Re: Round 5 Trades
Hmmm, Lucas.
Job Security?
Hmmm, Lucas.
Job Security?
-
LIVE: Sydney v Port Adelaide - 7:40 / 7:10 Fri
Squiggle tips Swans at 57% chance -- What's your tip? -- Teams on Thurs »
-
LIVE: Geelong v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Cats at 54% chance -- What's your tip? -- Teams on Thurs »
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Prelim Finals
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Round SF Winner: And_ROOS
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
SC Trading Thread (Part II)
- Thread starter Cats_29
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Re: Round 5 Trades
I don't get why people are so desperate to get Judd into their side this early, sure he will go up in price but he's not THAT far undervalued that you have to bend over backwards to get him.... patience people!
I don't get why people are so desperate to get Judd into their side this early, sure he will go up in price but he's not THAT far undervalued that you have to bend over backwards to get him.... patience people!
Re: Round 5 Trades
I like the look of him and was planned to be a replacement for Shuey but apparently he won't be out for as long as first thought so i've decided against it.
My thoughts exactly. McLean, Bower, Waite, Thornton to return at some stage means he may be in trouble. They didnt bring him in for a like player so theres no reason they'll replace him with a like either.
I like the look of him and was planned to be a replacement for Shuey but apparently he won't be out for as long as first thought so i've decided against it.
Re: Round 5 Trades
yep.
carlton have got geelong, collingwood and saints in the next three rounds so i wouldnt be so quick on trading him in. i'll pick him up roud 8 or 9
yep.
carlton have got geelong, collingwood and saints in the next three rounds so i wouldnt be so quick on trading him in. i'll pick him up roud 8 or 9
Re: Round 5 Trades
Really? Ah f***** didn't see that...
Ling then ??? then Jones
Maybe Judd in last week was a bad idea.....
yep.
carlton have got geelong, collingwood and saints in the next three rounds so i wouldnt be so quick on trading him in. i'll pick him up roud 8 or 9
Really? Ah f***** didn't see that...
Ling then ??? then Jones
Maybe Judd in last week was a bad idea.....
Re: Round 5 Trades
Didn't think of that. A downgrade for Masten was on the cards. I may start Bastinac over Masten this week and wait for Cunnington's 3rd game perhaps.
Didn't think of that. A downgrade for Masten was on the cards. I may start Bastinac over Masten this week and wait for Cunnington's 3rd game perhaps.
Re: Round 5 Trades
Do you rate Lucas above Melksham, Colyer and Howlett? Was thinking about Melksham myself.
Do you rate Lucas above Melksham, Colyer and Howlett? Was thinking about Melksham myself.
Re: Round 5 Trades
yeah, with gray and rodan coming in on the weekend, and hartlett almost ready to go, banner may find it hard to get games
Banner was an emergency player for Port who got belted.....shouldn't he be next off the cab rank...
Reading the Port team board, noone thinks Banner will get a game, but Banner was emergency... Sigh
yeah, with gray and rodan coming in on the weekend, and hartlett almost ready to go, banner may find it hard to get games
Re: Round 5 Trades
Very nervous about considering Essendon rookies as they get chopped and changed all the time.
Very nervous about considering Essendon rookies as they get chopped and changed all the time.
Re: Round 5 Trades
Surely you are taking the piss there right Prompts?
Cox >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> X 10 compared to Hille.
Surely you are taking the piss there right Prompts?
Cox >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> X 10 compared to Hille.
Re: Round 5 Trades
LOL...it's the issue about using the trade
I know you love to trade, but I got a few holes with rookies to fill first (and I assume everyone else has)
But having said all that, I want to trade Hille to Cox too....LOL
Surely you are taking the piss there right Prompts?
Cox >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> X 10 compared to Hille.
LOL...it's the issue about using the trade
I know you love to trade, but I got a few holes with rookies to fill first (and I assume everyone else has)
But having said all that, I want to trade Hille to Cox too....LOL
Re: Round 5 Trades
Both Cox and Judd will be in my squad next week mate!
Toot! Toot!
LOL...it's the issue about using the trade
I know you love to trade, but I got a few holes with rookies to fill first (and I assume everyone else has)
But having said all that, I want to trade Hille to Cox too....LOL
Both Cox and Judd will be in my squad next week mate!
Toot! Toot!
- Apr 15, 2010
- 69
- 0
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Banned
- #863
Re: Round 5 Trades
. Houli is a prime example of this, they guy has so much talent but Knights just loves toying with him.
Yeah Knights is a funny coach, he gives player a hard time and nobody has JS over there except maybe the top 10 players oh and then there is Gumby...
