-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Rounds 9 & 10 - Trades
- Thread starter IDIG
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Re: Round 10 - Trades
Pure_ownage - option B
my little dilemma 10 trades left 222k left
Waters > Gilbee leaving me 64k left and only maguire is D7 and have Martin/Howlett as M6
Martin > 540k finishing my mids off and have Waters and Maguire as D6/D7
is Hargrave worth trading Waters for also??
Pure_ownage - option B
my little dilemma 10 trades left 222k left
Waters > Gilbee leaving me 64k left and only maguire is D7 and have Martin/Howlett as M6
Martin > 540k finishing my mids off and have Waters and Maguire as D6/D7
is Hargrave worth trading Waters for also??
Re: Round 10 - Trades
Hondo; I see ur point on Goodes and my Fwd line.. But Goodes and Dal/Montagna is so tempting and potentially massive.
If I trade Cyril to Pav it'll leave me with about $70k to up Martin which int enough...
But I can downgrade Rokcliff/Hitch or Howlett in a few weeks to up Martin then but there's so many well priced premiums now!
Ahh too many options !
Hondo; I see ur point on Goodes and my Fwd line.. But Goodes and Dal/Montagna is so tempting and potentially massive.
If I trade Cyril to Pav it'll leave me with about $70k to up Martin which int enough...
But I can downgrade Rokcliff/Hitch or Howlett in a few weeks to up Martin then but there's so many well priced premiums now!
Ahh too many options !
Re: Round 10 - Trades
Do the Martin to mid now. There are some cheap options. Montagna/Dal Santo/Murphy
Waters is scoring well and Martin is a more urgent upgrade.
My question's are who to upgrade and who to keep of Waters and Maguire?
Which forward downgrade target should i go for?
Playfair/Watts/Hughes/Any other recomendations?
Do the Martin to mid now. There are some cheap options. Montagna/Dal Santo/Murphy
Waters is scoring well and Martin is a more urgent upgrade.
My question's are who to upgrade and who to keep of Waters and Maguire?
Which forward downgrade target should i go for?
Playfair/Watts/Hughes/Any other recomendations?
Pure_Ownage
TheBrownDog
Re: Round 10 - Trades
Howlett is fine as he should continue making money for a little while. Martin has a tough run though and has almost peaked so I would probably do that trade now, particularly while there's some decent fallen guns around (i.e. Montagna etc).
Howlett is fine as he should continue making money for a little while. Martin has a tough run though and has almost peaked so I would probably do that trade now, particularly while there's some decent fallen guns around (i.e. Montagna etc).
Moonwalker
Senior List
- Feb 11, 2010
- 170
- 0
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Re: Round 10 - Trades
anyone thinking of trading to burgoyne? he is at 88;5% efficiency and is avging 91 in his first two games..how u think he will score when he can run for full 4 quarters?
i was thinking of doing
macguire --> heath
scully --> burgoyne and having him as 7th mid
leaving me with
goddard, hodge, enright, shaw, hurn, gilbee, malceski
ablett, swan, dal santo, barlow, burgoyne, howlett
sandilands, cox
pavlich, brown, o'keefe, goodes, hggins, hall, pods
with 9 trades and 234,000 in bank to use on howlett to get 6th prem mid.
what you guys thing?
anyone thinking of trading to burgoyne? he is at 88;5% efficiency and is avging 91 in his first two games..how u think he will score when he can run for full 4 quarters?
i was thinking of doing
macguire --> heath
scully --> burgoyne and having him as 7th mid
leaving me with
goddard, hodge, enright, shaw, hurn, gilbee, malceski
ablett, swan, dal santo, barlow, burgoyne, howlett
sandilands, cox
pavlich, brown, o'keefe, goodes, hggins, hall, pods
with 9 trades and 234,000 in bank to use on howlett to get 6th prem mid.
what you guys thing?
Re: Round 10 - Trades
thinking rockliff>playfair then waters>gilbee
teams done after this week with 6 trades left for injuries. if i dont have any injuries will upgrade nic nat to sandi or cox later in the year
backs: hodge, goddard, malceski, enright, gilbee, shaw & cornes
mids: ablett, chapman, nds, pendlebury, griffen & barlow
rucks: kreuzer & nic nat
forwards: pav, brown, o'keefe, didak, goodes, higgins & pods
thinking rockliff>playfair then waters>gilbee
teams done after this week with 6 trades left for injuries. if i dont have any injuries will upgrade nic nat to sandi or cox later in the year
backs: hodge, goddard, malceski, enright, gilbee, shaw & cornes
mids: ablett, chapman, nds, pendlebury, griffen & barlow
rucks: kreuzer & nic nat
forwards: pav, brown, o'keefe, didak, goodes, higgins & pods
Ed_Gein
Very good. But brick not hit back!
