Round 4 Trades

[JTown21]

Hey guys need some opinions, Cant decide between Bartel > Swan and bank 40k or Bartel > Bont and Griffen > Sloane (or anyone else).

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

If I turf out Bartel and Goodes, which team looks best? I've used 1 trade so far.

Option 1 - $900 left
Bartel > Bont
Goodes > Hodge



Option 2 - $41k left
Bartel > Gray
Goodes > Roberton



Option 3 - 311k left
Bartel > Krak
Goodes > Smith

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Hey guys need some opinions, Cant decide between Bartel > Swan and bank 40k or Bartel > Bont and Griffen > Sloane (or anyone else).

Bartel to Swan all day long.

 

[Krujan]

If I turf out Bartel and Goodes, which team looks best? I've used 1 trade so far.

Option 1 - $900 left
View attachment 126499


Option 2 - $41k left
View attachment 126501


Option 3 - 311k left
View attachment 126502

Wow, that's annoying. How about posting which 2 trades you did for each of the 3 teams teams instead of just posting pictures expecting people to figure it out.

 

[Lums23]

Hey guys need some opinions, Cant decide between Bartel > Swan and bank 40k or Bartel > Bont and Griffen > Sloane (or anyone else).

The second option is appealing to me. Bont and Swan could well average fairly similarly, and while Griffen should improve, you would think he won't be a keeper anyway, and that Sloane will average 10-20 points more

 

[Headless]

OPTION ONE:
Haynes > Andrews/Kelly
Lonie/Anderson > Bontempelli

B: Simpson - Burgoyne - Newnes - Saad - Oxley - McIntosh (Brown - Andrews)
C: Pendlebury - Fyfe - Selwood - Ward - van Berlo - Ellis-Yolmen - Cripps - Heeney (vandenBerg - Miller - Anderson)
R: Jacobs - Goldstein (Read)
F: Gray - Bennell - Swan - Smith - Bontempelli - Hogan (Clark - Salem)

OPTION TWO:
Anderson/Lonie > Krakouer
Haynes > Fisher/Docherty/McDonald/Lumumba

B: Simpson - Burgoyne - Fisher - Newnes - Saad - Oxley (McIntosh - Brown)
C: Pendlebury - Fyfe - Selwood - Ward - van Berlo - Ellis-Yolmen - Cripps - Heeney (vandenBerg - Miller - Krakouer)
R: Jacobs - Goldstein (Read)
F: Gray - Bennell - Swan - Smith - Hogan - Clark (Salem - Lonie)

OPTION THREE:
Haynes > Andrews/Kelly
Newnes > Smith/Hodge/Rance/Shaw

B: Smith - Simpson - Burgoyne - Saad - Oxley - McIntosh (Brown - Andrews)
C: Pendlebury - Fyfe - Selwood - Ward - van Berlo - Ellis-Yolmen - Cripps - Heeney (vandenBerg - Miller - Anderson)
R: Jacobs - Goldstein (Read)
F: Gray - Bennell - Swan - Smith - Hogan - Clark (Salem - Lonie)

OPTION FOUR:
Haynes > Hunt
Newnes > Houli/Birchall

B: Simpson - Burgoyne - Houli - Hunt - Saad - Oxley (McIntosh - Brown)
C: Pendlebury - Fyfe - Selwood - Ward - van Berlo - Ellis-Yolmen - Cripps - Heeney (vandenBerg - Miller - Anderson)
R: Jacobs - Goldstein (Read)
F: Gray - Bennell - Swan - Smith - Hogan - Clark (Salem - Lonie)

OPTION FIVE:
Sit tight


I have no idea what I'll do yet. I don't expect comments (input would be grouse, though) - just wanted to map out my options a bit.

EDIT: Many apologies for the long post. I think Option One is the front-runner.

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Wow, that's annoying. How about posting which 2 trades you did for each of the 3 teams teams instead of just posting pictures expecting people to figure it out.

Oops, sorry about that

Post has been edited

 

[Krujan]

Oops, sorry about that

Post has been edited

Ooh option 1 from me. Nice team BTW.

 

[Headless]

Oops, sorry about that

Post has been edited

I like Bontempelli and Hodge. Option 3 would allow you to bring in another premium next week, though.

 

[toxic]

Option 1

If I turf out Bartel and Goodes, which team looks best? I've used 1 trade so far.

Option 1 - $900 left
Bartel > Bont
Goodes > Hodge
View attachment 126499


Option 2 - $41k left
Bartel > Gray
Goodes > Roberton
View attachment 126501


Option 3 - 311k left
Bartel > Krak
Goodes > Smith
View attachment 126502

Option 1


Next week is grab a krak week for all

 

[Hoges64]

Deledio has forced my hand,

Need to trade in some better options:
Deledio > Swan
Geary > Hooker

Leaves me $90K in the bank and sitting on my team for at least 4 to 5 weeks (except to maybe try and get Krak in next week...)

