Round 5 Trades

[Mofra]

A Brayshaw > Stack (putting Constable on field)
Balta > Marshall

 

[JuddgementDay]

Only because you kicked her out and now your crawling your way back to her.
When you trade her back in bring flowers and chocolate .

Thanks for the advise.
How can you say no to those lipsticks

 

[Unknown Identity]

Alright, so looking at Marshall's stats.
Currently sitting at 46% hit out to advantage, that's 13% more than Gawn and 17% more than Grundy.

That isn't sustainable, 25% might be achievable long term.
Currently picking up around 60-70 points just from ruck work (averaging 29 hit outs with around 13 going to advantage - 5 points per hit out)

So you could probably see around a 12-14 point adjustment when his hit out % drops, still has him sitting around the 100 average mark if he keeps up the other facets of his game.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Thanks for the advise.
How can you say no to those lipsticks

And dont leave the house with a loaded gun .

 

[PoopingHindi]

A Brayshaw > Stack (putting Constable on field)
Balta > Marshall

that feels kinda sideways. even if it does mean you're starting Constable over a fwd rookie im not sure its worth the trade.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Quick question, anyone know where to find the history of your trades?

 

[rocker_oz33]

I can get mummy insteed of Marshall and put licehead forward.

Keeping butters .

Moving a settersfeild / parker type insteed. Ummmmm.

 

[freddy mercury]

What about hore instead of stack

I had Hore, but traded him early. His JS isn't great.

 

[slamdunka]

Been toying with this exact same thing.

It's risky as **** if you don't have ruck coverage though, Mumford notorious for a soft tissue, either straining it or punching someone elses.

Yeah, make 300k but its probably going to cost 2 trades.

 

[Andrew Birch]

 

[AFDogs]

A Brayshaw > Stack (putting Constable on field)
Balta > Marshall

This seems counter productive. Melbourne starting to hit form you can expect some big scores from Brayshaw. I would be keeping him.

 

[rocker_oz33]

NOONS ...

 

[JuddgementDay]

View attachment 655138



View attachment 655139

Nah - you are missing SP Billings

 

[Plugger35]

Marshall was a great POD for me in the last round but he probably won't be a POD much longer as it looks like every flog and his dog is jumping on him.

 

[Chrissybabes]

View attachment 655138



View attachment 655139

I'm personally looking to get Marshall in myself but you're going well early on those 2 rooks. A more conservative play would be to just go Gibbons > Stack for better cash gen

 

[Shermy]

I'm leaning towards
Scott > Stack
then
Tobias > Marshall

Hold me Jeebus

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

I think I may do Z.Williams to Marshall via Rozee. I'm not certain it is worth the trade but i think Marshall will average 15 more and potentially be a keeper or F7 at worst. If i keep Williams he will be D7 at best. Its more likely ill trade him later so i think its worth the trade. Even if Marshall starts doing poorly he will make plenty of cash.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Marshall was a great POD for me in the last round but he probably won't be a POD much longer as it looks like every flog and his dog is jumping on him.

Thing is the forward line even tho early on has fuuuuu all standouts.
Danger,heens,boak.
Then billings gone bang.

Dev mena dunks etc down .

Even tho early days still.

 

[srobbo]

Patience starting to wear thin with Lycett. 3 average scores surrounding the obvious monster in between.

Tempted to go to mummy & pocket the 120k for an extra 20pts a week....only caveat being his body can’t be trusted.

To stick fat or not for now?? Port fans feedback welcomed.

 

[Chrissybabes]

It it worth keeping Dunkley and getting Marshall at the expense of Moore and Shitterfield (with lockhart added to Def)?

Here are some visuals of my 2 options for assistance..


+ 18k


+120k

 

[Plugger35]

Thing is the forward line even tho early on has fuuuuu all standouts.
Danger,heens,boak.
Then billings gone bang.

Dev mena dunks etc down .

Even tho early days still.

Yeah there aren't many mid price forwards worth getting and Marshall is one of the only ones producing premo like scores.

He's already jumped 65k in price since last week but even at around 400k he is still good value.

 

[Dark Sharks]

Hmm... best way to bring Marshall into this lemon team?


Butters > Ross/Stack
Moore > Marshall

71k left in the bank.

 

[Andrew Birch]

I'm personally looking to get Marshall in myself but you're going well early on those 2 rooks. A more conservative play would be to just go Gibbons > Stack for better cash gen

How so? Parker's b/e is 46 and he's already arsed his quota of 80+ scores.

Gibbons > Stack really isn't a more conservative play. Gibbons hasn't started making cash yet, but at his still low price once he arses an 80+ score (and he will as soon as you trade him out) his cash gen will belatedly kick in so long as his JS is still there he will make his 140k profit. Not only that, there is bugger all profit in that trade. Was the reason I held onto Hore when he was dropped while some others are looking to trade him back in this week. The conservative play is to not trade out rookies who've made very little/no money yet.

 

[evo]

Didn't Stack play closer to goals in his first match?

looked like HBF both weeks

 

[Andrew Birch]

Nah - you are missing SP Billings

It's "Classic Billings" and I don't need him as I've got "Big Noons"