- Dec 17, 2003
- 17,871
- 12,042
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Glasgow Rangers, Liverpool, Storm.
Re: Round 10 - Trades
Playfair's JS is pretty dodgy. Only getting a run cause Jesse White has had a poor start to the season. Selection chances have increased due to Bradshaw injury. But beyond the next 3-4 weeks he may not be in the team. why not go for Rohan? He has been super impressive since being included in the team. I think he's in the team for the rest of the season to be honest. But in saying that, maybe when Moore and McGlynn come back it could be dicey.
Playfair's JS is pretty dodgy. Only getting a run cause Jesse White has had a poor start to the season. Selection chances have increased due to Bradshaw injury. But beyond the next 3-4 weeks he may not be in the team. why not go for Rohan? He has been super impressive since being included in the team. I think he's in the team for the rest of the season to be honest. But in saying that, maybe when Moore and McGlynn come back it could be dicey.
Re: Round 10 - Trades
any help would be really appreciated, really have no idea what to do.
Basically, I have Maguire, Martin and one forward to upgrade and Vince is out for four+ weeks.
Im thinking of upgrading Maguire, Martin and Vince in the next 2 weeks leaving me with 6 trades and the forward rookie to upgrade, leaving about 4 trades for injuries, etc.
Orrrrr, upgrading Martin and Maguire and waiting for a forward bargin and leaving Vince on the bench for Howlett for the 4 weeks. that would leave me with 5 trades for injuries but not as many points.
Any thoughts much appreciated..
any help would be really appreciated, really have no idea what to do.
Basically, I have Maguire, Martin and one forward to upgrade and Vince is out for four+ weeks.
Im thinking of upgrading Maguire, Martin and Vince in the next 2 weeks leaving me with 6 trades and the forward rookie to upgrade, leaving about 4 trades for injuries, etc.
Orrrrr, upgrading Martin and Maguire and waiting for a forward bargin and leaving Vince on the bench for Howlett for the 4 weeks. that would leave me with 5 trades for injuries but not as many points.
Any thoughts much appreciated..
Ed_Gein
Very good. But brick not hit back!
- Dec 17, 2003
- 17,871
- 12,042
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Glasgow Rangers, Liverpool, Storm.
Re: Round 10 - Trades
Maybe hang onto Vince a little longer. Adelaide seem to have gotten their act together, he may improve when he comes back and if Adelaide continue to do well. On top of that Howlett has had some impressive scores so he is pretty handy to have as back up for the time being.
Definitely upgrade Martin. He's done as far as cash making goes. Maguire isn't too bad really, but i'd upgrade if trades allow, but it seems you may be getting on the low side.
Maybe hang onto Vince a little longer. Adelaide seem to have gotten their act together, he may improve when he comes back and if Adelaide continue to do well. On top of that Howlett has had some impressive scores so he is pretty handy to have as back up for the time being.
Definitely upgrade Martin. He's done as far as cash making goes. Maguire isn't too bad really, but i'd upgrade if trades allow, but it seems you may be getting on the low side.
- Aug 17, 2006
- 23,678
- 22,259
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Re: Round 10 - Trades
I agree with Ed Gein re: Vince. It's a classic "league win vs overall position" decision. If you're going for the best overall position you can get, then no question, Vince needs to be traded. But if you just want to win your league, it would be tough to swallow if Vince comes back and starts scoring more than the bloke you traded him for, when you have solid bench cover.
Martin is the first one to trade of that trio. He must be upgraded. I'd wait and see with Maguire for another few weeks. He's only averaging about 15-20 less than the second tier guns at the position and he's been pretty consistent.
As for my trades this week, I've got nine left and 543k in the bank. My original thought was to trade Trengove for probably Murphy and Gumby for Chapman. I still don't mind those moves, but I'm very strongly considering Kane Cornes, who is averaging 100 and is bargain basement price. And with Chappy's break even in the 160 range, I'm also leaning towards bringing Goodes in as my seventh forward and trading Tippett for Chapman next week.
Any thoughts on these trades, or any ideas on better midfield options,considering money isn't the top priority for me, would be appreciated. My current midfield is Ablett, Barlow, Judd, Cooney, Mitchell, Stevenson, Shuey and Trengove.
