Gray held Nyhuis. He held onto his arms. I guess he was playing for a free (holding the man). Gray thought it was a better idea to play for the free kick than protect himself. As a result he dragged Nyhuis down and didn't put out his arms to break his fall. This is a simple case of play on, and a lesson for Robbie Gray that in the future - protect yourself ahead of playing for frees.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Ryan Nyhuis tackle on Robbie Gray
- Thread starter kane249
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Eddie Dingle
Moving chairs
“Massive form”
Looking for a history lesson from you here not what happened yesterday.
This is what I don't get. Smith laid a good tackle on Crisp last week who chose to hold onto the ball with his free arm rather than protect himself. But he wins a free kick for a dangerous tackle because of how he landed. It's on the lower end of the same scale as the one here with Gray.
Either an arm free means there is some onus on the player to protect himself, or there isn't. The inconsistency with this stuff is frustrating.
Trial by media has well started:
"Sling tackle"
"Slam tackle"
"Dirty tackle"
"Crude tackle"
AFL will respond!.....Probably 5 weeks now
"Sling tackle"
"Slam tackle"
"Dirty tackle"
"Crude tackle"
AFL will respond!.....Probably 5 weeks now
Nah, Sam's pretty fair - Robbie is a stager and a diver and got himself into trouble trying to draw a holding free
It's akin to someone ducking and getting more than they asked for
I can't help but wonder if this thread would exist if he tacked Sam Gray.
On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app
I agree with this. Poor form from a coach really.
Love the outrage at the tackle like we've never seen it happen before. Show me the last time someone got 6 weeks for a tackle where someone hits the turf.
He'll cop 1-2, if they go to 3 it's an escalation on what we've seen so far this year.
Enjoy
He'll cop 1-2, if they go to 3 it's an escalation on what we've seen so far this year.
Enjoy
demontim27
Cancelled
- May 27, 2018
- 1,482
- 991
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
You realise in your outrage that is one of the considerations in a dangerous tackle, yes?
demontim27
Cancelled
- May 27, 2018
- 1,482
- 991
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
Can’t believe people support Dixon remonstrating. It wasn’t a Malicious act, he didn’t intend to knock him out so it’s completely unnecessary.
A bloke got knocked out a few weeks back from a tackle by a teammate. It wasn’t malicious. He caught the bloke off balance and pinned his arms so he couldn’t dispose and his head hit the turf. His team didn’t remonstrate, they actually went over and stood in support of their teammate being stretchered off. You don’t remonstrate accidents.
A bloke got knocked out a few weeks back from a tackle by a teammate. It wasn’t malicious. He caught the bloke off balance and pinned his arms so he couldn’t dispose and his head hit the turf. His team didn’t remonstrate, they actually went over and stood in support of their teammate being stretchered off. You don’t remonstrate accidents.
2 weeks I reckon.
He did have one arm free but Im not sure it was much use to him as he was slammed down on the opposite side so probably couldn't use it for the brace.
2 distinct actions in the tackle will class it as reckless and the end result being high impact means he will have to go for a minimum of 2, I suspect 3 weeks downgraded to 2.
Bit unlucky but the second action was not required so he has only himself to blame.
He did have one arm free but Im not sure it was much use to him as he was slammed down on the opposite side so probably couldn't use it for the brace.
2 distinct actions in the tackle will class it as reckless and the end result being high impact means he will have to go for a minimum of 2, I suspect 3 weeks downgraded to 2.
Bit unlucky but the second action was not required so he has only himself to blame.
Whateley going hard this morning that he MUST be sent directly to the tribunal. Sam McClure was saying the same earlier.
Christ where was the media outrage when Dusty intentionally touched the umpire? But he will cruxify a tackle that had an unfortunate outcome.
Surely this is just a simple 2 weeker.
Christ where was the media outrage when Dusty intentionally touched the umpire? But he will cruxify a tackle that had an unfortunate outcome.
Surely this is just a simple 2 weeker.
He would of had two arms free if he wasn't bracing onto the opponents arms trying to milk a free kick.
Eddie Dingle
Moving chairs
Love the outrage at the tackle like we've never seen it happen before. Show me the last time someone got 6 weeks for a tackle where someone hits the turf.
He'll cop 1-2, if they go to 3 it's an escalation on what we've seen so far this year.
Enjoy
It should be two down to one.
People are getting over excited.
Maybe if the other hand was free instead he could have braced for it and if it happened in slow motion. I just don't get how robbie is at fault here.
Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
Higgins got knocked out in a blind side bump where his opponent had the opportunity to tackle. No suspension.
Nyhuis didn't sling, left an arm free and didn't drive the head first (body and head impacted same time) yet media is baying for a suspension.
This MRP is a lottery.
I said it earlier, it needs to be based on action not outcome.
Nyhuis didn't sling, left an arm free and didn't drive the head first (body and head impacted same time) yet media is baying for a suspension.
This MRP is a lottery.
I said it earlier, it needs to be based on action not outcome.
demontim27
Cancelled
- May 27, 2018
- 1,482
- 991
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
The other hand was free. It gripped onto nyhius arm.
You said so what. I have a simple answer to your smart arse question.
- Oct 9, 2014
- 12,777
- 22,902
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
2 weeks
Should be 1-2 weeks. The outrage ("6 weeks, straight to the tribunal") by the usual morons in the media is completely overblown. Just a regular hard tackle which went a bit far, with the outcome not helped by Gray failing to protect himself with his free right arm.
- Apr 9, 2016
- 1,825
- 3,174
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Fremantle aren’t a ‘big’ club.
Fremantle have already appealed decisions undermining the tribunals decidion.
Player was knocked out.
Nyhuis is not a Brownlow fancy.
It’ll be weeks, probably more than the incedent deserves in isolation - but hey, it’s the AFL and they’ll do whatever they want.
Fremantle have already appealed decisions undermining the tribunals decidion.
Player was knocked out.
Nyhuis is not a Brownlow fancy.
It’ll be weeks, probably more than the incedent deserves in isolation - but hey, it’s the AFL and they’ll do whatever they want.
Rubbish. The footage clearly shows him attempting to baulk with the ball in his left hand which immediately gets pinned. To say he was trying to milk a free by evading the tackle is comical.
CakeEater
Brownlow Medallist
Hes from a Non Vic club and Whateley hates Freo.
Usually like Whateley and how he goes about it, but saying straight to the tribunal is going way over the top.
If the MRO guy can't make a decision on this then he should get sacked immediately.
If the MRO guy can't make a decision on this then he should get sacked immediately.
Similar threads
