Opinion Sack Hinkley 10 - UnTENable

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
"The club thought that this year was going to be the year" (we win the flag).
"(name withheld) been tearing out his hair wondering why the season's been up and down".
- by former player with a role at the club

This club is desperately in need of an independent external review.
By definition, that really is insanity.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

By definition, that really is insanity.

At the end of 2017 KT discussed that the club decided it needed to get back into the draft and get youth into the team (which is why Koch credits the great bloke Hinkley for 'accepting' the club's direction) and in that discussion KT highlighted the year 2024 being the year where the fruits of this youth will be seen. I instantly thought Hinkley could possibly be here to 2024 ... and here we are.
 
At the end of 2017 KT discussed that the club decided it needed to get back into the draft and get youth into the team (which is why Koch credits the great bloke Hinkley for 'accepting' the club's direction) and in that discussion KT highlighted the year 2024 being the year where the fruits of this youth will be seen. I instantly thought Hinkley could possibly be here to 2024 ... and here we are.
There's the biggest mistake. When they decided that was the direction, Hinkley should've been moved on, particularly given his holding the club to ransom. Such a poor decision had and has us circling the drain.
 
At the end of 2017 KT discussed that the club decided it needed to get back into the draft and get youth into the team (which is why Koch credits the great bloke Hinkley for 'accepting' the club's direction) and in that discussion KT highlighted the year 2024 being the year where the fruits of this youth will be seen. I instantly thought Hinkley could possibly be here to 2024 ... and here we are.

The Keith Thomas pivot is true, but you’re 12 months early in the timeline:

• Port finishes 5th with 15 wins at the end of the minor round in 2017;

• Loses the home Elimination Final to Luke Shuey and 8th-placed West Coast;

• Amidst Donnagate, Koch & co extend Hinkley out to the end of 2020 (already contracted for 2018 and tacked on 2 more);

• The club then goes out and gets Tom Rockliff, Steven Motlop, Jack Watts, Trent McKenzie, Jack Trengove and Lindsay Thomas;

• Holds the ‘INSIDE PORT ADELAIDE — LIVE’ Members Convention on 10 February 2018, which is heavily attended by BigFooty and is met with almost universal and lavish praise from many who now wouldn’t trust the club to successfully feed chips to seagulls;

• In season 2018 Port misses the eight from 11-4, vindicating those who felt the way we were playing/winning was a false economy;

• The club then pivots, trading out Wingard/Polec/Pittard to ultimately bring in Burton/Duursma/Rozee as well as Sam Mayes, Scott Lycett & Cam Sutcliffe(!);

• 2019 is a Jekyll & Hyde sh¡tshow, underpinned and excused away by a mythological narrative that Port’s lineup is now teeming with children and won’t be in a position to seriously challenge for 2-3 years, despite having a list profile similar to the premiers and a stack of 28-30+ year olds in the lineup.

• Keith Thomas continues to run with a narrative of “Kenny sacrificed his career! [for the good of the club/list]”, and the media and large swathes of our fans swallow this rubbish whole.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top