Round 4 Trades

[Nelso]

He would be trading Newnes out for a few reasons..... he's mildly overpriced, hes scoring worse than the rookies, McIntosh is a wasted scorer on his bench, and perhaps most importantly, it may allow you to get Rory Sloane (arguably 2nd best player in the comp ATM) in return. Its not like Im suggesting trade Newnes out for a sideways trade or for nothing...... Its basically 2 trades + Newnes --> Sloane.

Worth it IMO. May not be to others

Does not matter if McIntosh is a wasted scorer on the bench. He is still making cash for you even sitting on the pine.

And the golden rule is that each trade should be "valued" at $200k and there is no guarantee that the rookie he is downgrading Newnes to will be there for the time needed to recoup some of those funds. I can't see the value in what has been suggested.

But like you said, Everyone is entitled to their opinion

 

[Asho81]

Does not matter if McIntosh is a wasted scorer on the bench. He is still making cash for you even sitting on the pine.

And the golden rule is that each trade should be "valued" at $200k and there is no guarantee that the rookie he is downgrading Newnes to will be there for the time needed to recoup some of those funds. I can't see the value in what has been suggested.

But like you said, Everyone is entitled to their opinion

Yep, No worries "Nelso".... I don't have a man-crush on Newnes. but for your viewing pleasure Ill attach an image so you can enjoy.
Im sure Thugee will make his own mind up. Would be interested to know what path he chooses

 

[Big Fozza]

If I turf out Bartel and Goodes, which team looks best? I've used 1 trade so far.

Option 1 - $900 left
Bartel > Bont
Goodes > Hodge
View attachment 126499


Option 2 - $41k left
Bartel > Gray
Goodes > Roberton
View attachment 126501


Option 3 - 311k left
Bartel > Krak
Goodes > Smith
View attachment 126502

Option 1 for me. Gives you 2 keepers

 

[brentman]

Blicavs or Lycett for R2?

 

[Headless]

Blicavs or Lycett for R2?

What's your team at present? Depends a bit.

 

[brentman]

What's your team at present? Depends a bit.

Its a draft team actually. Looking for a DPP ruck to be on the bench.
Who do you think will finish with a higher average?

 

[illusionis real]

What's your team at present? Depends a bit.

Hi, I need some help. So I have Yarra but I'm not sure who to change him to. Im happy to burn two trades. I'm sort of wanting Birchall but if I want him I have to also ,ale another trade besides yarran, any sugestions please

 

[illusionis real]

Hi, I need some help. So I have Yarra but I'm not sure who to change him to. Im happy to burn two trades. I'm sort of wanting Birchall but if I want him I have to also ,ale another trade besides yarran, any sugestions please

Whoops here is my team

 

[IGetBuckets]

does trading griffen>>Dannebery sound like a stupid move? just thinking of griffen and looking at his scores make me wanna punch my laptop

 

[Chrissybabes]

I'm not sure who to trade Wines out for.

Only end up with 617k to trade him out and I'm not willing to make 2 trades to free up more cash.

At the moment I'm torn between Jordan Lewis or Dion Prestia (Feel free to suggest other options).
Prestia will be a massive POD, and seems to be improving each year at the suns.
But Lewis is the top possession taker so far this season.. so might significantly outscore prestia if he can up his DE.

Thoughts?

 

[Chrissybabes]

does trading griffen>>Dannebery sound like a stupid move? just thinking of griffen and looking at his scores make me wanna punch my laptop

I have griffo but I'm just going to hold him at least until the byes. He might just be having a slow start to the year.
Hannebery can have some shockers as well, there are better options out there if you really want to trade.

 

[Asho81]

Well the McGrath injury makes it a simple decision for me now.....
McGrath --> Krak
Wines --> Selwood
$3000 spare cash.... meant to be

Jaden McGrath, Sam Mayes and Claye Beams have suffered injury setbacks and will spend time on the sidelines.
McGrath has been diagnosed with a stress reaction in the navicular bone in his foot, and been ruled out for 8-12 weeks.