I agree with Ed Gein re: Vince. It's a classic "league win vs overall position" decision. If you're going for the best overall position you can get, then no question, Vince needs to be traded. But if you just want to win your league, it would be tough to swallow if Vince comes back and starts scoring more than the bloke you traded him for, when you have solid bench cover.
Martin is the first one to trade of that trio. He must be upgraded. I'd wait and see with Maguire for another few weeks. He's only averaging about 15-20 less than the second tier guns at the position and he's been pretty consistent.
As for my trades this week, I've got nine left and 543k in the bank. My original thought was to trade Trengove for probably Murphy and Gumby for Chapman. I still don't mind those moves, but I'm very strongly considering Kane Cornes, who is averaging 100 and is bargain basement price. And with Chappy's break even in the 160 range, I'm also leaning towards bringing Goodes in as my seventh forward and trading Tippett for Chapman next week.
Any thoughts on these trades, or any ideas on better midfield options,considering money isn't the top priority for me, would be appreciated. My current midfield is Ablett, Barlow, Judd, Cooney, Mitchell, Stevenson, Shuey and Trengove.
Re: Round 10 - Trades
I've got 197k to spend this week and I was gonna upgrade Waters to Gilbee, although I am now thinking of going Water and Goose to Gilbert and Duffield... Which option is better?
I've got 197k to spend this week and I was gonna upgrade Waters to Gilbee, although I am now thinking of going Water and Goose to Gilbert and Duffield... Which option is better?
Re: Round 10 - Trades
So
Maguire > Rookie (who?)
Martin > Swan (was 3k off Judd)
but that would leave me starting a rookie in defence for a few weeks so I am thinking
Martin > Rookie (who again?)
Maguire > Gilbee
or
Gumbleton > Playfair?
Maguire > Gilbee
???
So
Maguire > Rookie (who?)
Martin > Swan (was 3k off Judd)
but that would leave me starting a rookie in defence for a few weeks so I am thinking
Martin > Rookie (who again?)
Maguire > Gilbee
or
Gumbleton > Playfair?
Maguire > Gilbee
???
Re: Round 10 - Trades
i would if i had enough cash but i cant get gilbee if i go for rohan. gilbee is pretty cheap this week due to his 44 3 weeks ago.
i still have peterson on the bench as cover as well.
rohans a gun looking forward to watching him carve it up for many years to come.
i would if i had enough cash but i cant get gilbee if i go for rohan. gilbee is pretty cheap this week due to his 44 3 weeks ago.
i still have peterson on the bench as cover as well.
rohans a gun looking forward to watching him carve it up for many years to come.
Dawesome Dock
Debutant
Re: Round 10 - Trades
My forward line as of right now is:
Didak, ROK, Hall, Ballantyne, Pods, Ziebell and Gumbleton with Fyfe and Rohan on the bench. I have 440k in the bank so i was thinking...
Out
Gumbleton
Ziebell
In
Goodes
Pavlich.
Any thoughts?
My forward line as of right now is:
Didak, ROK, Hall, Ballantyne, Pods, Ziebell and Gumbleton with Fyfe and Rohan on the bench. I have 440k in the bank so i was thinking...
Out
Gumbleton
Ziebell
In
Goodes
Pavlich.
Any thoughts?
Re: Round 10 - Trades
Looks good to me, I'd do it.
My question:
OUT: Kennelly
IN: Gilbert/Fisher (name who and why, can also afford H.Shaw, but wary because huge B/E)
Only have 8 trades left, so really have to slow down, but Kennelly does have to go if I want to get a move-on in leagues. Don't want to waste two trades, because will leave me with six, and I still have a few other upgrades to make.
Looks good to me, I'd do it.
My question:
OUT: Kennelly
IN: Gilbert/Fisher (name who and why, can also afford H.Shaw, but wary because huge B/E)
Only have 8 trades left, so really have to slow down, but Kennelly does have to go if I want to get a move-on in leagues. Don't want to waste two trades, because will leave me with six, and I still have a few other upgrades to make.
Supercoachfan
Debutant
- Apr 1, 2010
- 59
- 0
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Re: Round 10 - Trades
Fisher for me, is a proven performer and has just been moved back into his favourite position down back
Fisher for me, is a proven performer and has just been moved back into his favourite position down back
GotTheGoodes
Bloods
- Moderator
- #623
Re: Round 10 - Trades
You don't have the option of going Gilbee (or do you already have him?)
