Round 6 Trades

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Should I be upgrading one of Weiters, Dea or BenKen this week?
Always a bit hesitant on upgrading this early when it comes to rookies. Those three only need a big week, which they've proven they can do, and they start generating $$$ again.

Got 232k in the bank, worth upgrading one of them to a premo now?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Would really appreciate some other opinions on my movements this round. Just traded Weiters for Simpson, got heaps of cash to splash ($531,400) and not sure whether I should trade Dea -> Lee or go another prem. Sitting around 2000. I don't like Menadue in my team any more at all but obviously Dea's BE is higher.

upload_2016-4-28_14-58-52.png
 
ttomred17 said:
Would really appreciate some other opinions on my movements this round. Just traded Weiters for Simpson, got heaps of cash to splash ($531,400) and not sure whether I should trade Dea -> Lee or go another prem. Sitting around 2000. I don't like Menadue in my team any more at all but obviously Dea's BE is higher.

View attachment 240753
Click to expand...
id go menadue -->premo
you cant play him on the ground
 
Funky_Kong said:
He just cops it week in week out and keeps battling on.
Click to expand...
Such a gun.
schnoods said:
Well, you don't make friends with salad
Click to expand...
Saad is one of my favourite players. Especially considering his background. I love watching blokes like him, Tippa etc kill it because it shows anything is possible. Id make friends with him :)
 
ttomred17 said:
Would really appreciate some other opinions on my movements this round. Just traded Weiters for Simpson, got heaps of cash to splash ($531,400) and not sure whether I should trade Dea -> Lee or go another prem. Sitting around 2000. I don't like Menadue in my team any more at all but obviously Dea's BE is higher.

View attachment 240753
Click to expand...
I'd definitely upgrade. None of the downgrade guys on the bubble this week are 'must haves'. Appears like there will be a few good ones in the coming weeks (Petracca, Tucker, Keays). Dea could make his BE. Even if he doesn't, he likely won't go down much.
Menadue -> premo would be my preferred option as others have said also.
Wells forward, mid premo in
 
dustysfendoffs said:
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...s/news-story/c12723f162c37b6f1266a472ab610854

This man continues to amaze. Gets through all the niggles, if the Suns actually win this weekend at the cattery, he's an absolute champion GOAT - already is (I dont think it will happen)

'Salad" out for them as well hurts. o_O
Click to expand...
Maybe Davis (assuming he's in after being rested) gets a shot in the midfield with so many missing. He is a natural midfielder isn't he? Really want him to make it to at least $240k
 
stevebbb said:
Maybe Davis (assuming he's in after being rested) gets a shot in the midfield with so many missing. He is a natural midfielder isn't he? Really want him to make it to at least $240k
Click to expand...
That would be ideal as ive got Dunks and Gresham on the bench doing nothing
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

MVallence90 said:
What happened to Delaney at the Saints, similar type to Lee, seems to have fallen of the face of the earth...
Click to expand...

We picked him up from NM when we, literally, had a complete lack of KPD (save Fish, who at the time looked like he might never play again...), so threw a three year deal at him so we would atleast have someone to play on the KPF each week. And, in his first year, he didn't do all that bad at it - but he was always a fringe/depth player - and not really part of our next window with the likes of Goddard/Roberton/Carlisle now on the list too, don't think he will be hanging around past his current contract (end this year or next?)
 
buttox said:
id go menadue -->premo
you cant play him on the ground
Click to expand...

cdcanman said:
I'd definitely upgrade. None of the downgrade guys on the bubble this week are 'must haves'. Appears like there will be a few good ones in the coming weeks (Petracca, Tucker, Keays). Dea could make his BE. Even if he doesn't, he likely won't go down much.
Menadue -> premo would be my preferred option as others have said also.
Wells forward, mid premo in
Click to expand...

You have talked me into it fella's, cheers. Parker it is
 
I'm almost sure I'm bringing Fantasia in for Dea this week.

I'm not really looking to be convinced it's a bad move. I know it's risky. I'm hoping he'll be in the mix for a D5/6 spot long term, and confident he'll score better, and make more money than Dea in the event I can't keep him.

I'm mostly just putting this here so it's on the record.
 