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

OPTION ONE:
Haynes > Andrews/Kelly
Lonie/Anderson > Bontempelli

B: Simpson - Burgoyne - Newnes - Saad - Oxley - McIntosh (Brown - Andrews)
C: Pendlebury - Fyfe - Selwood - Ward - van Berlo - Ellis-Yolmen - Cripps - Heeney (vandenBerg - Miller - Anderson)
R: Jacobs - Goldstein (Read)
F: Gray - Bennell - Swan - Smith - Bontempelli - Hogan (Clark - Salem)

OPTION TWO:
Anderson/Lonie > Krakouer
Haynes > Fisher/Docherty/McDonald/Lumumba

B: Simpson - Burgoyne - Fisher - Newnes - Saad - Oxley (McIntosh - Brown)
C: Pendlebury - Fyfe - Selwood - Ward - van Berlo - Ellis-Yolmen - Cripps - Heeney (vandenBerg - Miller - Krakouer)
R: Jacobs - Goldstein (Read)
F: Gray - Bennell - Swan - Smith - Hogan - Clark (Salem - Lonie)

OPTION THREE:
Haynes > Andrews/Kelly
Newnes > Smith/Hodge/Rance/Shaw

B: Smith - Simpson - Burgoyne - Saad - Oxley - McIntosh (Brown - Andrews)
C: Pendlebury - Fyfe - Selwood - Ward - van Berlo - Ellis-Yolmen - Cripps - Heeney (vandenBerg - Miller - Anderson)
R: Jacobs - Goldstein (Read)
F: Gray - Bennell - Swan - Smith - Hogan - Clark (Salem - Lonie)

OPTION FOUR:
Haynes > Hunt
Newnes > Houli/Birchall

B: Simpson - Burgoyne - Houli - Hunt - Saad - Oxley (McIntosh - Brown)
C: Pendlebury - Fyfe - Selwood - Ward - van Berlo - Ellis-Yolmen - Cripps - Heeney (vandenBerg - Miller - Anderson)
R: Jacobs - Goldstein (Read)
F: Gray - Bennell - Swan - Smith - Hogan - Clark (Salem - Lonie)

OPTION FIVE:
Sit tight


I have no idea what I'll do yet. I don't expect comments (input would be grouse, though) - just wanted to map out my options a bit.

EDIT: Many apologies for the long post. I think Option One is the front-runner.

I actually like Option 2 and would go for Docherty or The Fresh Prince. IMO Krak is certainly worth the risk to bring in before the bubble

If you are going to get rid of a rookie now then it may as well be Anderson, there is little point in trading out Lonie now as he still has some cash to make.

Andrews and Kelly have only played the one game and may not stay in their teams for long so maybe wait a week on them. There is also Robbie Tarrant to watch this week as a trade down option.

 

[james1995]

Anyone have a clue what to do with Wallis? Maybe Rich?

 

[Asho81]

OPTION ONE:
Haynes > Andrews/Kelly
Lonie/Anderson > Bontempelli

B: Simpson - Burgoyne - Newnes - Saad - Oxley - McIntosh (Brown - Andrews)
C: Pendlebury - Fyfe - Selwood - Ward - van Berlo - Ellis-Yolmen - Cripps - Heeney (vandenBerg - Miller - Anderson)
R: Jacobs - Goldstein (Read)
F: Gray - Bennell - Swan - Smith - Bontempelli - Hogan (Clark - Salem)

OPTION TWO:
Anderson/Lonie > Krakouer
Haynes > Fisher/Docherty/McDonald/Lumumba

B: Simpson - Burgoyne - Fisher - Newnes - Saad - Oxley (McIntosh - Brown)
C: Pendlebury - Fyfe - Selwood - Ward - van Berlo - Ellis-Yolmen - Cripps - Heeney (vandenBerg - Miller - Krakouer)
R: Jacobs - Goldstein (Read)
F: Gray - Bennell - Swan - Smith - Hogan - Clark (Salem - Lonie)

OPTION THREE:
Haynes > Andrews/Kelly
Newnes > Smith/Hodge/Rance/Shaw

B: Smith - Simpson - Burgoyne - Saad - Oxley - McIntosh (Brown - Andrews)
C: Pendlebury - Fyfe - Selwood - Ward - van Berlo - Ellis-Yolmen - Cripps - Heeney (vandenBerg - Miller - Anderson)
R: Jacobs - Goldstein (Read)
F: Gray - Bennell - Swan - Smith - Hogan - Clark (Salem - Lonie)

OPTION FOUR:
Haynes > Hunt
Newnes > Houli/Birchall

B: Simpson - Burgoyne - Houli - Hunt - Saad - Oxley (McIntosh - Brown)
C: Pendlebury - Fyfe - Selwood - Ward - van Berlo - Ellis-Yolmen - Cripps - Heeney (vandenBerg - Miller - Anderson)
R: Jacobs - Goldstein (Read)
F: Gray - Bennell - Swan - Smith - Hogan - Clark (Salem - Lonie)

OPTION FIVE:
Sit tight


I have no idea what I'll do yet. I don't expect comments (input would be grouse, though) - just wanted to map out my options a bit.

EDIT: Many apologies for the long post. I think Option One is the front-runner.