Anyway, Looking at the two:
Gilbert: $458K (-$50K); 97.8 Avg @ 76 BE
Fisher: $432K (-$58K); 88 Avg @ 54 BE
Thus, Fisher has a lower BE, has lost more overall and by all accounts his Avg is set to rise in the next few weeks... Sounds like the smarter choice out of the 2 to me.
Actually, I was thinking the same but have decided I'll probably go Gilbee next week as I believe he is a more consistent & higher scoring option. I know it'll be 1 week late but I'm thinking cash is more important this week.
Thus, this week:
OUT Warnock; IN Skipper
OUT Gumby; IN Watts maybe? Playfair (I don't like his JS tho)?
Then next week I can go (I hope):
OUT Hunt; IN Gilbee
OUT Martin/Ball??; IN Montagna
What do you guys think?
You don't have the option of going Gilbee (or do you already have him?)
Anyway, Looking at the two:
Gilbert: $458K (-$50K); 97.8 Avg @ 76 BE
Fisher: $432K (-$58K); 88 Avg @ 54 BE
Thus, Fisher has a lower BE, has lost more overall and by all accounts his Avg is set to rise in the next few weeks... Sounds like the smarter choice out of the 2 to me.
Actually, I was thinking the same but have decided I'll probably go Gilbee next week as I believe he is a more consistent & higher scoring option. I know it'll be 1 week late but I'm thinking cash is more important this week.
Thus, this week:
OUT Warnock; IN Skipper
OUT Gumby; IN Watts maybe? Playfair (I don't like his JS tho)?
Then next week I can go (I hope):
OUT Hunt; IN Gilbee
OUT Martin/Ball??; IN Montagna
What do you guys think?
Re: Round 10 - Trades
My team is
Defs: Goddard, Hodge, Enright, Hurn, Gilbee, Malceski, Waters (Maguire, Davis)
Mids: Ablett, Swan, Selwood, Pendlebury, Barlow, Martin (Bastinac, Banner)
Rcks: Sandilands, Kreuzer (Warnock, Fitzpatrick)
Fwds: Brown, Okeefe, Pavlich, Franklin, Hall, Pods, Fyfe (Hughes, Roberts)
im currently ranked 680th. hopefully move into top 500 this week.
my team is almost complete and i have 12 trades left and 165k in the bank
looking to upgrade martin this week. so im gonna go
maguire down to a rookie (ideas??) for which would leave me with ~420k and martin to one of
dal santo
boyd
marc murphy
judd
im leaning towards boyd for uniqueness and take away the first game back from a broken hand his avg. is 117.
or i could fork out an extra 80k and get judd whos just a gun but also very popular pick.
the leftover money will be to upgrade fyfe in cppl of weeks. any help appreciated?
My team is
Defs: Goddard, Hodge, Enright, Hurn, Gilbee, Malceski, Waters (Maguire, Davis)
Mids: Ablett, Swan, Selwood, Pendlebury, Barlow, Martin (Bastinac, Banner)
Rcks: Sandilands, Kreuzer (Warnock, Fitzpatrick)
Fwds: Brown, Okeefe, Pavlich, Franklin, Hall, Pods, Fyfe (Hughes, Roberts)
im currently ranked 680th. hopefully move into top 500 this week.
my team is almost complete and i have 12 trades left and 165k in the bank
looking to upgrade martin this week. so im gonna go
maguire down to a rookie (ideas??) for which would leave me with ~420k and martin to one of
dal santo
boyd
marc murphy
judd
im leaning towards boyd for uniqueness and take away the first game back from a broken hand his avg. is 117.
or i could fork out an extra 80k and get judd whos just a gun but also very popular pick.
the leftover money will be to upgrade fyfe in cppl of weeks. any help appreciated?
Re: Round 10 - Trades
Gumbleton ---> Watts
Waters ---> Gilbee
All good. Leaves me with Natanui and Maguire to upgrade with 12 trades left.
Though I don't have anyone to trade to ROK from, is he a must get?
My forwards: Pavlich, Brown, Higgins, Pods, Franklin, Gray, Goodes
Gumbleton ---> Watts
Waters ---> Gilbee
All good. Leaves me with Natanui and Maguire to upgrade with 12 trades left.
Though I don't have anyone to trade to ROK from, is he a must get?
My forwards: Pavlich, Brown, Higgins, Pods, Franklin, Gray, Goodes
- Status