 

[scaryness]

Should I trade Hibberd for Brodie Smith?

 

[brentman]

Whoops here is my teamView attachment 126541

Youre either having a great season so far or burning trades to chase last weeks points. Assume it's the former

 

[Asho81]

Should I trade Hibberd for Brodie Smith?

Yes... like, Now.

 

[Headless]

Should I trade Hibberd for Brodie Smith?

If your biggest problem is Hibberd, I think you're going pretty well.

 

[TassieSaint]

Eski -> Birch

 

[illusionis real]

Youre either having a great season so far or burning trades to chase last weeks points. Assume it's the former

Nah it's my first year. Had a good week last week and starting to make some good decisions. ,y theory is well I'll burn so,e trades to get a gokd team and wish for no injuries lol. It's a tactic, but yeah I have yarran out so what to do I have no idea. I love Birchall but just not sure. In fact backline just seems impossible to nail as most teams have half with rookies and time will tell if they can keep it up

 

[Big Fozza]

Well the McGrath injury makes it a simple decision for me now.....
McGrath --> Krak
Wines --> Selwood
$3000 spare cash.... meant to be

Jaden McGrath, Sam Mayes and Claye Beams have suffered injury setbacks and will spend time on the sidelines.
McGrath has been diagnosed with a stress reaction in the navicular bone in his foot, and been ruled out for 8-12 weeks.

I wouldn't do 2 trades to sort out yarran. Looo at THunt maybe. Otherwise take the best available. If there is noone you can afford that you like maybe wait till teams and see if Goddard gets a game then hold off on yarran for a week and see what rookies get on the bubble.

 

[illusionis real]

I wouldn't do 2 trades to sort out yarran. Looo at THunt maybe. Otherwise take the best available. If there is noone you can afford that you like maybe wait till teams and see if Goddard gets a game then hold off on yarran for a week and see what rookies get on the bubble.

Two trades is ok, I mean my team has weaknesses, one thing I sort of not sure is having westhoff, buddy and walker in same side, buddy safe and walker more looking maybe a westhoff move for a mid/ forward. The hoff just hasn't been on as he usually is. Thinking I could get a mid/ forward for 400 g then also get Birchall?

 

[go you pups]

Here's my rabble, I have 48k left

Thinking DPPing Bellchambers fwd for Bartel and getting in Goldstein or straight swap Bartel for Roughy, not sure if downgrading Bartel to Bonti is the way to go

Apart from that the cows seem like months from mooing and there's no point trading Swallow and Gryphon out as they are scoring a tad better than the rookies except CEY, I also would like them to be depth players once the cows have mooed and are culled and buzz them off to M9/10 and be called upon when injuries strike.

Would be nice if Sydney gave Naismith a run

 

[Derogue]

I still have 30 trades left and 30k in bank, im unsure if i should trade anyone.

Havent got the cash to upgrade Goodes and no one yet worth downgrading to.

Other players on the chopping block would be Bellchambers, Griffen and Newnes.

 

[Captain Harley]

View attachment 126551

Here's my rabble, I have 48k left

Thinking DPPing Bellchambers fwd for Bartel and getting in Goldstein or straight swap Bartel for Roughy, not sure if downgrading Bartel to Bonti is the way to go

Apart from that the cows seem like months from mooing and there's no point trading Swallow and Gryphon out as they are scoring a tad better than the rookies except CEY, I also would like them to be depth players once the cows have mooed and are culled and buzz them off to M9/10 and be called upon when injuries strike.

Would be nice if Sydney gave Naismith a run

A fellow Naismith man! I like this!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[go you pups]

A fellow Naismith man! I like this!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Him and Lamb have been loophole candidates so far

 

[Sydney Kicker]

Whoops here is my teamView attachment 126541

why not trade Yarran for Newnes - so many nutjobs trading Newnes out, as soon as he fixes his disposal efficiency he'll be a great p.o.d for those who showed a bit of patience. And in case you're wondering I'm serious.