. Houli is a prime example of this, they guy has so much talent but Knights just loves toying with him.
N1k0s287
All Australian
- Mar 14, 2010
- 940
- 16
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Huddersfield Town, Nuggets
Re: Round 5 Trades
Hille or Seaby for Cox?
Hitchcock or gumbleton for pods?
Hille or Seaby for Cox?
Hitchcock or gumbleton for pods?
Re: Round 5 Trades
Got 19 trades
Got Pods, Rockliff and Gumby from the start...so heaps of cover in the forwards
114K residing
Was thinking:
Ladson -> Schmidt (with Maguire and Davies cover..Waters starting)
then
Warren -> $550k forward. But who???? I have Hall, Higgins, Pav, Danger and ROK. Would love Chappy but fall short of sufficient coin.
Or????
Do nothing. If I dont get a trade hit fix this week I may vomit.
Got 19 trades
Got Pods, Rockliff and Gumby from the start...so heaps of cover in the forwards
114K residing
Was thinking:
Ladson -> Schmidt (with Maguire and Davies cover..Waters starting)
then
Warren -> $550k forward. But who???? I have Hall, Higgins, Pav, Danger and ROK. Would love Chappy but fall short of sufficient coin.
Or????
Do nothing. If I dont get a trade hit fix this week I may vomit.
Re: Round 5 Trades
Alright, so I was probably the only person left in Australia who decided to give Tippet another round to prove himself.. although it was far better than his other performances, the spud still couldn't hit 50.
All faith gone now, if Jared Brennan is selected on Thursday, I will trade him in for Tippet.
Looking for a downgrade too (so I can get Judd next week).
Going either
Bastinac >>> Lucas
or
Gumbleton >>>> Pods
Either would make me a lot of money... Might go Lucas.
Alright, so I was probably the only person left in Australia who decided to give Tippet another round to prove himself.. although it was far better than his other performances, the spud still couldn't hit 50.
All faith gone now, if Jared Brennan is selected on Thursday, I will trade him in for Tippet.
Looking for a downgrade too (so I can get Judd next week).
Going either
Bastinac >>> Lucas
or
Gumbleton >>>> Pods
Either would make me a lot of money... Might go Lucas.
marky53
Club Legend
- Apr 2, 2009
- 1,064
- 429
- AFL Club
- Essendon
GOAUS!
Norm Smith Medallist
- Apr 20, 2010
- 9,850
- 7,553
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
Re: Round 5 Trades
Think of a couple of trades here
Hitchcock to PODS
then
Seaby (b/e of 104) to Cox (b/e of 93)
OR
Hitchcock to PODS
Medhurst (b/e of 42) to Harvey (b/e of 16)
Which one should I do? Or none at all?
Think of a couple of trades here
Hitchcock to PODS
then
Seaby (b/e of 104) to Cox (b/e of 93)
OR
Hitchcock to PODS
Medhurst (b/e of 42) to Harvey (b/e of 16)
Which one should I do? Or none at all?
Re: Round 5 Trades
@ golazzo I wouldn't be downgrading either of those as they both have growth left in them and Bastinac and Gumbleton have greater job security also.
@ goaus If you are really keen on trading then I would do the first option as Cox looks like a great upgrade option and Medhurst still has growth left in him.
Ok now for my trade ideas, I haven't used a single trade yet and waited a week on the Riewoldt trade to assess my options. They now are;
Option 1
Riewoldt to Pavlich
Clark to Cox
($55,000 left over)
Option 2
This week:
Hitchcock to Podsiadly
Clark to Cox
Next week:
Riewoldt to Didak
Hall to Goodes
I think Cox is looking to valuable to not pick up and would leave me with a ruck combo of Sandy/Cox which would give me an advantage in my league who all have 2 of Hille/Seaby/Kruezer/NicNat.
Didak and Goodes look good, give me an extra premium forward and would give me good points of difference in my league, whereas Pavlich is also looking great and would leave me with 18 trades still.
Opinions anybody? Would love some insight into this.
@ golazzo I wouldn't be downgrading either of those as they both have growth left in them and Bastinac and Gumbleton have greater job security also.
@ goaus If you are really keen on trading then I would do the first option as Cox looks like a great upgrade option and Medhurst still has growth left in him.
Ok now for my trade ideas, I haven't used a single trade yet and waited a week on the Riewoldt trade to assess my options. They now are;
Option 1
Riewoldt to Pavlich
Clark to Cox
($55,000 left over)
Option 2
This week:
Hitchcock to Podsiadly
Clark to Cox
Next week:
Riewoldt to Didak
Hall to Goodes
I think Cox is looking to valuable to not pick up and would leave me with a ruck combo of Sandy/Cox which would give me an advantage in my league who all have 2 of Hille/Seaby/Kruezer/NicNat.
