Round 3 Trades

[Judd_Magic]

is it worth going sicily to mclean or taranto? thanks in advance

 

[Hai_Newman]

Judda the trade ****.... (yes thats you Judd_Magic lolz)

get your splendid Trade Genie in here...

Would like your Juddment on these trades...

Crouch > Cogs
Siccy > Simmo Crazy trade I know but feelz good man

144k and 27 trades left...

or

Just Crouch to seccy Olliepig? 44k cashola...

 

[Marlowe]

What I like about Taranto is how his name sounds like Tarantino.

 

[enobrien]

Judda the trade ****.... (yes thats you Judd_Magic lolz)

get your splendid Trade Genie in here...

Would like your Juddment on these trades...

Crouch > Cogs
Siccy > Simmo Crazy trade I know but feelz good man

144k and 27 trades left...

or

Just Crouch to seccy Olliepig? 44k cashola...

View attachment 478998

Even just Crouch > Cogs and bank the cash for a nice upgrade next week..

Fielding Bonner, Doedee, Finlayson and Murray isnt so bad tbh

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Hibberd >>>> Laird

Naughton >>>> Ryan via Sicily

Holding ZGL. Naughton won't make FA.

$175k still in the bank.

 

[Waspy79]

Naughton to $444k or less forward or back.

Petracca? Marchbank?

Pull the trigger or hold?

 

[toxic]

What would y'all do? Beams is going, but my issue is $0 in the bank, yes 0

Really want Titch because I'll never get him, only way is Hibberd/Lambert out for Bonner/Taranto type

EDIT: When I trade Beams/Hibberd out and Titch in, I have $449,300 for a defender.

Options are Ryan, Stewart, Marchbank, Wilson?

**** makes me sad knowing I couldve just started with Titch and Ryan, id be top 1k instead of 19k...

Lambo to TimT
Beams to a real mid

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Options

Hibberd to Heater
Naughton to Bonner

Or.

Hibberd to Heater
ZGL to Ryan

In leaning towards option 1. Thoughts?

If you think Bonner is a keeper, option 1.

 

[Marlowe]

Naughton to $444k or less forward or back.

Petracca? Marchbank?

Pull the trigger or hold?

If you're high on Marchbank, jump on now before he's worth $750k (which will be soon).

 

[enobrien]

Lambo to TimT
Beams to a real mid

You liking Timmy tox?

Him and Ollie Florent are from my area (younger than me) and its crazy how well they are both doing in the AFL already - especially considering their age and sides they are playing in (Syd and GWS)

Think TT can avg enough to be worth the trade in? Argument of points to go around in the GWS team is true, however they will win most games and by a fair margin in most of them, so they'll be getting more points as a team.

Currently have Beams/Hibberd > Titch/Luke Ryan. 27k in bank

 

[DraftPunk]

You liking Timmy tox?

Hey mate, as a Tiges supporter what are your thoughts on Kane Lambert? Is he playing a different role than last year when he was pumping out 100’s? Could he come good or should I jump off?

 

[andrewcich]

Hey guys after some advice. Really happy with my team. Only real issue is Beams. I dont have Ryan or Murphy but have all the other main rookies. Have 3 options for my trades this week and interested to hear thoughts.

A) Beams to Cripps & Zgl to ryan/keefe to murphy- Leaves me with round 185k

B) Beams to Ryan via dpp & Keefe to Simpson- Leaves me with 193k

C) Beams to Ryan & Keefe to Murphy- Leaves me with 607k

Leaning A however with b and c it only means playing Kelly in the mid which is fine with brayshaw and holman. I only have 2 premos in defence w bonner so Simmo would be playing instead of Murray. C is risky but allows me to have another look at players/take advantage of price drops and potentially go 2 up in one week.

 

[enobrien]

Hey mate, as a Tiges supporter what are your thoughts on Kane Lambert? Is he playing a different role than last year when he was pumping out 100’s? Could he come good or should I jump off?

After sitting at the game round 1 at quarter time looking at my phone and seeing a big fat 0, I already thought to myself ****ing stupid decision starting Lambo. Then I saw him run 15km and get 71 points in the remaining three quarters and I knew there was a reason I picked him.

I did want to rage trade him after the weekend gone by, but our whole side bar Dusty was just heavily outplayed by the Crows away.

I think he'll come good, our next 5 games are at the G against non-finals sides of last year, and then North after that. He's runs a shitload, gets to a heap of contests, I think he'll pick it up

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

30 trades, 217k left. I'm mad keen to chop the Bont, I think he will limp to a shitty 95-105 average and I need another heavy hitter in the mids.

As Keanu Reves asks Dennis Hopper in the movie Speed:
What do you do? ... What do you do? (Yes, he really does ask him twice)

Option 1:
Bont > Danger

Option 2:
Sicily > Simpson
Bont > Dusty

Option 3:
Keefe > Murphy

 

[DraftPunk]

After sitting at the game round 1 at quarter time looking at my phone and seeing a big fat 0, I already thought to myself ******* stupid decision starting Lambo. Then I saw him run 15km and get 71 points in the remaining three quarters and I knew there was a reason I picked him.