Krujan said:
I still have Barlow and am meh about him still being in my team. His 1 decent score has been against Carlton, so I'm not sold that he's back just yet. Had I traded him out to a Dahl/Zorko/Hall/Merrett as many did, I'd be relieved that he's no longer one of my POD's in league matches TBH.

As for letting go of spud picks, I got rid of Sam Gray a couple of weeks ago and don't regret burning that trade whatsoever. Lonergan has been nearly as bad. I just hadn't got around to booting his arse out yet. He's had 5 weeks playing in the midfield and hasn't shown any signs that would make me think he will average close to a keeper. On averages, he's my D7 ATM and quite frankly, I'd sooner start my D8 Byrne than him this week. At 352k, if he's not scoring well enough to start on the field, he needs to GTFO of my team.

I was going to dump De Goey last week as well, but thought I would give him 1 last chance as he'd shown some good signs, even though they hadn't translated to SC points to that point. Scored a valuable 101 at F6 on the weekend, so I'm relieved I held that trade. Nevertheless, he needs to back up again this week, or he also will be unceremoniously kicked to the curb. No place for sentiment in SC unless we're talking about SP Cripps, who I wouldn't trade out even if he was averaging sub 80. :straining:
Click to expand...
Valid points - 5 weeks is enough grace for these spuds
I suppose last year I've got burnt by trading out a few players too early - but 'em the chances you make or break
 
go you pups said:
Doesn't bode well for someone who has been on the periphery for 4-5 years though

St Kilda are rebuilding, you either sink or swim, he sunk

Surely Goddard and co would be more tolerable
Click to expand...
Lee had both shoulders reconstructed at the end of his first year at the Saints.
He'll be a great third tall with Goddard and Carlisle.
 
Gribnoor said:
We picked him up from NM when we, literally, had a complete lack of KPD (save Fish, who at the time looked like he might never play again...), so threw a three year deal at him so we would atleast have someone to play on the KPF each week. And, in his first year, he didn't do all that bad at it - but he was always a fringe/depth player - and not really part of our next window with the likes of Goddard/Roberton/Carlisle now on the list too, don't think he will be hanging around past his current contract (end this year or next?)
Click to expand...

Delaney is out of contract the year. Very unlikely to be offered a new one.

Is also a very different player to Lee. Delaney is a big bollocking key defender who is literally a worse kick than Geary. Doesn't do much but defend. Lee is a 3rd tall in the dempster mould. With one of the better field kicks I've seen on a 195cm player.

Can't really speak for his job security though. Even I'm on the fence about swapping dea to him.
 
Just heard on the local grapevine that Lovell could be debuting for the Hawks this week. Not sure his JS will be great, but he has been doing well at Box Hill from all reports and knows how to find the footy. Could be a 'watch this space'.
 
Changa10 said:
Just heard on the local grapevine that Lovell could be debuting for the Hawks this week. Not sure his JS will be great, but he has been doing well at Box Hill from all reports and knows how to find the footy. Could be a 'watch this space'.
Click to expand...
mid rookies coming out of our ears now!
Petracca, Keays, Mathieson, Smith, Willis, MacPherson and now LOVELL!!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

stevebbb
Trades 2024 Round 6 Trades
42 43 44 45 46
Replies
1K
Views
39K
54Dogs
54Dogs
WaynesWorld19
Trades 2024 Round 21 Trades
2 3 4
Replies
94
Views
5K
Maybe Tomorrow
Maybe Tomorrow
Maybe Tomorrow
Trades 2024 Round 20 Trades
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
139
Views
7K
Pure_Ownage
Pure_Ownage
WaynesWorld19
Trades 2024 Round 23 Trades 🤣
2 3 4
Replies
87
Views
4K
bontiful speciman
bontiful speciman
WaynesWorld19
Trades 2024 Round 19 Trades
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
155
Views
7K
Raveneyes
Raveneyes
WaynesWorld19
  • Locked
Trades 2024 Round 22 Trades 🤣
2 3
Replies
65
Views
3K
BOMBERBLITZ
BOMBERBLITZ
WaynesWorld19
Trades 2024 Round 18 Trades
15 16 17 18 19
Replies
469
Views
17K
stevebbb
stevebbb

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top