Didak and Goodes look good, give me an extra premium forward and would give me good points of difference in my league, whereas Pavlich is also looking great and would leave me with 18 trades still.
Opinions anybody? Would love some insight into this.
Re: Round 5 Trades
Fwds are:
Brown, Chapman, O'Keefe, Pav, Harvey
as keepers.
Ziebell Tippett
Duncan Gumbleton
I am considering
1 Tippett > Pods
2 Gumby > Pods
3 Ziebell + Tippett > Pods + Brennan/Prem
Holding 45,800 in cash.
Any help would be appreciated.
Fwds are:
Brown, Chapman, O'Keefe, Pav, Harvey
as keepers.
Ziebell Tippett
Duncan Gumbleton
I am considering
1 Tippett > Pods
2 Gumby > Pods
3 Ziebell + Tippett > Pods + Brennan/Prem
Holding 45,800 in cash.
Any help would be appreciated.
Re: Round 5 Trades
Goodwin, Hodge, Shaw, Enright, Ceski, Kennely, Waters - Silvagni & Maguire
Ablett, Swan, Selwood, Ball, Barlow, Martin - Jetta & Bastinac
Nic Nat, Hille - Warnock & Lobbe
Brown, ROk, Harvey, Rioli, Hall, Ballantyne, Rockliff - Gumby & Hitchcock
$241,600 in bank & 17 Trades left
Options are:
1 - Ballantyne -> Pods & Ball -> Goddard/Dal/Judd
2 - Hitchcock -> Pods & Ceski/Irish/Waters -> Goddard ?
3 - Hitchcock/Ballantyne -> Pods & Hille - Cox/Sandi?
or i can not trade at all but have a tough league game this week...
What do people think are my biggest upgrade spots needed?
Goodwin, Hodge, Shaw, Enright, Ceski, Kennely, Waters - Silvagni & Maguire
Ablett, Swan, Selwood, Ball, Barlow, Martin - Jetta & Bastinac
Nic Nat, Hille - Warnock & Lobbe
Brown, ROk, Harvey, Rioli, Hall, Ballantyne, Rockliff - Gumby & Hitchcock
$241,600 in bank & 17 Trades left
Options are:
1 - Ballantyne -> Pods & Ball -> Goddard/Dal/Judd
2 - Hitchcock -> Pods & Ceski/Irish/Waters -> Goddard ?
3 - Hitchcock/Ballantyne -> Pods & Hille - Cox/Sandi?
or i can not trade at all but have a tough league game this week...
What do people think are my biggest upgrade spots needed?
Re: Round 5 Trades
Got 19 trades left...
am thinking Peterson > Pods (Peterson is a reserve with Gumby, Gumby more likely to play every week) and Maguire > Schmidt (currently have Maguire on the ground with Bock a reserve for a couple more weeks)
then next week upgrade Luke Ball and Seaby
thoughts?
Got 19 trades left...
am thinking Peterson > Pods (Peterson is a reserve with Gumby, Gumby more likely to play every week) and Maguire > Schmidt (currently have Maguire on the ground with Bock a reserve for a couple more weeks)
then next week upgrade Luke Ball and Seaby
thoughts?
Re: Round 5 Trades
jonesy86: Maguire still has a lot of money to make.. and im not sold on Schmidt being able to keep his spot? Crows have a few ppl to come back in soon you would think?
Peterson to Pods sounds like my problem although i have hitchcock instead... Peterson should keep his spot for a while longer and his BE is 5 so i don't know if thats really needed...
jonesy86: Maguire still has a lot of money to make.. and im not sold on Schmidt being able to keep his spot? Crows have a few ppl to come back in soon you would think?
Peterson to Pods sounds like my problem although i have hitchcock instead... Peterson should keep his spot for a while longer and his BE is 5 so i don't know if thats really needed...
muttonchops
Club Legend
Re: Round 5 Trades
How does this trade sound. I have finally ran out of patience with Tippett.
Out Ballantyne 299,900
In Podsiadly 83,400
Cash 31,600 + 216,500
Total 216,500
Out Tippett 301,400
Total to spend 517,900
In Didak 503,400
End Result
Out Ballantyne and Tippett
In Didak and Podsiadly.
How does this trade sound. I have finally ran out of patience with Tippett.
Out Ballantyne 299,900
In Podsiadly 83,400
Cash 31,600 + 216,500
Total 216,500
Out Tippett 301,400
Total to spend 517,900
In Didak 503,400
End Result
Out Ballantyne and Tippett
In Didak and Podsiadly.
- Status