Wow, lol.... I thought my posts were elongated and confusingly and totally utterly annoying.
Jokes aside, I mentioned it before and I still think you should go for the 2nd best player in the comp in Sloane.
Not sure why Im helping because youre ahead of my rank, but here goes;

Have you got enough to downgrade spud-face Newnes (to a 110k rookie), switch McIntosh onto the field (he will likely outscore Newnes anyways, and hes a wasted scorer on the bench IMO), then add Sloane in for a rookie or NVB?
This would give you a killer midfield.... that's what Id do

 

[Kishkobi]

Already done wines>sloane

Torn between
Newnes or goodes>smith or hodge

I want to get rid or both before their prices drop any more i would of done both this week but wines forced my hand this week.

 

[Headless]

I actually like Option 2 and would go for Docherty or The Fresh Prince. IMO Krak is certainly worth the risk to bring in before the bubble

If you are going to get rid of a rookie now then it may as well be Anderson, there is little point in trading out Lonie now as he still has some cash to make.

Andrews and Kelly have only played the one game and may not stay in their teams for long so maybe wait a week on them. There is also Robbie Tarrant to watch this week as a trade down option.

Wow, lol.... I thought my posts were elongated and confusingly and totally utterly annoying.
Jokes aside, I mentioned it before and I still think you should go for the 2nd best player in the comp in Sloane.
Not sure why Im helping because youre ahead of my rank, but here goes;

Have you got enough to downgrade spud-face Newnes (to a 110k rookie), switch McIntosh onto the field (he will likely outscore Newnes anyways, and hes a wasted scorer on the bench IMO), then add Sloane in for a rookie or NVB?
This would give you a killer midfield.... that's what Id do

Thank you both. I'll look into the Sloane option.

Again, sorry about the post. It turned out a lot longer than anticipated.

Cheers.

 

[dewah07]

out
lonie
mcgrath

 

[dewah07]

Already done wines>sloane

Torn between
Newnes or goodes>smith or hodge

I want to get rid or both before their prices drop any more i would of done both this week but wines forced my hand this week.

newnes has dropped 6k with a BE of 90…..

 

[Nelso]

Have you got enough to downgrade spud-face Newnes (to a 110k rookie), switch McIntosh onto the field (he will likely outscore Newnes anyways, and hes a wasted scorer on the bench IMO), then add Sloane in for a rookie or NVB?
This would give you a killer midfield.... that's what Id do

Why would you be trading Newnes out?

Sure his scores have not been great so far but he just needs to improve his DE and he will be fine. There is a reason why people selected him at the start of the year. You can't dump him after such a small sample size of 3 rounds. Back your initial judgement.

Classic example of why people come round 15-16 are complaining that they have run out of trades when they are getting rid of players who have started off a bit slowly than they expected and want immediate results.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Adcock > Labamba
Deledio > Sloane

next week

McGrath > Krak\Tazz

 

[toxic]

Anyone have a clue what to do with Wallis? Maybe Rich?

Depends on the rest of your team

 

[Kishkobi]

newnes has dropped 6k with a BE of 90…..

True. He has the same this week so goodes is a better option but smith or hodge

 

[Asho81]

Why would you be trading Newnes out?

Sure his scores have not been great so far but he just needs to improve his DE and he will be fine. There is a reason why people selected him at the start of the year. You can't dump him after such a small sample size of 3 rounds. Back your initial judgement.

Classic example of why people come round 15-16 are complaining that they have run out of trades when they are getting rid of players who have started off a bit slowly than they expected and want immediate results.

He would be trading Newnes out for a few reasons..... he's mildly overpriced, hes scoring worse than the rookies, McIntosh is a wasted scorer on his bench, and perhaps most importantly, it may allow you to get Rory Sloane (arguably 2nd best player in the comp ATM) in return. Its not like Im suggesting trade Newnes out for a sideways trade or for nothing...... Its basically 2 trades + Newnes --> Sloane.

Worth it IMO. May not be to others

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

He would be trading Newnes out for a few reasons..... he's mildly overpriced, hes scoring worse than the rookies, McIntosh is a wasted scorer on his bench, and perhaps most importantly, it may allow you to get Rory Sloane (arguably 2nd best player in the comp ATM) in return. Its not like Im suggesting trade Newnes out for a sideways trade or for nothing...... Its basically 2 trades + Newnes --> Sloane.

Worth it IMO. May not be to others

This is why i think Adcock to N Brown is my best bet

Free up McIntosh to score the same on the field

 

[Krujan]

Even just Bartel > Watson (via Lambert DPP) & pray/hope no need for fwd emerg cover

Lamb plays on Sunday, as does McGrath & Tarrant*

You know what, this is probably the most sensible plan for my team. Leaves me with 300k in the bank and can E loophole Salem's E score with Lamb. If Salem should spud up badly, I can always trade Lamb > Krak a week early, start him on the field and have 310k in the bank for an early premo upgrade for Rd5.

Oh krk004 I realise by doing this trade I will most likely lose our Kliq cashie league game since we will only have 5 POD's between us, with me having 2 rookies starting from those 5 players.


*Lamb possible OUT for Krak*