I did want to rage trade him after the weekend gone by, but our whole side bar Dusty was just heavily outplayed by the Crows away.

I think he'll come good, our next 5 games are at the G against non-finals sides of last year, and then North after that. He's runs a shitload, gets to a heap of contests, I think he'll pick it up

Thanks mate, was leaning towards sticking with him too so let’s hope he comes good!

 

[Judd_Magic]

Would like your Juddment on these trades...

Crouch > Cogs
Siccy > Simmo Crazy trade I know but feelz good man

144k and 27 trades left...


View attachment 478998

 

[Hai_Newman]

Respect Judda....

 

[Brick Loosener]

30 trades, 217k left. I'm mad keen to chop the Bont, I think he will limp to a shitty 95-105 average and I need another heavy hitter in the mids.

As Keanu Reves asks Dennis Hopper in the movie Speed:
What do you do? ... What do you do? (Yes, he really does ask him twice)

Option 1:
Bont > Danger

Option 2:
Sicily > Simpson
Bont > Dusty

Option 3:
Keefe > Murphy

View attachment 479008

Hibberd to murphy
zorko to danger

 

[Judd_Magic]

Respect Judda....

 

[Hai_Newman]

30 trades, 217k left. I'm mad keen to chop the Bont, I think he will limp to a shitty 95-105 average and I need another heavy hitter in the mids.

As Keanu Reves asks Dennis Hopper in the movie Speed:
What do you do? ... What do you do? (Yes, he really does ask him twice)

Option 1:
Bont > Danger

Option 2:
Sicily > Simpson
Bont > Dusty

Option 3:
Keefe > Murphy

View attachment 479008

2.

 

[Dark Sharks]

Trading Bont, trading Sicily, trading Hibberd, trading Merrett... Why do campaigners start with these players if they won't back them in?

Trade away lads, personally I'm sticking in with my premiums i chose only 2 weeks ago.

Hilarious about Sicily though. Who'd have thought Lobb the potato was the better choice and would have scored more than Sicily after 3 rounds

 

[Brick Loosener]

Trading Bont, trading Sicily, trading Hibberd, trading Merrett... Why do campaigners start with these players if they won't back them in?

Trade away lads, personally I'm sticking in with my premiums i chose only 2 weeks ago.

Hilarious about Sicily though. Who'd have thought Lobb the potato was the better choice and would have scored more than Sicily after 3 rounds

round 2



round 4

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Trading Bont, trading Sicily, trading Hibberd, trading Merrett... Why do campaigners start with these players if they won't back them in?

Trade away lads, personally I'm sticking in with my premiums i chose only 2 weeks ago.

Hilarious about Sicily though. Who'd have thought Lobb the potato was the better choice and would have scored more than Sicily after 3 rounds

Bont:
JLT: Spent a lot of time in the midfield.
Rounds 1 & 2: Spent a lot of time anchored in the F50 with his thumb up his coit and cant get his hands on the pill when he is the middle.

Was very fortunate to ton up in SC last week. Bevo seems to prefer the two Macs on the ball and have Bont's finish up forward but the ball ain't going down there often enough.

Sicily:
A risk yes I agree but he has upside, I will most likely hold for now. Will score more than Lobb for the year IMO.

Hibberd:
Agreed, too early to cull. He put together successive sub 85 scores on a few occasions last year but followed them up with big scores.

Merrett:
Got KO'd in Round 1, will take at least 2-3 weeks to get back to form, I can understand the argument for both keeping or trading him.

 

[Hai_Newman]

Trading Bont, trading Sicily, trading Hibberd, trading Merrett... Why do campaigners start with these players if they won't back them in?

Trade away lads, personally I'm sticking in with my premiums i chose only 2 weeks ago.

Hilarious about Sicily though. Who'd have thought Lobb the potato was the better choice and would have scored more than Sicily after 3 rounds

By all means Sharky, be our guest to sit on your fins whilst form players present, and spud expensive rookies digress.
Pool is warm jump in...

 

[TurtleKid]

Hey guys after some advice. Really happy with my team. Only real issue is Beams. I dont have Ryan or Murphy but have all the other main rookies. Have 3 options for my trades this week and interested to hear thoughts.

A) Beams to Cripps & Zgl to ryan/keefe to murphy- Leaves me with round 185k

B) Beams to Ryan via dpp & Keefe to Simpson- Leaves me with 193k

C) Beams to Ryan & Keefe to Murphy- Leaves me with 607k

Leaning A however with b and c it only means playing Kelly in the mid which is fine with brayshaw and holman. I only have 2 premos in defence w bonner so Simmo would be playing instead of Murray. C is risky but allows me to have another look at players/take advantage of price drops and potentially go 2 up in one week.

Option A will give you better on-field scoring than Option B.

Option C is too much cash to have sitting idle at this stage (if you're going for ranking).