Round 9 Ins/Outs

[DarwinRoo]

WTF, did you just call Peter Burgoyne a match winner? Remember he was tagging Peter Burgoyne, not Shaun. Thats too bloody funny.

Look, Power has done nothing, he was tagging Selwood last week and got shown up, for him to still retain he's spot over Harris is a disgrace and no one will come up with a good enough excuse to justify it, no freaking one!

I'm so over this crap from Laidleys.

Yes, Peter Burgoyne. The bloke that carved us up in Round 22. Do you still remember that or have you wiped that from your collective memory.

 

[CrazyQ]

I don't think you read it right. I was comparing the DE of Riggio and Ross not Power and Ross.

It is all well and good to take risks but at least put it in a spot where it is too our advantage. The only bloke in our side that can kick it to a 3 on 1 and hit our one is Wells.

I disagree on Powers handballing. I think he has the quickest hands and is the best handball in the side. That isn't saying much though because our handballing as a team is terrible.

He isnt close to the quickest hands or best handballer. Urquhart is a much better handballer.

 

[CrazyQ]

Just buy your membership and don't question anything okay.

Okay unky Geoff

 

[DarwinRoo]

He isnt close to the quickest hands or best handballer. Urquhart is a much better handballer.

That is one player. Care to name another good handballer in our team?

 

[Roos4eva]

Yes, Peter Burgoyne. The bloke that carved us up in Round 22. Do you still remember that or have you wiped that from your collective memory.

Because he had over 40 possessions?

 

[DarwinRoo]

Because he had over 40 possessions?

We are talking about Peter Burgoyne not Matt Priddis.

 

[CrazyQ]

That is one player. Care to name another good handballer in our team?

You said Power is the best handballer in the side. He isnt, not by a mile. I'd rather Wells, Harris, Simpson and Smith handball to me than Power. He isnt even the quickest, he just panics alot.

 

[Event Horizon]

No I don't work there and I haven't applied for a job there but I don't think the club should take any notice of what I have to say on here.

So you are telling us that you are not the club staffer who leaked the chicken video to YouTube?

 

[DarwinRoo]

So you are telling us that you are not the club staffer who leaked the chicken video to YouTube?

Im pretty sure that was established weeks ago Mr Positivity.

 

[PokerRoo]

No problem with Harris being out, IMO we can't have swallow, simpson and harris in the same team so harris is the one to miss.

As for power I am over the crap that gets written, hes in the team he is not the difference between us winning and loosing no matter what people think.

And for those who are saying they wont turn up if he is playing ect ect..your the idiots. I support the CLUB, and will support them not matter who is in the team.

 

[Deep Wells]

Just finished reading the whole thread. If anyone wants to know what's wrong with our club I suggest they read through it as well. The coach can't see the wood from the trees and until he is replaced we're going nowhere.

To summarise the general sentiment:

In: Harris, Jones, a decent coach
Out: Power, Hale, Laidley

A lot of love for Garlett & Greenwood as well.

Add Hansen, Harvey, Smith, Anthony & Pratt to the mix and the discussion is very different on a Thursday night.

Wake up Dean!

 

[DarwinRoo]

Just finished reading the whole thread. If anyone wants to know what's wrong with our club I suggest they read through it as well. The coach can't see the wood from the trees and until he is replaced we're going nowhere.

To summarise the general sentiment:

In: Harris, Jones, a decent coach
Out: Power, Hale, Laidley

A lot of love for Garlett & Greenwood as well.

Add Hansen, Harvey, Smith, Anthony & Pratt to the mix and the discussion is very different on a Thursday night.

Wake up Dean!

I have only seen one person calling for the inclusion of Jones so I don't know how that is the general sentiment.

 

[NICK_ROOBOY83]

Yes, Peter Burgoyne. The bloke that carved us up in Round 22. Do you still remember that or have you wiped that from your collective memory.

No, i haven't wiped that out of my mind, i just don't believe he's as good as he was last season.

Anyway, what did Power do last week? Thats right, he kept Selwood to 31 possessions and only gathered 10 himself.

 

[DarwinRoo]

No, i haven't wiped that out of my mind, i just don't believe he's as good as he was last season.

Anyway, what did Power do last week? Thats right, he kept Selwood to 31 possessions and only gathered 10 himself.

Who was Harris playing on last week?

 

[__aria__]

You think Harro played on 1 opponent for the whole game and you accuse us of knowing nothing about football?

 

[DarwinRoo]

You think Harro played on 1 opponent for the whole game and you accuse us of knowing nothing about football?

I asked a question aria. Care to answer it.

Can you tell me who was playing on Bartel? If Power was on Selwood and Ling was tagging Simpson then who was opposed to Bartel?

 

[NICK_ROOBOY83]

Who was Harris playing on last week?

Who did he play on?

Frankly, Harro is no tagger, he would be the one most likely to get tagged, he's a clearances specialist, and IMO he has done that job well since he was given a go against the Pies. While Power had done absolutely nothing, oh other then stopping Peter Burgoyne. BTW, thats one game, one game out of 8.

 

[DarwinRoo]

Who did he play on?

Frankly, Harro is no tagger, he gets tagged, he's a clearances specialist, and IMO he has done that job well since he was given a go against the Pies. While Power had done absolutely nothing, oh other then stopping Peter Burgoyne. BTW, thats one game, one game out of 8.

Who is talking about tagging? Im talking about which player from Geelong was Harro accountable for when we don't have the ball.

When was the last time Harro copped a tag?

 

[NICK_ROOBOY83]

Who is talking about tagging? Im talking about which player from Geelong was Harro accountable for when we don't have the ball.

When was the last time Harro copped a tag?

How would you know if Harro was accountable for Bartel? I cannot remember them lining up on each other at all, so i wouldnt be lumping Harro with that.

Harro has to put up with being blocked out of clearances on a consistent basis, I've seen it for myself and IMO thats a form of tagging.

 

[TerryBosniak]

I wonder what Nathan Buckley/David King/Peter German think of 'Honest' Sam Power?

 

[DarwinRoo]

How would you know if Harro was accountable for Bartel? I cannot remember them lining up on each other at all, so i wouldnt be lumping Harro with that.

Harro has to put up with being blocked out of clearances on a consistent basis, I've seen it for myself and IMO thats a form of tagging.

I don't, that is why I was asking you who Harro was matched up with.

Someone must have been playing on Bartel and I am wondering who it was.

Its blocking not tagging.

 

[Crazy Horse]

I wonder what Nathan Buckley/David King/Peter German think of 'Honest' Sam Power?

Don't know. But Blighty or Leigh Matthews would have dropped him after round 3.

 

[muttley45]

Just finished reading the whole thread. If anyone wants to know what's wrong with our club I suggest they read through it as well. The coach can't see the wood from the trees and until he is replaced we're going nowhere.

To summarise the general sentiment:

In: Harris, Jones, a decent coach
Out: Power, Hale, Laidley

A lot of love for Garlett & Greenwood as well.

Add Hansen, Harvey, Smith, Anthony & Pratt to the mix and the discussion is very different on a Thursday night.

Wake up Dean!

if you want a laugh read the freo thread,about 90% oh them are tipping us ha ha

 

[NICK_ROOBOY83]

I don't, that is why I was asking you who Harro was matched up with.

Someone must have been playing on Bartel and I am wondering who it was.

Its blocking not tagging.

Well, yes but then having a specific player line you up each clearance contest and block your run IMO has the same affect as tagging for a player like Harris.

 

[CrazyQ]

Simply put, Harris is 3 times the player Power is.