibberd he’s just not getting as much

Av 20 touches last 2 games.
But only one kick out.He was kicking out heaps last year.

 

[Blackhawk42]

My advice for everybody trading Hibberd is HOLD HOLD HOLD. I understand that he is about to lose money, but through my experience of being awful at Supercoach I have learnt that you need to hold and trust your premiums for as long as possible. back to back 70's isn't ideal, but unless he is still posting these scores by round 6 or 7, your are risking burning a trade you may desperately need later in the season. I had Kade Simpson last season and he posted a bunch of 70's and 80's. Heath Shaw burnt you all and people are looking to forgive and burn Hibberd 2 weeks in. If you can, just chill!

 

[rocker_oz33]

Rounds 6 0r 7 is a bit much rd 4 max if hes still a potato.

 

[GT619]

Av 20 touches last 2 games.
But only one kick out.He was kicking out heaps last year.

He did score 121 v north in jlt and guess who he plays this weekend

 

[GT619]

Hibberd getting dropped .

Traded out

 

[rocker_oz33]

He did score 121 v north in jlt and guess who he plays this weekend

Lewis hurt his calf early in that game.Clearly didn't hurt it enough.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

My advice for everybody trading Hibberd is HOLD HOLD HOLD. I understand that he is about to lose money, but through my experience of being awful at Supercoach I have learnt that you need to hold and trust your premiums for as long as possible. back to back 70's isn't ideal, but unless he is still posting these scores by round 6 or 7, your are risking burning a trade you may desperately need later in the season. I had Kade Simpson last season and he posted a bunch of 70's and 80's. Heath Shaw burnt you all and people are looking to forgive and burn Hibberd 2 weeks in. If you can, just chill!

you want us to hold Hibberd, based on your self assessment ? ......shouldn't we therefore based on this statement, do the opposite of your suggestion

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Hibberd getting dropped .

 

[Blackhawk42]

you want us to hold Hibberd, based on your self assessment ? ......shouldn't we therefore based on this statement, do the opposite of your suggestion

Haha, i'm saying I have learnt from my mistakes! Just don't hate me if anyone follows my advice and he is averaging 65 in round 10

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Haha, i'm saying I have learnt from my mistakes! Just don't hate me if anyone follows my advice and he is averaging 65 in round 10

I can understand .....i held Shaw last year, hoping like hell that he would come good ......after 16 weeks i realised he & I was F....ked

 

[Blackhawk42]

I can understand .....i held Shaw last year, hoping like hell that he would come good ......after 16 weeks i realised he & I was F....ked

Thanks heaven's for Doedee! To honest, it's all the rookies in the backline that are impressing. Doedee, Finlayson, Bonner. Not totally stressed about an under performing premium just yet since the youngsters are picking up the slack.

 

[Andrewy]

Use the search function .....think this question as been asked & answered a dozen times ?